• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Jotedars, zamindars' resistance and the Fifth Report

Explain the rise and power of the jotedars, the strategies zamindars used to survive, and why the Fifth Report must be read critically.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain who the jotedars were and why they were powerful in rural Bengal.
  • Describe the zamindars' strategies of fictitious sale, benami purchase and physical resistance.
  • Explain why the Fifth Report was produced and why historians read it critically.

While many zamindars faced crisis at the end of the eighteenth century, a group of rich peasants was consolidating power in the villages. And the zamindars themselves did not simply collapse: new contexts produced new strategies.

The rise of the jotedars

Francis Buchanan's survey of Dinajpur in North Bengal vividly describes the jotedars. By the early nineteenth century they had acquired vast lands, sometimes several thousand acres, controlled local trade and moneylending, and held immense power over poorer cultivators. Much of their land was worked by sharecroppers (adhiyars or bargadars) who brought their own ploughs and handed over half the produce after the harvest.

Zamindar and jotedar in rural Bengal

  • Zamindar
    • Often lived in urban areas
    • Controlled numerous villages from a distance
    • Paid revenue to the Company and distributed the jama over villages
    • Faced auction if he defaulted
  • Jotedar
    • Lived in the village; direct control over poor villagers
    • A rich ryot, also trader and moneylender
    • Resisted zamindars' efforts to raise the village jama
    • Obstructed zamindari officials and mobilised dependent ryots
    • Delayed revenue payments; often bought auctioned estates

Buchanan noted that landlords disliked this class but could not do without them unless they lent money to needy tenants themselves; jotedars paid little, held more land than their deeds (pottahs) allowed, complained to the police station and the munsiff's court if zamindars' officers detained them, and encouraged petty ryots not to pay. Jotedars were most powerful in North Bengal; elsewhere similar figures were called haoladars, gantidars or mandals. Their rise weakened zamindari authority.

The zamindars resist

  1. Fictitious sale: the Raja of Burdwan first transferred part of his zamindari to his mother, since the Company had decreed that women's property would not be taken over. His agents then manipulated auctions: revenue was withheld, an estate was auctioned, his men outbid others but refused to pay, forcing a resale; this was repeated until other bidders and the state were exhausted and the estate went back cheaply to the zamindar.
  2. Benami purchases: between 1793 and 1801 four big zamindaris of Bengal, including Burdwan, made benami purchases that together yielded as much as Rs 30 lakh; over 15 per cent of total auction sales were fictitious. Benami means a transaction in the name of a fictitious or insignificant person, the real beneficiary staying unnamed.
  3. Force and loyalty: outside buyers could not always take possession; their agents were attacked by the former zamindar's lathyals (strongmen with sticks), and sometimes ryots themselves resisted outsiders, seeing their zamindar as an authority and themselves as his proja (subjects).

By the early nineteenth century the price depression ended; zamindars who had survived the 1790s consolidated power, and revenue rules became somewhat flexible, strengthening their hold over villages. Only in the Great Depression of the 1930s did they finally collapse, as jotedars consolidated power.

The Fifth Report

Submitted to the British Parliament in 1813, the Fifth Report was the fifth of a series on the East India Company's administration. It ran to 1002 pages, over 800 of them appendices: petitions of zamindars and ryots, collectors' reports, revenue statistics and officials' notes on Bengal and Madras. It was produced because the Company's rule was closely watched and debated in England: groups opposed the Company's trade monopoly with India and China, private traders wanted a share, British industrialists wanted Indian markets for their goods, and many argued that the conquest of Bengal benefited only the Company. Company greed and corruption were widely publicised, and Parliament passed Acts in the late eighteenth century to regulate the Company, forced it to report regularly, and set up enquiry committees. The Fifth Report, by a Select Committee, became the basis of intense parliamentary debate.

For over a century and a half it shaped ideas of rural Bengal, and its evidence is invaluable. But recent research in zamindars' archives and district records shows that, intent on criticising Company maladministration, it exaggerated the collapse of zamindari power and overestimated how much land zamindars lost; even when estates were auctioned, zamindars were not always displaced.

Worked example 1: reading the Fifth Report's figures

The Report gives (in sicca rupees of assessment): in 1796-97, land advertised for sale 28,70,061 and land actually sold 14,18,756; in 1797-98, advertised 26,66,191 and sold 22,74,076. Share actually sold: 1796-97 = 14,18,756 / 28,70,061, about 49 per cent; 1797-98 = 22,74,076 / 26,66,191, about 85 per cent. Caution: two years cannot support long-term generalisations, and 'sold' does not mean the zamindar lost control, since some sales were fictitious.

Worked example 2: why did ryots defend their zamindar?

Made-up case: an outside buyer purchases an estate at auction, but when his agent arrives, villagers refuse him entry. Explain using the book. Working: ryots felt bound to their zamindar by loyalty, saw him as a figure of authority and themselves as his proja; a sale disturbed their sense of identity and pride. Combined with lathyals' force, this made zamindars hard to displace.

Official reports such as the Fifth Report are invaluable, but they must be read with attention to who wrote them and why; the Fifth Report, aimed at criticising the Company, exaggerated the collapse of zamindari power.

— Key idea, in our own words

Key takeaways: jotedars, rich village-based peasants, traders and moneylenders using sharecroppers, undermined zamindars and often bought their estates. Zamindars survived through transfers to women, fictitious and benami purchases, lathyals and ryots' loyalty, and recovered after prices rose. The Fifth Report (1813, 1002 pages) arose from British debates on Company rule and overstated zamindars' decline.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Sharecroppers who cultivated jotedars' land and handed over half the produce were called:

    1. lathyals
    2. adhiyars or bargadars
    3. amlahs
    4. pahi-kashta
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Adhiyars or bargadars brought their own ploughs, laboured in the fields and gave half the produce to the jotedars after harvest.

  2. 2. Why did the Raja of Burdwan transfer part of his zamindari to his mother?

    1. Because she was a better manager
    2. To pay the Sunset Law fine
    3. Because Muslim law required it
    4. Because the Company had decreed that the property of women would not be taken over
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The book explains that the Company had decreed women's property would not be taken over, so transferring land to his mother protected it from auction.

  3. 3. Read this source (written for this lesson): 'He holds far more fields than his deed allows, pays a few rupees and falls behind every instalment; if our officers summon him, he runs to the police station and the munsiff's court, and tells the poorer tenants to stop paying.' Which group does this describe?

    1. Zamindars
    2. Santhals
    3. Jotedars
    4. Collectors
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Buchanan describes the jotedars of Dinajpur as refractory, holding more land than their pottahs allowed, complaining to the police and munsiff and instigating petty ryots not to pay.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): The Fifth Report exaggerated the collapse of traditional zamindari power. Reason (R): It was intent on criticising the maladministration of the East India Company.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Recent research shows that, intent on criticising Company maladministration, the Report exaggerated zamindars' collapse and overestimated land loss. R explains A.

  5. 5. When did the power of Bengal's zamindars finally collapse, according to the textbook?

    1. In the 1790s
    2. During the Great Depression of the 1930s
    3. After 1857
    4. In 1813
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Zamindars consolidated power after prices recovered in the early nineteenth century; only in the Great Depression of the 1930s did they collapse and jotedars consolidate their power.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery