- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Peace and cooperation: SAARC, SAFTA and outside powers
Explain SAARC and SAFTA, why their success has been limited, the efforts to manage India-Pakistan tensions, and the role of China and the US in South Asia as the textbook describes it.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe SAARC and SAFTA and the differing views about SAFTA.
- Explain the efforts the textbook lists to manage India-Pakistan tensions.
- Explain how China and the US influence South Asia, and who the textbook says will shape its future.
Do the states of South Asia only quarrel? The textbook answers no: despite many conflicts, they recognise the importance of cooperation and friendly relations. This lesson looks at the main regional initiative, efforts at peace between India and Pakistan, and the outside powers active in the region.
SAARC
The South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC) is the major regional initiative for cooperation through multilateral means. It began in 1985: according to the textbook's timeline, South Asian leaders signed the SAARC Charter at the first summit in Dhaka in December 1985. The timeline also records that Afghanistan joined SAARC in 2007 and that the 18th summit was held in Kathmandu in November 2014. The textbook's assessment is that, because of persisting political differences, SAARC has not had much success.
SAFTA
SAARC members signed the South Asian Free Trade Area (SAFTA) agreement, which promised a free trade zone for the whole of South Asia. It was signed in 2004 (at the 12th SAARC Summit in Islamabad) and came into effect on 1 January 2006. It aims at lowering trade tariffs. The idea behind it is that a region that allows free trade across borders may open a new chapter of peace and cooperation.
Views on SAFTA in the textbook
-
Some neighbours' fear
- SAFTA is a way for India to 'invade' their markets
- India may influence their societies and politics through commerce
-
India's view
- Real economic benefits for all
- Freer trade will help political cooperation
-
Some in India
- Not worth the trouble
- India already has bilateral agreements with Bhutan, Nepal and Sri Lanka
Managing India-Pakistan tensions
- The two countries agreed to confidence-building measures to reduce the risk of war.
- Social activists and prominent personalities worked to build friendship between the peoples.
- Leaders met at summits; the timeline records the Tashkent Agreement (1966), the Simla Agreement (1972), the 1988 agreement not to attack each other's nuclear installations, the 1999 bus journey to Lahore to sign a Peace Declaration, and the unsuccessful Agra Summit of 2001.
- Bus routes were opened, trade increased and visas were more easily granted, though the textbook notes that the situation has changed in recent times.
Outside powers
No region exists in a vacuum. The textbook names China and the United States as key players. Sino-Indian relations had improved significantly, it says, but China's strategic partnership with Pakistan remains a major irritant; the demands of development and globalisation have brought the two Asian giants closer, with economic ties multiplying since 1991. American involvement grew rapidly after the Cold War: the US has had good relations with both India and Pakistan and increasingly acts as a moderator in India-Pakistan relations. Economic reforms, the large South Asian diasporas in the US and the region's huge population and markets give America an added stake in regional peace.
Peace and cooperation in South Asia
-
Regional institutions
- SAARC (1985)
- SAFTA (signed 2004, in force 2006)
-
Bilateral efforts
- Confidence-building measures
- Summits and agreements
- People-to-people contact and bus routes
-
Outside powers
- China: closer economic ties with India; partnership with Pakistan an irritant
- US: good relations with both; moderator
The textbook's conclusion: whether South Asia remains known as a conflict-prone zone or becomes a regional bloc with common cultural features and trade interests will depend more on the people and governments of the region than on any outside power.
| Year | Event (from the textbook's timeline) |
|---|---|
| 1947 | India and Pakistan become independent |
| 1948 | Sri Lanka (then Ceylon) gains independence; Indo-Pak conflict over Kashmir |
| 1954-55 | Pakistan joins the Cold War military blocs SEATO and CENTO |
| 1960 | Indus Waters Treaty |
| 1965 / 1966 | Indo-Pak war; Tashkent Agreement |
| 1971 | Indo-Soviet Treaty of Friendship (August); Indo-Pak war and liberation of Bangladesh (December) |
| 1972 | Simla Agreement |
| 1974 | India conducts a nuclear test |
| 1985 | SAARC Charter signed at the first summit in Dhaka |
| 1987 | Indo-Sri Lanka Accord; IPKF operation |
| 1996 | Farakka Treaty on Ganga waters with Bangladesh |
| 1998 | Nuclear tests by India and Pakistan; India-Sri Lanka FTA |
| 1999 | Lahore bus journey and Peace Declaration; Kargil conflict |
| 2004 | SAFTA signed at the 12th SAARC Summit, Islamabad |
SAFTA: an agreement among SAARC members to create a free trade zone for South Asia by lowering tariffs; signed in 2004, in force from 1 January 2006.
Worked example 1: role and limits of SAARC
Question: 'SAARC exists on paper but has achieved little.' How far does the textbook support this claim? Role: begun in 1985, SAARC is the region's main multilateral initiative; through SAFTA it seeks a free trade zone by lowering tariffs, on the idea that freer trade can build political cooperation. Limits: the textbook says persisting political differences have limited its success; some neighbours fear SAFTA lets India dominate their markets; some in India see it as unnecessary given bilateral agreements. Conclusion: a useful framework held back by political mistrust.
Worked example 2: an outside power's influence
Question: Can a power from outside the region shape relations inside it? Answer with an example from the chapter. Answer: China. The textbook says Sino-Indian economic ties have multiplied since 1991, yet China's strategic partnership with Pakistan remains a major irritant for India. So the same outside power both draws India closer through trade and complicates India-Pakistan relations. (The US is another example: the book describes it as a moderator between India and Pakistan.)
Key takeaways: SAARC (1985) is South Asia's main multilateral initiative but, according to the textbook, has had limited success because of political differences. SAFTA (signed 2004, effective 2006) aims to lower tariffs, with differing views on its value. India and Pakistan have used confidence-building measures, summits and people-to-people links, with mixed results. China and the US are key outside players, but the region's future depends mainly on its own people and governments.
Check your understanding
-
1. SAARC began in:
- 1967
- 1985
- 1996
- 2004
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter says SAARC began in 1985; its Charter was signed at the first summit in Dhaka in December 1985.
-
2. SAFTA came into effect on:
- 1 January 1985
- 1 January 2004
- 25 March 1957
- 1 January 2006
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook says the SAFTA agreement was signed in 2004 and came into effect on 1 January 2006.
-
3. Why do some of India's neighbours have reservations about SAFTA, according to the textbook?
- They fear it is a way for India to 'invade' their markets and influence their politics
- They want higher tariffs on all goods
- They are not members of SAARC
- SAFTA bans trade with China
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter says some neighbours fear SAFTA is a way for India to 'invade' their markets and to influence their societies and politics through commercial presence.
-
4. The textbook describes the United States' role in India-Pakistan relations since the Cold War as that of a:
- military ally of one side only
- member of SAARC
- moderator
- neutral observer with no involvement
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter says the US has had good relations with both India and Pakistan since the Cold War and increasingly works as a moderator in their relations.
-
5. Assertion (A): SAARC has not had much success. Reason (R): There are persisting political differences among the states of South Asia.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: the textbook says that, due to persisting political differences, SAARC has not had much success.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.