- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
What South Asia is and the spread of democracy in the region
Define South Asia as the textbook does, describe its natural boundaries and diversity of political systems, and explain the evidence that democracy is becoming an accepted norm across the region.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Name the seven countries the textbook includes in South Asia and explain its natural insularity.
- Compare the political experience of the countries of the region.
- Explain what the survey of popular attitudes revealed about support for democracy.
When India and Pakistan joined the club of nuclear powers, South Asia suddenly drew global attention, mostly for its conflicts: border and water-sharing disputes, insurgency, ethnic strife and quarrels over resources. Yet many people in the region also recognise that it can prosper if its states cooperate. The textbook's image for this is an India-Pakistan cricket match: gripping rivalry on the field, warm hospitality for visiting fans off it. Rivalry and goodwill, suspicion and trust, coexist. This chapter deals with neighbouring countries and disputes. The lessons follow the textbook's own framing and attribute claims and views to it or to the governments it names; they do not add later events.
Defining South Asia
In the textbook, South Asia means seven countries: Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, the Maldives, Nepal, Pakistan and Sri Lanka. The Himalayas in the north and the Indian Ocean, the Arabian Sea and the Bay of Bengal in the south, west and east give the region a natural insularity, largely responsible for the sub-continent's linguistic, social and cultural distinctiveness. The boundaries are less clear in the east and west: Afghanistan and Myanmar are often included in discussions of the region, and China is an important player but is not considered part of it. So defined, South Asia stands for diversity in every sense, yet forms one geo-political space.
South Asia as the textbook defines it
-
The seven countries
- Bangladesh
- Bhutan
- India
- The Maldives
- Nepal
- Pakistan
- Sri Lanka
-
Natural boundaries
- Himalayas to the north
- Arabian Sea to the west
- Bay of Bengal to the east
- Indian Ocean to the south
-
Often discussed with the region
- Afghanistan
- Myanmar
- China: an important player, not part of the region
Different political systems
| Country | Political experience (as the textbook describes it) |
|---|---|
| India | A democracy throughout its existence as an independent country, despite limitations |
| Sri Lanka | Has retained a democratic system since independence in 1948 |
| Pakistan | Alternating civilian and military rule; a military coup in 1999; civilian government again since 2008 |
| Bangladesh | Both civilian and military rulers; a democracy in the post-Cold War period |
| Nepal | Constitutional monarchy till 2006; monarchy abolished in 2008, becoming a democratic republic |
| Bhutan | Became a constitutional monarchy in 2008 and, under the king's leadership, a multi-party democracy |
| The Maldives | A Sultanate till 1968, then a republic with a presidential government; parliament voted unanimously for a multi-party system in June 2005 |
From the experience of Bangladesh and Nepal in particular, the textbook concludes that democracy is becoming an accepted norm in the whole region.
Popular support for democracy
The textbook cites a survey, State of Democracy in South Asia (2007), based on interviews with more than 19,000 ordinary citizens in the five big countries of the region. It found widespread support for democracy in all five: rich and poor, and people of different religions, viewed democracy positively, supported representative institutions, preferred democracy to any other form of government and thought it suitable for their country. This matters because it was once believed that democracy could flourish only in prosperous countries. In that sense, the textbook says, the South Asian experience has expanded the global imagination of democracy.
South Asia's record of democracy is mixed, but the aspiration for democracy is shared across all its countries, rich and poor alike.
Worked example 1: identifying a country from clues
Question: Which country is described? 'An island state, once ruled by a Sultan, now a republic with a presidential government, which voted for multi-party politics in 2005.' Reasoning: two island states are in the region, Sri Lanka and the Maldives. Sri Lanka was never a Sultanate in the chapter's account; the Maldives was a Sultanate till 1968 and its parliament voted unanimously for a multi-party system in June 2005. Answer: the Maldives.
Worked example 2: interpreting survey evidence
Question: Why does the textbook call the survey findings 'significant'? Step 1: recall the older belief that democracy could find support only in prosperous countries. Step 2: note what the survey found: strong support among poor as well as rich citizens in a region with many poor people. Step 3: draw the conclusion: the findings challenge the older belief, showing that democracy can take root without prosperity, which is why the book says South Asia has expanded the global imagination of democracy.
Key takeaways: the textbook's South Asia is seven countries bounded by the Himalayas and the seas, with Afghanistan and Myanmar often discussed alongside it and China an outside player. India and Sri Lanka have stayed democratic; Pakistan and Bangladesh have alternated between civilian and military rule; Nepal, Bhutan and the Maldives have moved towards democracy. A 2007 survey showed wide popular support for democracy across the region, rich and poor alike.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of these is NOT among the seven countries the textbook includes in South Asia?
- Bhutan
- Myanmar
- the Maldives
- Sri Lanka
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook's seven are Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, the Maldives, Nepal, Pakistan and Sri Lanka. Myanmar, like Afghanistan, is often included in discussions but is not one of the seven.
-
2. The natural insularity of South Asia is provided mainly by:
- the Hindu Kush in the south
- deserts on all sides
- the Indus river alone
- the Himalayas in the north and the seas and ocean to the south, west and east
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook says the Himalayas in the north and the Indian Ocean, the Arabian Sea and the Bay of Bengal provide natural insularity, shaping the region's distinctiveness.
-
3. Bhutan became a constitutional monarchy in:
- 2008
- 1990
- 2005
- 1968
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter says Bhutan became a constitutional monarchy in 2008 and, under the king's leadership, emerged as a multi-party democracy.
-
4. Which countries, according to the textbook, have operated a democratic system since independence?
- Pakistan and Bangladesh
- Nepal and Bhutan
- India and Sri Lanka
- the Maldives and Pakistan
Show answer
Answer: C. The textbook says that despite problems, Sri Lanka and India have successfully operated a democratic system since their independence.
-
5. Assertion (A): The South Asian experience has expanded the global imagination of democracy. Reason (R): Surveys found widespread support for democracy among both rich and poor citizens in the region, though it was once believed democracy could flourish only in prosperous countries.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: strong support for democracy in a region with many poor people challenged the belief that only prosperous countries could sustain it.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.