- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
The experience of injustice and the Deccan Riots Commission
Explain why ryots felt moneylenders violated customary norms, how bonds, deeds and the Limitation Law worked against them, and why the Deccan Riots Commission's report must be read with care.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the customary norms of moneylending and how they broke down under colonial rule.
- Describe how bonds, deeds of hire and the Limitation Law of 1859 were used against ryots.
- Explain how the Deccan Riots Commission worked and why official sources must be read with care.
What enraged Deccan ryots was not only debt and dependence on moneylenders, but the moneylenders' insensitivity to their plight and violation of customary norms. Moneylending and powerful moneylenders existed before colonial rule, but the relationship had been governed by custom.
Custom and its breakdown
One general norm was that interest could not exceed the principal, which limited exactions and defined 'fair interest'. Under colonial rule this broke down: in one case investigated by the Deccan Riots Commission, a moneylender charged over Rs 2,000 as interest on a loan of Rs 100. Ryots complained in petition after petition of such injustice. One petition from Mirajgaon (Ahmednagar) complained that sahukars sold clothes and grain to debtors at prices 25 to 50 per cent above cash rates, took the harvest promising to credit it to their accounts but did not, and refused to give receipts.
Bonds, deeds and the law
How the Limitation Law was turned around
- Loan bond signed The ryot borrows on a written bond.
- Three years pass The 1859 Limitation Law made loan bonds valid for only three years, to check accumulation of interest.
- New bond forced The moneylender makes the ryot sign a new bond before the old one expires.
- Balance becomes principal The unpaid loan plus accumulated interest is entered as the new principal, and interest is charged on it again.
Then back to step 1: Loan bond signed
Moneylenders also refused receipts for repayments, entered fictitious figures in bonds, bought peasants' harvests at low prices and finally took over their property. When debts mounted, a peasant handed over land, carts and animals; to keep cultivating he then rented the land and hired the very animals that had been his, signing a deed of hire stating they did not belong to him, enforceable in court. One such deed of 1873 records a peasant 'selling' two carts and four bullocks to his creditor and hiring them back at Rs 4 a month.
In the past such deeds had been rare; transactions rested on informal understanding. The British distrusted this and insisted that terms be stated clearly in legally enforceable contracts, deeds and bonds. Peasants came to associate their misery with this new regime of bonds and deeds: they signed or put thumb impressions on documents without knowing the clauses, and feared the written word, but needed loans that moneylenders would give only on legal bonds.
The Deccan Riots Commission
The Government of Bombay at first did not treat the revolt as serious, but the Government of India, worried by the memory of 1857, pressed it to set up a commission of enquiry. Its report was presented to the British Parliament in 1878. The commission held enquiries in affected districts, recorded statements of ryots, sahukars and eyewitnesses, compiled statistics on revenue rates, prices and interest rates, and collated collectors' reports.
It was specifically asked to judge whether government revenue demand caused the revolt, and it concluded that the demand was not the cause; moneylenders were to blame. The textbook notes that this argument appears very frequently in colonial records, showing a persistent reluctance to admit that popular discontent ever arose from government action. Official reports are invaluable but must be read with care and set beside newspapers, unofficial accounts, legal records and, where possible, oral sources.
| Source | Value | Caution |
|---|---|---|
| Fifth Report (1813) | Petitions, collectors' reports, revenue statistics | Aimed to criticise the Company; exaggerated zamindars' collapse |
| Buchanan's surveys | Detailed observation of land, people, minerals | Company employee with commercial aims and Western ideas of progress |
| Deccan Riots Report (1878) | Statements of ryots, sahukars and witnesses; price and interest data | Asked to judge revenue demand; blamed moneylenders, not government |
Worked example 1: the customary limit on interest
Under the customary norm, on a loan of Rs 100 the total interest could not exceed Rs 100, so the most a borrower could owe was Rs 100 + Rs 100 = Rs 200. In the Commission's case the interest charged was over Rs 2,000, more than 20 times the principal (2,000 / 100 = 20) and more than ten times the customary maximum total. Ryots saw this as a violation of custom, not just a high price.
Worked example 2: re-signing a bond (illustrative figures)
Made-up case: a ryot borrows Rs 100 at simple interest of 25 per cent a year and repays nothing. After 3 years, interest = 100 x 25/100 x 3 = Rs 75, so he owes Rs 175. A new bond makes Rs 175 the principal. After 3 more years, interest = 175 x 25/100 x 3 = Rs 131.25, total Rs 306.25. Without re-signing, after 6 years at simple interest he would owe 100 + 150 = Rs 250. Re-signing turned interest into principal and raised the debt by Rs 56.25 in this example.
The Deccan Riots Commission concluded that moneylenders, not government revenue demand, caused the revolt; the textbook reads this as part of a persistent colonial reluctance to blame government action.
Key takeaways: ryots resented moneylenders for breaking customary norms such as interest not exceeding principal. The 1859 Limitation Law was turned around through repeated bonds; deeds of hire made peasants rent their own animals. Peasants came to fear the written regime of bonds and deeds. The Deccan Riots Commission (report to Parliament in 1878) blamed moneylenders, reflecting official concerns, so its evidence must be checked against other sources.
Check your understanding
-
1. The Limitation Law of 1859 stated that loan bonds between moneylenders and ryots would be valid for:
- three years
- one year
- ten years
- thirty years
Show answer
Answer: A. The law made bonds valid for three years to check accumulation of interest, but moneylenders forced ryots to sign new bonds every three years.
-
2. Which customary norm of moneylending broke down under colonial rule?
- Loans could be given only in grain
- Loans had to be approved by the zamindar
- Moneylenders had to be Brahmanas
- Interest could not be more than the principal
Show answer
Answer: D. A general norm was that interest could not exceed the principal; under colonial rule it broke down, as in a case of over Rs 2,000 interest on Rs 100.
-
3. Read this source (written for this lesson): 'I give to you, for my debt, my plough-bullocks and my cart, and I take the same bullocks and cart from you on hire at a monthly rent, and shall not claim that I paid without your written receipt.' What kind of document does this resemble?
- A pottah
- A deed of hire
- A sanad
- A farman
Show answer
Answer: B. Indebted peasants handed over their animals and carts and then hired them back, signing a deed of hire stating they did not belong to them, enforceable in court.
-
4. Assertion (A): The Deccan Riots Commission concluded that the government revenue demand was not the cause of the revolt. Reason (R): There was a persistent reluctance in colonial records to admit that popular discontent arose from government action.
- A is true, but R is false.
- A is false, but R is true.
- Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
- Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A.
Show answer
Answer: C. The book links the Commission's conclusion that moneylenders were to blame to a persistent colonial reluctance to blame government action. R explains A.
-
5. What does the textbook advise about using official reports such as the Deccan Riots Report?
- Accept them as complete and neutral
- Ignore them entirely
- Use only their statistics
- Read them with care and juxtapose them with newspapers, unofficial accounts, legal records and oral sources
Show answer
Answer: D. Official reports are invaluable but reflect official concerns; they must be read carefully alongside other evidence.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.