- Foundation
- About 20 min
- 5 practice questions
Shapes of short run cost curves and long run costs
Explain the shapes of the TFC, TVC, TC, AFC, AVC, SAC and SMC curves, why SMC cuts AVC and SAC at their minimum points, and how returns to scale shape the U-shaped LRAC and LRMC curves.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe the shapes of the short run cost curves and explain why SMC, AVC and SAC are U-shaped.
- Explain why SMC cuts AVC and SAC from below at their minimum points, and read costs as areas and slopes.
- Explain the U-shape of LRAC and LRMC using returns to scale.
Numbers in a cost schedule become much easier to remember as shapes. This lesson describes each cost curve in words (output on the horizontal axis, cost on the vertical axis) and explains why it looks the way it does, in the short run and the long run.
Total cost curves
TFC does not depend on output, so its curve is a horizontal straight line at the level of fixed cost. TVC starts at the origin (zero cost at zero output) and rises with output. TC has the same shape as TVC but starts at the level of TFC on the cost axis: it is TVC shifted up by TFC everywhere, i.e. the vertical sum of TFC and TVC.
The AFC curve
AFC = TFC/q, and TFC is constant, so AFC falls continuously as output rises: very large when output is near zero, approaching zero as output becomes very large, but never touching either axis. Since AFC × q always equals the same TFC, the AFC curve is a rectangular hyperbola: the rectangle formed under any point of it has the same area, equal to TFC. Equally, at any output, AFC equals the slope of a line from the origin to the corresponding point on the TFC line (the tangent of the angle it makes with the output axis).
Why SMC, AVC and SAC are U-shaped
SMC comes from the law of variable proportions. While the marginal product of the variable factor rises, each extra unit of output needs less and less of the factor, so with a given factor price SMC falls; once marginal product falls, each extra unit needs more of the factor and SMC rises. So the SMC curve is U-shaped. The area under the SMC curve up to any output equals TVC at that output.
AVC starts at the same point as SMC (for the first unit they are equal). It is the average of SMCs, so it falls while SMC is below it - even after SMC has started to rise - and rises once SMC climbs above it. So AVC is U-shaped and SMC cuts AVC from below at AVC's minimum point. TVC at any output equals the rectangle under the AVC curve (AVC × q), and AVC equals the slope of the line from the origin to the TVC curve.
SAC = AVC + AFC. At first both fall, so SAC falls. After AVC starts rising, AFC is still falling; for a while the fall in AFC outweighs the rise in AVC, so SAC keeps falling. Eventually the rise in AVC is larger, and SAC rises. So SAC is U-shaped, lies above AVC by the amount of AFC (a gap that narrows as output grows), and its minimum lies to the right of AVC's minimum. SMC cuts SAC from below at SAC's minimum point.
Average curves and the SMC curve
-
SMC below the average
- The average is falling
- Applies to AVC and to SAC
-
SMC equal to the average
- The average is at its minimum
- SMC crosses it here
-
SMC above the average
- The average is rising
- SMC has cut it from below
Worked example 1: reading the shapes from a schedule
Use the candle maker's schedule from the previous lesson (illustrative). Working: SMC falls 12, 8, 6, 4 and then rises 6, 9, 13, 18 - U-shaped. AVC falls 12, 10, 8.67, 7.5, 7.2 and then rises 7.5, 8.29, 9.5, so its minimum (₹7.2) is at 5 units; there SMC of the 5th unit is 6 (below 7.2) and of the 6th unit is 9 (above 7.5), so SMC crosses AVC between 5 and 6 units, from below. SAC falls to ₹12.5 at 6 units and then rises to 12.57 and 13.25; SMC of the 7th unit is 13, above SAC. SAC's minimum (6 units) is to the right of AVC's minimum (5 units), as the theory says.
Long run costs
In the long run all inputs are variable, so there are no fixed costs; total cost and total variable cost coincide. Long run average cost LRAC = TC/q. Long run marginal cost LRMC = TC at q units − TC at (q − 1) units. As in the short run, the sum of all LRMCs up to an output equals TC at that output.
The shape of LRAC depends on returns to scale. Under IRS, doubling output needs less than double the inputs, so cost less than doubles and average cost falls. Under CRS, average cost stays constant. Under DRS, cost more than doubles and average cost rises. A typical firm is thought to experience IRS at low output, then CRS, then DRS, so the LRAC curve is U-shaped: its falling part reflects IRS, its minimum point CRS, and its rising part DRS.
Returns to scale and the LRAC curve
- Increasing returns to scale LRAC falls
- Constant returns to scale LRAC at its minimum
- Decreasing returns to scale LRAC rises
LRMC equals LRAC for the first unit; while LRAC falls, LRMC is below it, and while LRAC rises, LRMC is above it. So LRMC is also U-shaped and cuts LRAC from below at LRAC's minimum point.
Marginal cost cuts average cost from below at the minimum point of the average: SMC cuts AVC and SAC, and LRMC cuts LRAC, at their lowest points.
Worked example 2: long run schedule (illustrative)
A made-up firm's long run TC for 1 to 6 units is ₹50, 80, 105, 140, 185, 240. Working: LRAC = TC/q: 50, 40, 35, 35, 37, 40. LRMC = ΔTC: 50, 30, 25, 35, 45, 55. Check the sum: 50 + 30 + 25 + 35 + 45 + 55 = 240 = TC at 6. LRAC falls up to 3 units (IRS), is flat at its minimum of ₹35 between 3 and 4 units (CRS), and rises after that (DRS). LRMC is below LRAC while it falls (30 < 40, 25 < 35), equals it at the minimum (35 = 35), and is above it afterwards (45 > 37, 55 > 40).
| Output | TC (₹) | LRAC (₹) | LRMC (₹) | Phase |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 50 | 50 | 50 | - |
| 2 | 80 | 40 | 30 | IRS |
| 3 | 105 | 35 | 25 | IRS |
| 4 | 140 | 35 | 35 | CRS |
| 5 | 185 | 37 | 45 | DRS |
| 6 | 240 | 40 | 55 | DRS |
Key takeaways: TFC is horizontal; TVC rises from the origin; TC is TVC lifted by TFC. AFC is a falling rectangular hyperbola. SMC is U-shaped because of the law of variable proportions; AVC and SAC are U-shaped and SMC cuts each from below at its minimum, SAC's minimum lying to the right of AVC's. In the long run there are no fixed costs; IRS, CRS and DRS make LRAC U-shaped, and LRMC cuts it from below at its minimum.
Check your understanding
-
1. The AFC curve is:
- U-shaped
- A horizontal straight line
- A rectangular hyperbola that falls continuously
- Upward sloping
Show answer
Answer: C. AFC × q always equals the constant TFC, so AFC keeps falling as output rises and its curve is a rectangular hyperbola.
-
2. The SMC curve is U-shaped mainly because of:
- The law of variable proportions
- Constant returns to scale
- A fall in fixed cost
- The law of demand
Show answer
Answer: A. As marginal product of the variable factor first rises and then falls, the extra input (and cost) needed for each extra unit first falls and then rises, making SMC U-shaped.
-
3. Where does the SMC curve cut the SAC curve?
- At the maximum point of SAC, from above
- Where SAC meets the AVC curve
- At zero output
- At the minimum point of SAC, from below
Show answer
Answer: D. While SAC falls, SMC is below it; while SAC rises, SMC is above it. So SMC crosses SAC from below exactly at SAC's minimum.
-
4. A made-up firm's long run TC for 1, 2 and 3 units is ₹60, 100 and 126. Which phase is it in between 1 and 3 units?
- Decreasing returns to scale, since LRAC rises
- Increasing returns to scale, since LRAC falls from 60 to 50 to 42
- Constant returns to scale, since LRAC is constant
- Cannot tell without fixed cost
Show answer
Answer: B. LRAC = 60/1 = 60, 100/2 = 50, 126/3 = 42. Falling LRAC corresponds to increasing returns to scale. (There are no fixed costs in the long run.)
-
5. Assertion (A): The minimum point of SAC lies to the right of the minimum point of AVC. Reason (R): After AVC starts rising, AFC continues to fall, so SAC keeps falling for a while.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true. Since SAC = AVC + AFC and AFC is still falling when AVC turns up, SAC goes on falling until the rise in AVC outweighs the fall in AFC, i.e. at a larger output. R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.