- Foundation
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Monarchy and democracy in Nepal; ethnic conflict and democracy in Sri Lanka
Explain Nepal's journey from monarchy to a democratic republic, including the role of the Maoists and the 2006 movement, and the ethnic conflict in Sri Lanka, India's involvement and the country's democratic record.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Trace the main stages in Nepal's transition from monarchy to republic.
- Explain the roots and course of the ethnic conflict in Sri Lanka as the textbook presents it.
- Describe India's role in Sri Lanka from 1987 and Sri Lanka's achievements despite conflict.
Nepal and Sri Lanka faced very different challenges to democracy. In Nepal the obstacle was the monarchy; in Sri Lanka, which has stayed democratic since 1948, it was ethnic conflict and a demand for secession by one region. This chapter deals with neighbouring countries and disputes. The lessons follow the textbook's own framing and attribute claims and views to it or to the governments it names; they do not add later events.
Nepal: from monarchy to democratic republic
Nepal was a Hindu kingdom and then for many years a constitutional monarchy. Parties and ordinary people wanted a more open and responsive government, but the king, with the army's help, kept full control and restricted democracy.
Nepal's path to a republic
- 1990: new democratic constitution King accepts it after a strong pro-democracy movement; governments short-lived
- 1990s: Maoist insurgency Armed insurrection against the monarch and elite; a triangular conflict
- 2002: king dissolves parliament Dismisses the government, ending even limited democracy
- April 2006: mass protests King forced to restore the House of Representatives
- 2008: monarchy abolished Nepal becomes a democratic republic
- 2015: new constitution adopted Drafted by a constituent assembly
- In the 1990s the Maoists spread their influence through armed insurrection against the monarch and the ruling elite. For a time there was a triangular conflict among monarchist forces, democrats and Maoists.
- The largely non-violent movement of April 2006 was led by the Seven Party Alliance (SPA), the Maoists and social activists.
- Nepal formed a constituent assembly to draft its constitution. Some sections wanted a nominal monarchy to keep a link with the past; the Maoists suspended armed struggle but wanted radical social and economic restructuring in the constitution, which not all SPA parties accepted. The textbook adds that the Maoists and some other groups were deeply suspicious of the Indian government's role in Nepal's future.
Sri Lanka: ethnic conflict
After independence, politics in Sri Lanka (then Ceylon) was dominated by forces representing the majority Sinhala community. According to the textbook, they were hostile to the large number of Tamils who had migrated from India and settled there, a migration that continued after independence. Sinhala nationalists held that Sri Lanka belonged to the Sinhala people only and should not give 'concessions' to Tamils. The neglect of Tamil concerns led to militant Tamil nationalism.
- From 1983, the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) fought an armed struggle against the Sri Lankan army for 'Tamil Eelam', a separate country for Sri Lankan Tamils; at one point it controlled the north-eastern part of the island.
- Because the problem involved people of Indian origin, there was pressure from Tamils in India for the Indian government to protect Sri Lankan Tamils' interests.
- In 1987 India signed an accord with Sri Lanka and sent troops, the Indian Peace Keeping Force (IPKF), to stabilise relations between the government and the Tamils. The Indian Army ended up fighting the LTTE, and many Sri Lankans saw the troops' presence as interference in internal affairs. The IPKF pulled out in 1989 without attaining its objective.
- International actors, particularly Scandinavian countries such as Norway and Iceland, tried to bring the groups back to negotiations. The armed conflict ended when the LTTE was vanquished in 2009.
Sri Lanka's achievements
In spite of the conflict, the textbook notes that Sri Lanka recorded considerable economic growth and high human development. It was one of the first developing countries to control population growth successfully, the first country in the region to liberalise its economy, and had the highest per capita GDP in the region for many years, right through the civil war. And it maintained a democratic political system throughout.
Challenges to democracy
-
Nepal
- Monarchy backed by the army
- Maoist armed insurgency
- Parliament dissolved in 2002
- Republic from 2008
-
Sri Lanka
- Democracy retained since 1948
- Sinhala majoritarianism and Tamil grievances
- LTTE armed struggle from 1983
- Conflict ended 2009
Nepal's challenge to democracy came from the monarchy; Sri Lanka's came from ethnic conflict and a secessionist demand, not from the military or a king.
Worked example 1: three challenges in Nepal
Question: Explain why Nepal's democratic governments after 1990 had, in the textbook's words, a short and troubled career, and what hurdles remained even after 2006. Model answer: (1) the monarchy, which with army support kept control and in 2002 dissolved parliament; (2) the Maoist armed insurrection of the 1990s and the triangular conflict among monarchists, democrats and Maoists; (3) disagreement over the new constitution: some wanted a nominal monarchy, the Maoists wanted radical restructuring that not all SPA parties accepted.
Worked example 2: assessing the IPKF
Question: Why did the IPKF withdraw in 1989 without achieving its aim? Reasoning from the chapter: Step 1, its aim was to stabilise relations between the Sri Lankan government and the Tamils. Step 2, it became involved in fighting the LTTE itself. Step 3, many Sri Lankans resented the troops as interference in internal affairs. Answer: caught between the parties and lacking local acceptance, it could not meet its objective. The textbook adds that India now prefers disengagement from Sri Lanka's internal troubles.
Key takeaways: Nepal moved from a monarchy restricting democracy, through the 1990 constitution, Maoist insurgency and the 2002 dissolution of parliament, to the 2006 movement, a republic in 2008 and a new constitution in 2015. Sri Lanka stayed democratic but faced conflict rooted, in the textbook's account, in Sinhala majoritarianism and the neglect of Tamil concerns; the LTTE fought from 1983, India's IPKF (1987-89) withdrew without success, and the conflict ended in 2009. Sri Lanka still achieved high human development and was the first in the region to liberalise.
Check your understanding
-
1. In 2006, the largely non-violent pro-democracy movement in Nepal was led by:
- the Seven Party Alliance, the Maoists and social activists
- the king and the army
- the Awami League
- the LTTE
Show answer
Answer: A. The textbook says the April 2006 movement was led by the Seven Party Alliance (SPA), the Maoists and social activists.
-
2. Nepal became a democratic republic after abolishing the monarchy in:
- 1990
- 2002
- 2008
- 2006
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter states that in 2008 Nepal became a democratic republic after abolishing the monarchy, and adopted a new constitution in 2015.
-
3. The LTTE fought for:
- the restoration of monarchy in Sri Lanka
- a separate country, Tamil Eelam, for Sri Lankan Tamils
- Sri Lanka's merger with India
- a presidential system
Show answer
Answer: B. From 1983 the LTTE fought an armed struggle against the Sri Lankan army for 'Tamil Eelam', a separate country for the Tamils of Sri Lanka.
-
4. Which is an achievement of Sri Lanka named in the chapter?
- It has the largest population in South Asia
- It never had any internal conflict
- It abolished its parliament in 2002
- It was the first country in the region to liberalise its economy
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook says Sri Lanka was the first country in the region to liberalise its economy and had the highest per capita GDP for many years, even during the civil war.
-
5. Assertion (A): Many Sri Lankans did not welcome the presence of Indian troops after 1987. Reason (R): They saw it as an attempt by India to interfere in Sri Lanka's internal affairs.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: the textbook says the presence of Indian troops was not much liked, as Sri Lankans saw it as interference in their internal affairs.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.