- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
The Permanent Settlement and the problem of unpaid revenue
Explain the auction of the Burdwan estates, the aims and terms of the Permanent Settlement of 1793, and the four reasons why zamindars defaulted on revenue payments.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe the 1797 Burdwan auction and what it reveals.
- Explain why the British introduced the Permanent Settlement and how the zamindar was defined under it.
- Explain the four reasons the textbook gives for zamindars' failure to pay revenue, and the problem of rent collection.
This chapter shows what colonial rule meant in the countryside: the zamindars of Bengal, the Paharias and Santhals of the Rajmahal hills, and peasants of the Deccan. Laws decided who grew richer or poorer and who gained or lost land, but people also resisted laws by acting on what they thought just, and so shaped how laws worked. The chapter also examines its sources: revenue records, surveys, travellers' journals and reports of enquiry commissions.
An auction in Burdwan
Colonial rule was first established in Bengal, where the earliest attempts were made to reorder rural society and land rights. In 1797, several mahals (estates) of the Raja of Burdwan (present-day Bardhaman) were auctioned, because the Permanent Settlement, in operation since 1793, had fixed each zamindar's revenue, and the estates of defaulters were to be sold. The raja had huge arrears. But the Collector found that many purchasers were the raja's own servants and agents: over 95 per cent of the sale was fictitious. The estates were sold publicly, yet the raja kept control. Burdwan was not alone: over 75 per cent of zamindaris changed hands after the Permanent Settlement.
Why the Permanent Settlement?
By the 1770s Bengal's rural economy was in crisis, with recurrent famines and declining output. Officials believed agriculture, trade and revenue could all grow by encouraging investment in agriculture, which required secure property rights and a permanently fixed revenue demand. With a fixed demand, the Company would get a regular flow of revenue, and entrepreneurs would invest knowing the state would not take their profits by raising its claim. Officials hoped a class of yeomen farmers and rich landowners would emerge with capital and enterprise to improve farming, and, nurtured by the British, would be loyal to the Company.
After long debate, the settlement was made with the rajas and taluqdars of Bengal (a taluqdar is 'one who holds a taluq', a connection that came to mean a territorial unit), now classified as zamindars. Under this definition the zamindar was not a landowner in the village but a revenue collector of the state. A zamindar might have many villages (sometimes as many as 400), which together formed one revenue estate. The Company fixed the total demand; the zamindar collected rent from the villages, paid the revenue and kept the difference, and if he failed to pay, his estate could be auctioned. Charles Cornwallis was Governor General when the settlement was introduced in 1793.
How revenue flowed under the Permanent Settlement
- Ryots and under-ryots Ryots paid rent to the zamindar; many leased part of their land to under-ryots, who paid rent to them.
- Zamindar Collected rent from the villages of his estate through officers such as the amlah.
- Company Received the fixed revenue; the zamindar kept the difference as income.
- Default If payment failed, the estate could be auctioned.
Why zamindars defaulted
| Reason | Explanation |
|---|---|
| 1. Very high initial demand | Since the demand was fixed for ever, the Company could never share in future rises; to reduce this loss it pegged the demand high, arguing the burden would ease as production and prices rose |
| 2. Depressed prices | The high demand was imposed in the 1790s when prices of produce were low, so ryots struggled to pay the zamindar, and the zamindar the Company |
| 3. Invariable demand and the Sunset Law | Revenue was fixed regardless of the harvest and had to be paid punctually; if it did not arrive by sunset of the due date, the zamindari could be auctioned |
| 4. Limits on zamindars' power | Their troops were disbanded, customs duties abolished, and their cutcheries (courts) put under a Company Collector; they lost control of local justice and police, and the collectorate became a rival centre of authority |
Rent collection was a perennial problem. An officer of the zamindar, usually the amlah, came to the village to collect. Bad harvests and low prices made payment hard, and sometimes ryots deliberately delayed payment. Rich ryots and village headmen, the jotedars and mandals, were happy to see the zamindar in trouble. Zamindars could prosecute defaulters, but cases were slow: in Burdwan alone there were over 30,000 pending suits for arrears of rent in 1798. In British records, the term ryot is the spelling of raiyat; ryots in Bengal did not always cultivate directly but leased land to under-ryots.
Worked example 1: why a fixed demand was pegged high
Illustrative figures (made up): suppose an estate's rent income could grow from Rs 10,000 to Rs 15,000 over thirty years as prices and cultivation rose. If revenue is fixed for ever at Rs 6,000, the Company gains nothing from the extra Rs 5,000. To limit this anticipated loss, it might set the demand at, say, Rs 9,000 from the start. Result: at today's income of Rs 10,000, the zamindar keeps only Rs 1,000, and in a bad year cannot pay at all. This is the logic, and the danger, the book describes.
Worked example 2: reading the Burdwan auction
What does a 95 per cent fictitious sale tell us? Step 1: the law said defaulters' estates must be sold. Step 2: the raja's agents bought them, so ownership did not really change. Step 3: so official records of 'sales' may overstate how many zamindars actually lost control. Lesson: laws had consequences, but people bent them; historians must look behind official figures.
Under the Permanent Settlement (1793), the zamindar was defined not as a landowner in the village but as a collector of revenue for the state, paying a demand fixed in perpetuity or losing his estate at auction.
Key takeaways: the 1797 Burdwan auction was over 95 per cent fictitious; over 75 per cent of zamindaris changed hands after 1793. The Permanent Settlement aimed at regular revenue, investment and a loyal landed class, and treated zamindars as revenue collectors. They defaulted because demand was high, prices low, payment rigid (Sunset Law) and their powers curtailed, while ryots and jotedars delayed rent.
Check your understanding
-
1. The Permanent Settlement came into operation in Bengal in:
- 1765
- 1773
- 1793
- 1813
Show answer
Answer: C. It came into operation in 1793, under Governor General Cornwallis. 1765 was the Diwani, 1773 the Regulating Act and 1813 the Fifth Report.
-
2. Under the Permanent Settlement, a zamindar was defined as:
- a landowner who cultivated the village land himself
- a revenue collector of the state who paid a fixed demand for his estate
- a village headman chosen by elders
- a Company judge
Show answer
Answer: B. The book says that in terms of this definition the zamindar was not a landowner in the village but a revenue collector of the state.
-
3. Read this source (written for this lesson): 'The instalment due today was delayed by floods on the river road; the messenger reached the Collector's office an hour after dusk. By evening the estate was listed for auction.' Which rule does this illustrate?
- The Sunset Law
- The Limitation Law
- The Regulating Act
- The ryotwari settlement
Show answer
Answer: A. Under the Sunset Law, if payment did not come in by sunset of the specified date, the zamindari was liable to be auctioned.
-
4. Assertion (A): The Company fixed the initial revenue demand very high. Reason (R): Since the demand was fixed for all time, the Company would not be able to share in increased income from land when prices rose.
- A is true, but R is false.
- Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A.
- A is false, but R is true.
- Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
Show answer
Answer: D. The book explains that to minimise the anticipated loss from a permanently fixed demand, the Company pegged it high. R explains A.
-
5. Which of these was NOT one of the ways the Company restricted zamindars' power?
- Disbanding their troops
- Abolishing customs duties
- Bringing their cutcheries under a Collector
- Giving them control of the local police
Show answer
Answer: D. Zamindars lost their power to organise local justice and the local police; their troops were disbanded, customs duties abolished and cutcheries supervised by the Collector.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.