• Foundation
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Military and democracy in Pakistan; democracy in Bangladesh

Trace the alternation of military and civilian rule in Pakistan and the reasons the textbook gives for it, and follow Bangladesh from the struggle against West Pakistani domination to multi-party democracy.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Outline the sequence of military and civilian governments in Pakistan as given in the textbook.
  • Explain the factors the textbook gives for Pakistan's difficulty in building a stable democracy.
  • Describe the creation of Bangladesh and its path to democracy after 1991.

The textbook examines democracy in each of the four big countries of the region other than India. This lesson takes Pakistan and Bangladesh, which were one country from 1947 to 1971 and have both experienced civilian and military rule.

Pakistan: alternating rule

Pakistan's political history in the textbook

  1. General Ayub Khan Took over after the first constitution; later gave up office amid popular dissatisfaction
  2. General Yahya Khan Military rule; the Bangladesh crisis and the 1971 war
  3. Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, 1971-77 Elected government
  4. General Zia-ul-Haq, from 1977 Removed Bhutto; faced a pro-democracy movement from 1982
  5. Elective democracy, 1988-99 Benazir Bhutto first; competition between the Pakistan People's Party and the Muslim League
  6. General Pervez Musharraf, 1999 Removed Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif; got himself elected President in 2001
  7. Since 2008 Democratically elected leaders

Why stable democracy proved difficult in Pakistan

  • Social dominance of the military, the clergy and the landowning aristocracy led to frequent overthrow of elected governments.
  • Conflict with India made pro-military groups more powerful; they argued that parties and democracy were flawed, that 'chaotic' democracy would harm security, and that army rule was therefore justified.
  • Lack of genuine international support for democracy: the textbook says the US and other Western countries encouraged military rule in the past for their own reasons, including fears about what they call 'global Islamic terrorism' and about the safety of Pakistan's nuclear arsenal, seeing the military regime as a protector of Western interests.

At the same time, the textbook stresses that there has been a strong pro-democracy sentiment in Pakistan, a courageous and relatively free press and a strong human rights movement.

Bangladesh: from East Pakistan to independence

Bangladesh was part of Pakistan from 1947 to 1971, made up of the partitioned areas of Bengal and Assam from British India. Its people resented the domination of western Pakistan and the imposition of Urdu, protested against unfair treatment of Bengali culture and language, and demanded fair representation in administration and a fair share of political power. Sheikh Mujib-ur Rahman led the struggle and demanded autonomy for the eastern region.

  • In the 1970 elections, the Awami League led by Sheikh Mujib won all the seats in East Pakistan and a majority in the proposed constituent assembly for all of Pakistan; the West Pakistan-dominated government refused to convene the assembly and Sheikh Mujib was arrested.
  • Under General Yahya Khan, the Pakistani army tried to suppress the mass movement; the textbook says thousands were killed, causing large-scale migration and a huge refugee problem for India.
  • India supported the demand for independence and helped financially and militarily, leading to a war in December 1971 that ended with the surrender of Pakistani forces in East Pakistan and the formation of Bangladesh.

Democracy in Bangladesh

  • Bangladesh's constitution declared faith in secularism, democracy and socialism.
  • In 1975 Sheikh Mujib amended it to shift from a parliamentary to a presidential form and abolished all parties except the Awami League; he was assassinated in a military uprising in August 1975.
  • Military ruler Ziaur Rahman formed the Bangladesh National Party and won elections in 1979; after his assassination, Lt Gen H. M. Ershad took over.
  • People, with students in the forefront, demanded democracy; mass protests made Ershad step down in 1990.
  • Elections were held in 1991; since then representative democracy based on multi-party elections has been working.

Democratic experience: Pakistan and Bangladesh

  • Common features
    • Both had civilian and military rulers
    • Military takeovers interrupted elected rule
    • Strong popular pro-democracy movements
  • Pakistan
    • Military dominance backed by clergy and landed elite
    • Conflict with India strengthened the military
    • Elected leaders again since 2008
  • Bangladesh
    • Born from a struggle against domination, 1971
    • Students led protests that ended military rule in 1990
    • Multi-party democracy since 1991

In both Pakistan and Bangladesh, democracy has been interrupted by the military, yet in both, popular movements kept pressing for elected government.

— Key idea in our words

Worked example 1: commonalities and differences

Question: A made-up student writes: 'Pakistan and Bangladesh have had exactly the same political history.' Use the chapter to correct this. Step 1, common ground: both have had civilian and military rulers, and both have seen strong pro-democracy movements (against Zia-ul-Haq from 1982 in Pakistan; against Ershad, led by students, in Bangladesh). Step 2, differences: the textbook explains Pakistan's difficulties by the social power of the military, clergy and landed aristocracy, conflict with India and Western support for military rule; Bangladesh has had multi-party elections since 1991. Conclusion: similar beginnings, different trajectories after the end of the Cold War.

Worked example 2: cause and effect in 1970-71

Question: Explain how the 1970 election led to the creation of Bangladesh. Chain: the Awami League won all seats in East Pakistan and a majority in the proposed assembly, then the West Pakistan-dominated government refused to convene the assembly and arrested Sheikh Mujib, then the army suppressed the movement and refugees fled to India, then India supported independence, then the December 1971 war ended with the surrender of Pakistani forces in the east and the birth of Bangladesh.

Key takeaways: Pakistan has swung between military rulers (Ayub Khan, Yahya Khan, Zia-ul-Haq, Musharraf) and elected governments (Z. A. Bhutto, Benazir Bhutto, Nawaz Sharif; elected leaders since 2008). The textbook links this to the power of the military, clergy and landed elite, conflict with India and Western backing for military rule, while noting a strong pro-democracy sentiment. Bangladesh emerged in 1971 from a struggle against West Pakistani domination, went through assassinations and military rule, and has had multi-party democracy since 1991.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In the 1970 elections in the then Pakistan, which party won all the seats in East Pakistan?

    1. Pakistan People's Party
    2. Muslim League
    3. Bangladesh National Party
    4. Awami League
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The textbook says the Awami League led by Sheikh Mujib won all the seats in East Pakistan and a majority in the proposed constituent assembly.

  2. 2. Who removed Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif in 1999, according to the chapter?

    1. General Zia-ul-Haq
    2. General Pervez Musharraf
    3. General Ayub Khan
    4. General Yahya Khan
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter says the phase of elective democracy lasted till 1999, when General Pervez Musharraf removed Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif.

  3. 3. Which factor does the textbook NOT give for Pakistan's difficulty in building a stable democracy?

    1. Social dominance of the military, clergy and landowning aristocracy
    2. Conflict with India strengthening pro-military groups
    3. A ban on all newspapers since independence
    4. Lack of genuine international support for democracy
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The textbook in fact says Pakistan has a courageous and relatively free press; the other three are the factors it lists.

  4. 4. Mass public protests forced Lt Gen H. M. Ershad to step down in Bangladesh in:

    1. 1990
    2. 1979
    3. 1975
    4. 1991
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter says mass public protests made Ershad step down in 1990, and elections were held in 1991.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): The people of East Pakistan protested against West Pakistani domination. Reason (R): Urdu was imposed on them and Bengali culture and language were treated unfairly.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: resentment at the imposition of Urdu and unfair treatment of Bengali culture, along with demands for fair representation, drove the protests.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery