- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
The hoe and the plough: Paharias, Santhals and Buchanan
Describe the Paharias' way of life and their conflict with expanding settled agriculture, the settlement of the Santhals in the Damin-i-Koh and their revolt, and how Buchanan's purposes shaped his accounts.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe the Paharias' livelihood, their relations with the plains and the British policies towards them.
- Explain how the Santhals were settled in the Damin-i-Koh, how this affected the Paharias, and why the Santhals rebelled.
- Evaluate Buchanan's accounts in the light of his position as a Company employee.
Moving from the wetlands of Bengal to drier hills, we see what happened when settled agriculture expanded into forests and pastures in the Rajmahal hills, creating conflicts that the textbook sums up as a battle between the hoe and the plough.
The Paharias
When Buchanan travelled through the hills early in the nineteenth century, people were hostile and fearful of officials, and often deserted their villages. Late-eighteenth-century revenue records call them Paharias. They practised shifting cultivation: clearing patches by cutting bushes and burning undergrowth, growing pulses and millets in soil enriched by potash from the ash, scratching the ground lightly with hoes, cultivating for a few years and then leaving land fallow to recover. From forests they collected mahua for food, silk cocoons and resin for sale and wood for charcoal; fallow and undergrowth gave pasture. They lived in tamarind groves, considered the whole region their land, and resisted outsiders. Their chiefs kept the group united, settled disputes and led battles.
Paharias regularly raided the plains: for survival in years of scarcity, to assert power over settled communities and to negotiate political relations. Plains zamindars often bought peace with regular tribute to hill chiefs, and traders paid a small amount to use passes the Paharias controlled, after which the chiefs protected them. This negotiated peace was fragile, and broke down in the last decades of the eighteenth century as settled agriculture was aggressively extended.
The British encouraged forest clearance, and zamindars and jotedars turned land into rice fields. To the British, settled agriculture meant more land revenue, export crops and a settled, ordered society; they associated forests with wildness and saw forest people as savage and hard to govern. As forests and pastures shrank, Paharia raids increased. In the 1770s the British pursued a brutal policy of extermination. In the 1780s Augustus Cleveland, Collector of Bhagalpur, proposed pacification: chiefs got an annual allowance and were made responsible for their men. Many refused; those who accepted usually lost authority, seen as stipendiary chiefs. The Paharias withdrew deep into the mountains, so in the winter of 1810-11 they viewed Buchanan with suspicion.
The Santhals: pioneer settlers
Near Ganjuria Pahar, Buchanan found land newly cleared by Santhals, who had moved in around 1800, displaced the hill folk on the lower slopes and settled. Santhals began coming into Bengal around the 1780s: zamindars hired them to reclaim land, and British officials, having failed to make the Paharias settled cultivators, invited them to settle in the Jangal Mahals. The Paharias refused to cut forests and resisted the plough; the Santhals seemed ideal settlers.
| Item | Figure |
|---|---|
| Demarcated as land of the Santhals | By 1832 |
| Condition of the grant | At least one-tenth of the area to be cleared and cultivated within the first ten years |
| Santhal villages | 40 in 1838; 1,473 by 1851 |
| Santhal population | About 3,000 to over 82,000 over the same period |
| Santhal Pargana after the revolt | 5,500 square miles carved from Bhagalpur and Birbhum |
The Damin was surveyed, mapped and enclosed with boundary pillars, separated from the plains and the Paharias' hills. Santhal myths and songs speak of a long history of travel; here the search for a home seemed to end. The Paharias, confined to the dry interior and barren upper hills, could not sustain shifting cultivation without fertile soils and suffered long-term impoverishment; their hunters lost forest. The Santhals settled, grew commercial crops and dealt with traders and moneylenders. But their land slipped away: the state levied heavy taxes, moneylenders (dikus) charged high interest and seized land, and zamindars asserted control over the Damin. By the 1850s they rebelled against zamindars, moneylenders and the colonial state; after the Santhal Revolt (1855-56), led among others by Sidhu Manjhi, the Santhal Pargana was created with special laws, in the hope of conciliating them. British images first showed Santhal villages as peaceful, then, after the rebellion, as places of violence, with burnt villages and prisoners displayed to the public in England.
The accounts of Buchanan
Francis Buchanan was a physician in the Bengal Medical Service (1794-1815), surgeon to Governor-General Wellesley for a time, organiser of what became the Calcutta Alipore Zoo, and surveyor of Company territories; he later took his mother's family name, Hamilton. He was a Company employee: he travelled with draughtsmen, surveyors and coolies at Company expense, had instructions on what to record, and was seen in villages as an agent of the sarkar. He obsessively recorded rocks, soils and commercially valuable minerals (iron ore, mica, granite, saltpetre), and described landscapes in terms of how they could be made more productive. His priorities were shaped by the Company's commercial concerns and Western notions of progress, so he was critical of forest dwellers' lifestyles and wanted forests turned into farmland.
Worked example 1: the growth of the Damin
Using the textbook's figures: villages rose from 40 (1838) to 1,473 (1851), an increase of 1,473 - 40 = 1,433, roughly 37 times the original number (1,473 / 40 = about 36.8). Population rose from about 3,000 to over 82,000, more than 27 times (82,000 / 3,000 = about 27.3). Meaning: rapid expansion of cultivation brought more revenue to the Company, but also pushed the Paharias into the barren hills.
Worked example 2: hoe versus plough
Compare the two livelihoods. Paharias (hoe): shifting cultivation, gathering, hunting, charcoal and silk; needed mobility and access to fresh fertile land. Santhals (plough): permanent fields, rice and cotton, commercial crops, dealings with traders. Once the lower slopes became the Damin, the Paharias lost the land their system needed, while the Santhals, though settled, fell into debt and lost land to dikus, so both suffered from the colonial order in different ways.
Damin-i-Koh: the area demarcated by 1832 as the land of the Santhals, enclosed by boundary pillars, where they were to practise plough agriculture as settled peasants.
Key takeaways: Paharias lived by shifting cultivation, forest produce and negotiated raids; the British moved from extermination (1770s) to pacification by allowances (Cleveland, 1780s). Santhals, invited as settlers, filled the Damin-i-Koh (40 villages in 1838 to 1,473 by 1851), pushing Paharias into barren hills. Heavy taxes, dikus and zamindars drove the Santhal Revolt of 1855-56, after which the Santhal Pargana was created. Buchanan's valuable accounts reflect Company commercial aims and Western ideas of progress.
Check your understanding
-
1. Who proposed a policy of pacification of the Paharias in the 1780s, giving chiefs annual allowances?
- Augustus Cleveland
- Charles Cornwallis
- Francis Buchanan
- William Hodges
Show answer
Answer: A. Augustus Cleveland, Collector of Bhagalpur, proposed pacification in the 1780s, after the brutal extermination policy of the 1770s.
-
2. By 1851 the number of Santhal villages in the Damin-i-Koh had risen to:
- 40
- 82,000
- 3,000
- 1,473
Show answer
Answer: D. From 40 villages in 1838, the number rose to 1,473 by 1851; the population rose from about 3,000 to over 82,000.
-
3. Read this source (written for this lesson): 'This valley would be glorious if the woods were cleared, the soil ploughed and the hills planted with trees for silkworms and lac; at present the people waste its riches.' Whose outlook, as described in the textbook, does this reflect?
- A Paharia chief
- Francis Buchanan
- A Santhal rebel
- A Deccan ryot
Show answer
Answer: B. Buchanan described landscapes in terms of how they could be transformed and made productive, shaped by Company commercial concerns and Western notions of progress.
-
4. Assertion (A): The Paharias were impoverished in the long term after the Santhals settled in the Damin-i-Koh. Reason (R): Shifting cultivation depended on moving to new fertile land, which became inaccessible to them.
- A is true, but R is false.
- Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A.
- Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
- A is false, but R is true.
Show answer
Answer: C. Confined to the dry interior and rocky upper hills, the Paharias could not sustain shifting cultivation without access to fertile soils; R explains A.
-
5. Which of these was a reason for the Santhal Revolt of 1855-56, according to the textbook?
- The Sunset Law
- Heavy taxes, high interest charged by dikus and zamindars asserting control over the Damin
- The cotton boom
- The Permanent Settlement in the Deccan
Show answer
Answer: B. The Santhals rebelled against heavy state taxes, moneylenders (dikus) who charged high interest and took land, and zamindars asserting control over the Damin.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.