• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Revolt in the Bombay Deccan: ryotwari, debt and the cotton boom

Describe the 1875 Deccan revolt, explain the ryotwari settlement and Ricardian ideas behind it, and trace how high revenue, famine, the cotton boom and its end deepened peasant debt.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe the events of the 1875 revolt beginning at Supa and its spread.
  • Explain why the Permanent Settlement was not extended and how the ryotwari settlement worked.
  • Trace how revenue demand, price falls, famine and the cotton boom and bust made peasants dependent on moneylenders.

Revolts reveal peasants' anger and experiences otherwise hidden, and they produce records, because states investigate causes in order to restore peace. Through the nineteenth century peasants in many parts of India rose against moneylenders and grain dealers. One such revolt came in 1875 in the Deccan.

Account books are burnt

The movement began at Supa, a large market village in Poona district where many shopkeepers and moneylenders lived. On 12 May 1875, ryots from surrounding areas attacked the shopkeepers, demanding their bahi khatas (account books) and debt bonds, burnt the khatas, looted grain shops and sometimes set fire to the houses of sahukars (people who were both moneylenders and traders). The revolt spread to Ahmednagar and over two months across 6,500 square km, affecting more than thirty villages, always with the same pattern; terrified sahukars fled. British officials saw the spectre of 1857: police posts were set up, troops called in, 951 people arrested and many convicted, yet it took months to restore control. A newspaper report of the time described ryots posting spies at village boundaries to warn of approaching officials.

A new revenue system

The Permanent Settlement was rarely extended beyond Bengal. One reason: after 1810 agricultural prices rose, increasing Bengal zamindars' incomes, but the state could claim none of it because the demand was fixed. Keen to maximise revenue, the government made temporary settlements in territories annexed in the nineteenth century. Another reason was economic theory: officials had learnt the ideas of the economist David Ricardo, a celebrated figure by the 1820s.

Ricardian reasoning, as officials applied it

  1. Average rent A landowner should claim only the average rent prevailing at the time.
  2. Surplus Any yield above that average was a surplus that the state should tax.
  3. Danger of no tax Untaxed, cultivators would become rentiers (living on rental income) and not invest in improving land.
  4. Bengal as proof Officials thought Bengal's zamindars had become rentiers, so a different system was needed.

The ryotwari settlement in the Bombay Deccan settled revenue directly with the ryot. The average income from different soils was estimated, the ryot's capacity to pay assessed, and a proportion fixed as the state's share. Lands were resurveyed every 30 years and rates raised, so the demand was no longer permanent.

Revenue demand and peasant debt

  1. 1820s: the first settlement demanded so much that in many places peasants deserted villages, especially where soil was poor and rain uncertain. Collectors, eager to show efficiency, extracted payment severely, seizing crops and fining whole villages.
  2. 1830s: prices fell sharply after 1832 and did not recover for over fifteen years; the famine of 1832-34 killed one-third of the Deccan's cattle and half the human population. Unpaid revenue mounted.
  3. Borrowing: revenue could rarely be paid without a moneylender's loan; once borrowed, loans were hard to repay, and peasants needed loans even for daily needs and production. By the 1840s officials found alarming indebtedness everywhere.
  4. Mid-1840s: officials admitted the 1820s settlements had been harsh; demand was moderated. After 1845 prices recovered and cultivation expanded, but more ploughs, cattle, seed and land again meant loans.

The cotton boom and its end

Before the 1860s, three-fourths of Britain's raw cotton imports came from America. Worried manufacturers founded the Cotton Supply Association (1857) and the Manchester Cotton Company (1859); India, with suitable soil, climate and cheap labour, was seen as an alternative. When the American Civil War broke out in 1861, American imports fell from over 2,000,000 bales (of 400 lbs) in 1861 to 55,000 bales in 1862. Bombay export merchants advanced money to urban sahukars, who lent to rural moneylenders promising produce. Deccan ryots found seemingly limitless credit, about Rs 100 as advance for every acre under cotton. Between 1860 and 1864 cotton acreage doubled, and by 1862 over 90 per cent of Britain's cotton imports came from India. Some rich peasants gained, but for most, cotton expansion meant heavier debt.

By 1865 the dream was over: American production revived and Indian exports declined. Merchants and sahukars stopped long-term credit and demanded repayment. At the same time the next revenue settlement raised the demand dramatically, by 50 to 100 per cent. With prices falling and cotton fields disappearing, ryots turned to moneylenders, who now refused loans, doubting their capacity to repay.

Worked example 1: how big was the cotton shock?

Using the textbook's figures: 55,000 / 2,000,000 = 0.0275, that is 2.75 per cent of the 1861 level, which matches the book's statement that imports fell to less than three per cent of normal. Each bale was 400 lbs, so 2,000,000 bales = 800,000,000 lbs; the shortfall explains Britain's frantic search for Indian cotton.

Worked example 2: permanent versus ryotwari

Compare. Permanent Settlement (Bengal, 1793): with zamindars; fixed for ever; state lost future gains. Ryotwari (Bombay Deccan, from the 1820s): directly with ryots; based on soil and capacity to pay; resurveyed every 30 years with higher rates. Consequence in the Deccan: when the 1860s resettlement raised demand by 50-100 per cent just as credit vanished, ryots had nowhere to turn.

Ryotwari settlement: revenue fixed directly with the ryot according to estimated soil income and capacity to pay, and revised upward at resurveys every 30 years.

— Definition, in our own words

Key takeaways: in May 1875 ryots at Supa burnt sahukars' account books; the revolt spread over 6,500 square km, and 951 were arrested. The ryotwari system, shaped by Ricardian ideas and the state's wish to share rising incomes, was settled with ryots and revised every 30 years. High demand in the 1820s, price falls after 1832 and the 1832-34 famine drove peasants into debt. The cotton boom (1861-65) gave easy credit; its end, plus a 50-100 per cent rise in demand, left ryots without loans.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Where did the Deccan revolt of 1875 begin?

    1. Ahmednagar
    2. Burdwan
    3. Supa, in Poona district
    4. Bhagalpur
    Show answer

    Answer: C. It began at Supa, a large market village in Poona district, on 12 May 1875, and then spread to Ahmednagar and beyond.

  2. 2. Under the ryotwari settlement in the Bombay Deccan:

    1. revenue was fixed permanently with zamindars
    2. no revenue was charged on cotton
    3. revenue was collected only in kind by jotedars
    4. revenue was settled directly with the ryot and lands were resurveyed every 30 years
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Revenue was settled directly with the ryot based on estimated soil income and capacity to pay; lands were resurveyed every 30 years and rates raised.

  3. 3. Read this source (written for this lesson): 'Last year the agent gave me a hundred rupees for every acre I sowed with cotton; this year, with the war overseas ended, he will not lend me even for seed, and the tax has gone up.' Which sequence of events does this reflect?

    1. The cotton boom during the American Civil War and the drying up of credit after 1865
    2. The Permanent Settlement and the Sunset Law
    3. The 1832-34 famine
    4. The Santhal settlement in the Damin-i-Koh
    Show answer

    Answer: A. During the boom ryots received about Rs 100 per acre of cotton as advance; after the Civil War ended, merchants and sahukars stopped credit while the new settlement raised revenue.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): The Permanent Settlement was rarely extended to regions beyond Bengal. Reason (R): After 1810 agricultural prices rose, but the state could not claim a share of the increased income because the demand was fixed.

    1. Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A.
    2. Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The book gives this as one reason: wanting to maximise revenue, the government made temporary settlements elsewhere. R explains A.

  5. 5. According to Ricardian ideas held by British officials, what would happen if the surplus above 'average rent' was not taxed?

    1. Cultivators would become rentiers and not invest productively in improving land
    2. Cultivators would invest heavily in land
    3. Prices would fall
    4. Moneylenders would disappear
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Officials believed untaxed surplus would turn cultivators into rentiers living on rent rather than improving land, as they thought had happened with Bengal's zamindars.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery