- Foundation
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Returns to scale and the cost function
Distinguish constant, increasing and decreasing returns to scale, test them with f(tL, tK) and the Cobb-Douglas exponents, and explain the cost function as the least cost of each output.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define constant, increasing and decreasing returns to scale and distinguish them from the law of variable proportions.
- Test a production function for returns to scale, including the Cobb-Douglas rule on α + β.
- Explain why the cost function gives the least cost of producing each level of output.
The law of variable proportions describes what happens when one factor is fixed and the other varies, so factor proportions change. What happens when all factors change together? That can only happen in the long run. The special case in which all inputs are increased in the same proportion - the firm is scaled up - is studied as returns to scale.
Three kinds of returns to scale
Returns to scale (all inputs increased in the same proportion)
-
Constant returns to scale (CRS)
- Output rises in the same proportion
- Inputs doubled, output doubled
- f(tL, tK) = t·f(L, K)
-
Increasing returns to scale (IRS)
- Output rises in a larger proportion
- Inputs doubled, output more than doubled
- f(tL, tK) > t·f(L, K)
-
Decreasing returns to scale (DRS)
- Output rises in a smaller proportion
- Inputs doubled, output less than doubled
- f(tL, tK) < t·f(L, K)
| Basis | Law of variable proportions | Returns to scale |
|---|---|---|
| Period | Short run | Long run |
| Inputs changed | Only one; the other is fixed | All, in the same proportion |
| Factor proportions | Change | Stay the same |
| What is studied | Marginal product of the variable factor | Proportionate change in output |
Worked example 1: testing returns to scale with numbers (illustrative)
A made-up firm produces 40 units with 5 workers and 2 machines. Classify the returns to scale if, after doubling both inputs to 10 workers and 4 machines, output becomes (a) 80, (b) 95, (c) 70. Working: t = 2, so CRS needs 2 × 40 = 80. (a) 80 = 80: CRS. (b) 95 > 80: output more than doubles: IRS. (c) 70 < 80: output less than doubles: DRS.
The Cobb-Douglas production function
A widely used production function is the Cobb-Douglas form q = x1^α × x2^β, where x1 and x2 are the two inputs and α and β are constants. If both inputs are multiplied by t, the new output is (t·x1)^α × (t·x2)^β = t^(α+β) × x1^α × x2^β = t^(α+β) × q. So output is multiplied by t^(α+β).
Cobb-Douglas q = x1^α x2^β: α + β = 1 gives constant returns to scale; α + β > 1 gives increasing returns; α + β < 1 gives decreasing returns.
Worked example 2: Cobb-Douglas checks (illustrative)
(a) q = L^0.5 K^0.5 with L = 4 and K = 9: q = 2 × 3 = 6. Double both to L = 8, K = 18: q = √8 × √18 = √144 = 12 = 2 × 6. Output doubles: CRS, as α + β = 0.5 + 0.5 = 1 predicts. (b) q = L × K (α = β = 1, sum 2) with L = 2, K = 3: q = 6. Double both: q = 4 × 6 = 24 = 4 × 6. Output quadruples (t^2 = 4): IRS. (c) q = L^0.25 K^0.25 (sum 0.5) with L = 1, K = 16: q = 1 × 2 = 2. Multiply both by 4: L = 4, K = 64, q = (4 × 64)^0.25 = 256^0.25 = 4. Inputs ×4 but output only ×2 (= 4^0.5): DRS.
Costs and the cost function
To produce output, the firm must employ inputs and pay for them. A given output can usually be produced with more than one combination of inputs - in the production table of lesson 1, 30 units could come from (2 workers, 3 machines) or (3 workers, 2 machines). Which will the firm choose? With input prices given, it chooses the combination that is least expensive. The cost function therefore describes the least cost of producing each level of output, given the prices of factors of production and the technology.
Worked example 3: choosing the least-cost combination (illustrative)
A made-up firm can make 30 units with (2 workers, 3 machines) or (3 workers, 2 machines). A worker costs ₹500 a day and a machine ₹800 a day. Working: first combination = 2 × 500 + 3 × 800 = 1,000 + 2,400 = ₹3,400. Second = 3 × 500 + 2 × 800 = 1,500 + 1,600 = ₹3,100. The firm chooses (3 workers, 2 machines), and the cost function records ₹3,100 as the cost of 30 units. If instead a machine cost only ₹400, the costs would be 1,000 + 1,200 = ₹2,200 and 1,500 + 800 = ₹2,300, and the firm would switch to (2 workers, 3 machines) - the least-cost choice depends on input prices.
Building the cost function
- Desired output level For example 30 units
- All input combinations that can produce it Points on that isoquant
- Cost of each at given input prices Workers × wage + machines × rental
- Pick the cheapest This least cost is the value of the cost function at that output
Key takeaways: returns to scale describe how output responds when all inputs rise in the same proportion (long run): CRS same proportion, IRS more, DRS less. For Cobb-Douglas, output rises by t^(α+β), so α + β = 1, > 1 or < 1 gives CRS, IRS or DRS. The cost function gives the least cost of producing each output at given input prices and technology.
Check your understanding
-
1. All inputs are increased by 50 per cent and output rises by 30 per cent. The production function shows:
- Constant returns to scale
- Increasing returns to scale
- The law of variable proportions
- Decreasing returns to scale
Show answer
Answer: D. Output (30 per cent) rises by a smaller proportion than inputs (50 per cent), which is decreasing returns to scale.
-
2. For the Cobb-Douglas function q = L^0.6 K^0.6, returns to scale are:
- Increasing, since α + β = 1.2 > 1
- Constant, since each exponent is less than 1
- Decreasing, since each exponent is less than 1
- Impossible to tell
Show answer
Answer: A. What matters is the sum α + β = 0.6 + 0.6 = 1.2, which exceeds 1, so output rises by t^1.2, more than in proportion: increasing returns to scale.
-
3. Returns to scale are a long-run concept because:
- Prices change only in the long run
- Only labour can change in the long run
- All inputs can be varied only in the long run
- Output is fixed in the long run
Show answer
Answer: C. Returns to scale require all inputs to be increased in the same proportion, which is possible only when no factor is fixed - in the long run.
-
4. A made-up firm can make 100 units with (4 workers, 5 machines) or (6 workers, 3 machines). Wage = ₹400, machine rent = ₹600. What is the least cost of 100 units?
- ₹4,600
- ₹4,200
- ₹3,400
- ₹5,000
Show answer
Answer: B. First: 4 × 400 + 5 × 600 = 1,600 + 3,000 = ₹4,600. Second: 6 × 400 + 3 × 600 = 2,400 + 1,800 = ₹4,200. The least cost, which the cost function records, is ₹4,200.
-
5. Assertion (A): The law of variable proportions and returns to scale describe the same situation. Reason (R): Under returns to scale, factor proportions stay the same because all inputs change in the same proportion.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: D. A is false: the law of variable proportions is short run with one factor fixed, while returns to scale is long run with all factors varied. R is true and in fact shows why the two differ.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.