- Foundation
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Conflicts: India and Pakistan, and India and its other neighbours
Describe the India-Pakistan disputes and India's relations with Bangladesh, Nepal, Sri Lanka, Bhutan and the Maldives exactly as the textbook frames them, including each side's stated concerns.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- List the issues in India-Pakistan relations that the textbook identifies.
- State the areas of disagreement and cooperation between India and each of its other neighbours, as the textbook gives them.
- Explain why, in the textbook's analysis, most conflicts in the region involve India.
Beyond domestic politics, South Asia has conflicts of an international nature. Given India's position, the textbook notes, most of them involve India. This chapter deals with neighbouring countries and disputes. The lessons follow the textbook's own framing and attribute claims and views to it or to the governments it names; they do not add later events.
India and Pakistan
The textbook calls the India-Pakistan conflict the most salient in the region. Soon after partition, the two countries were embroiled in a conflict over Kashmir; the textbook says the Pakistani government claimed that Kashmir belonged to it. Wars in 1947-48 and 1965 did not settle the matter. In the textbook's words, the 1947-48 war resulted in the division of the province into Pakistan-occupied Kashmir and the Indian province of Jammu and Kashmir, divided by the Line of Control. In 1971 India won a decisive war, but the Kashmir issue remained unsettled.
| Issue | As the textbook presents it |
|---|---|
| Kashmir | Wars in 1947-48 and 1965; the Line of Control; issue unsettled after 1971 |
| Siachen glacier and arms | Strategic disputes over the glacier and over acquisition of arms |
| Nuclear weapons | India's tests at Pokhran in 1998; Pakistan's tests in the Chagai Hills within days. The book says the chance of a full-scale war has since declined, but suspicion remains |
| Allegations of support to militants | The Indian government has blamed Pakistan for aiding militants in Kashmir and, during 1985-1995, pro-Khalistani militants; Pakistan's ISI is alleged to be involved in anti-India campaigns in the northeast. The Pakistani government in turn blames India for fomenting trouble in Sindh and Balochistan |
| River waters | The Indus Waters Treaty, signed in 1960 with World Bank help, has survived several military conflicts; minor differences of interpretation remain |
| Sir Creek | Disagreement over the demarcation line in the Rann of Kutch, with a worry about control of sea resources nearby |
The textbook notes that the two countries are holding negotiations on all these issues.
India and Bangladesh
India and Bangladesh: each government's concerns, as the textbook lists them
-
Concerns of the Indian government
- Bangladesh's denial of illegal immigration to India
- Support for anti-Indian Islamic fundamentalist groups
- Refusal to let Indian troops pass to northeastern India
- Decision not to export natural gas to India
-
Concerns of Bangladeshi governments
- India acting like a regional bully over river waters
- Encouraging rebellion in the Chittagong Hill Tracts
- Trying to extract its natural gas
- Being unfair in trade
-
Cooperation
- Economic relations improved over 20 years
- Part of India's Look East / Act East policy
- Disaster management and environment
- Exchange of enclaves in 2015
Other differences named include sharing the Ganga and Brahmaputra waters and a long-unresolved boundary dispute; the textbook's timeline records the Farakka Treaty (1996) on sharing Ganga waters.
India and Nepal
- A treaty lets citizens of each country travel to and work in the other without visas and passports, a relationship the book says has few parallels in the world.
- Indian concerns (as the book states): Nepal's warm relations with China, inaction against anti-Indian elements, and security agencies' view of the Maoist movement as a threat given Naxalite groups in India.
- Nepali concerns (as the book states): that India interferes in its internal affairs, has designs on its river waters and hydroelectricity, and limits landlocked Nepal's easier access to the sea through Indian territory.
- Nevertheless relations are described as fairly stable: trade, scientific cooperation, shared natural resources, electricity generation and water management grids hold them together.
India and Sri Lanka, Bhutan and the Maldives
- Sri Lanka: difficulties have mostly been over the ethnic conflict; after 1987 India prefers disengagement from Sri Lanka's internal troubles. A free trade agreement (signed December 1998) and India's help in post-tsunami reconstruction have brought them closer.
- Bhutan: a very special relationship with no major conflict; the Bhutanese monarch's efforts to remove militants from northeastern India operating in Bhutan helped India; India is involved in big hydroelectric projects and is Bhutan's biggest source of development aid.
- The Maldives: warm and cordial ties; in November 1988, when Tamil mercenaries from Sri Lanka attacked the Maldives, the Indian air force and navy responded quickly to the Maldives' request; India has also helped its economy, tourism and fisheries.
Why most conflicts involve India
The textbook explains that, given India's size and power, smaller neighbours are bound to be suspicious of its intentions and fear it wants to be regionally dominant, while the Indian government often feels exploited by them and dislikes political instability that could let outside powers gain influence. Geography matters too: India is centrally located and is the only country that borders the others. Not all conflicts involve India, though: the book mentions differences between Nepal and Bhutan over the migration of ethnic Nepalese into Bhutan, between Bangladesh and Myanmar over the Rohingyas, and between Bangladesh and Nepal over Himalayan river waters.
Much of South Asia's conflict runs through India partly because of geography: India sits at the centre and is the only country bordering all the others.
Worked example 1: two-sided analysis
Question: A made-up debate team must present the India-Bangladesh relationship fairly in one minute. What should they include? Model answer: Cooperation: (1) improved economic relations and Bangladesh's place in India's Look East / Act East policy; (2) regular cooperation on disaster management and environmental issues (also, the 2015 exchange of enclaves). Disagreement: (1) sharing of Ganga and Brahmaputra waters; (2) migration, which the Indian government calls illegal immigration and says Bangladesh denies. Tip: in such answers, attribute each complaint to the government that makes it, as the textbook does.
Worked example 2: identifying the treaty
Question: Which India-Pakistan agreement, signed with World Bank help, has survived several military conflicts? Reasoning: the chapter names only one water agreement between the two, signed in 1960 after a fierce argument over the Indus basin rivers. Answer: the Indus Waters Treaty (1960).
Key takeaways: the textbook lists India-Pakistan issues as Kashmir, Siachen and arms, nuclear weapons, mutual allegations about support to militants, river waters (the 1960 Indus Waters Treaty) and Sir Creek. With Bangladesh and Nepal there are differences voiced by both sides, alongside real cooperation; ties with Sri Lanka improved through trade and post-tsunami help; Bhutan and the Maldives are close partners. India's size and central location explain why most conflicts involve it.
Check your understanding
-
1. The Indus Waters Treaty between India and Pakistan was signed in 1960 with the help of:
- the United Nations Security Council
- SAARC
- the World Bank
- the Soviet Union
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter says that in 1960, with the help of the World Bank, India and Pakistan signed the Indus Waters Treaty, which has survived several military conflicts.
-
2. Sir Creek, mentioned in the chapter, is located in the:
- Rann of Kutch
- Siachen glacier region
- Chittagong Hill Tracts
- Chagai Hills
Show answer
Answer: A. The textbook says India and Pakistan disagree over the demarcation line in Sir Creek in the Rann of Kutch, with implications for sea resources nearby.
-
3. Which arrangement between India and Nepal does the textbook describe as having few parallels in the world?
- A common currency
- A shared parliament
- A joint army
- Travel and work in each other's country without visas and passports
Show answer
Answer: D. A treaty allows citizens of the two countries to travel to and work in the other country without visas and passports.
-
4. In November 1988, India's air force and navy responded to a request from which country to stop an attack by mercenaries?
- Sri Lanka
- the Maldives
- Bhutan
- Bangladesh
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter says that when Tamil mercenaries from Sri Lanka attacked the Maldives in November 1988, India responded quickly to the Maldives' request.
-
5. Assertion (A): Most of the major conflicts in South Asia involve India. Reason (R): India is centrally located and is the only country in the region that borders the others.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: the textbook says major conflicts are between India and the others partly because of geography, as India borders all of them.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.