• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Cooperative security and India's security strategy

Explain why non-traditional threats call for cooperative security and who takes part in it, and describe the four components of India's security strategy as the textbook presents them.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain why cooperation works better than force for most non-traditional threats.
  • Identify the levels and actors of cooperative security, and when force may be used.
  • Describe the four components of India's security strategy.

Many non-traditional threats call for cooperation rather than military confrontation. Force may have some role against terrorism or in enforcing human rights, though even there it has limits, but it is hard to see how force could reduce poverty, manage migration and refugees or control epidemics. In most such cases, the textbook says, force would only make matters worse.

Cooperative security

  • Levels: cooperation may be bilateral (between two countries), regional, continental or global, depending on the threat and on countries' willingness and ability to respond.
  • Actors: international organisations (the UN, WHO, World Bank, IMF), NGOs (Amnesty International, the Red Cross, foundations, charities, religious organisations, trade unions, social and development organisations), businesses and corporations, and great personalities (the textbook names Mother Teresa and Nelson Mandela).
  • Force as a last resort: the international community may have to sanction force against governments that kill their own people or ignore the misery of populations devastated by poverty, disease and catastrophe, or against international terrorists and those who harbour them. Non-traditional security is much better served when force is sanctioned and applied collectively than when one country acts on its own.

Cooperative security

  • Levels
    • Bilateral
    • Regional
    • Continental
    • Global
  • Actors
    • International organisations
    • NGOs
    • Businesses and corporations
    • Great personalities
  • Use of force
    • Only as a last resort
    • Better when sanctioned and applied collectively

India's security strategy

India has faced both traditional (military) and non-traditional threats, from within and outside its borders. The textbook describes four broad components of its strategy, used in varying combinations over time.

Four components of India's security strategy
ComponentWhat it involves (as the textbook describes)
1. Strengthening military capabilitiesIndia has been in conflicts with Pakistan (1947-48, 1965, 1971, 1999) and China (1962). Surrounded by nuclear-armed countries, the government justified the 1998 nuclear tests in terms of safeguarding national security; India first tested a nuclear device in 1974
2. Strengthening international norms and institutionsNehru supported Asian solidarity, decolonisation, disarmament and the UN as a forum to settle conflicts; India sought a universal, non-discriminatory non-proliferation regime with equal rights and obligations on weapons of mass destruction; argued for a New International Economic Order (NIEO); used non-alignment to create an area of peace outside bloc politics; joined the 1997 Kyoto Protocol; sent troops on UN peacekeeping missions
3. Meeting security challenges within the countryMilitant groups in areas such as Nagaland, Mizoram, Punjab and Kashmir have at times sought to break away; India has tried to preserve unity through a democratic system that lets communities voice grievances and share power
4. Economic development with reduced inequalityLifting the mass of citizens out of poverty and preventing huge inequalities; democratic politics gives voice to the poor and presses governments to combine growth with human development

The textbook draws a notable conclusion from the fourth component: democracy is not just a political ideal; a democratic government is also a way to provide greater security, because it creates pressure to address poverty and gives everyone a voice.

India's strategy covers both views of security

  • Traditional elements
    • Military capability
    • Nuclear deterrent (tests in 1974 and 1998)
    • Countering secessionist militancy
  • Non-traditional elements
    • Disarmament and fair non-proliferation
    • Kyoto Protocol on global warming
    • Poverty reduction and human development
    • Democracy as a source of security

Cooperative security: meeting threats such as poverty, epidemics, refugees and terrorism through joint action by states, international bodies, NGOs and others, with force used only as a collectively approved last resort.

— Key idea in our words

Worked example 1: choosing the right tool

Question: A made-up country faces (i) a cross-border epidemic and (ii) a neighbouring army massing at its frontier. Which approach suits each? Reasoning: (i) is a non-traditional threat; force cannot stop a virus, so cooperation with neighbours and bodies like the WHO is needed. (ii) is a traditional military threat; deterrence and defence are relevant, along with confidence-building talks. Answer: cooperative security for (i); traditional security tools for (ii).

Worked example 2: placing a policy in India's strategy

Question: Under which component of India's strategy does each fall? (a) Joining the Kyoto Protocol. (b) A democratic system allowing communities to voice grievances. (c) The 1998 nuclear tests. Answer: (a) strengthening international norms and institutions; (b) meeting security challenges within the country; (c) strengthening military capabilities.

Key takeaways: non-traditional threats need cooperation, bilateral to global, involving international organisations, NGOs, businesses and prominent individuals; force is a last resort and better used collectively. India's strategy, as the textbook describes it, combines military strength (including nuclear tests in 1974 and 1998), support for international norms and institutions (non-alignment, fair non-proliferation, NIEO, Kyoto, peacekeeping), democratic handling of internal challenges, and development that reduces poverty and inequality.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Why does the textbook prefer cooperation to force for most non-traditional threats?

    1. Force is always illegal
    2. Force cannot reduce poverty, manage migration or control epidemics, and may make matters worse
    3. Cooperation is cheaper than all wars
    4. No country has an army
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter says it is difficult to see what force would do to alleviate poverty, manage migration and refugees or control epidemics, and that force would often make matters worse.

  2. 2. Which of these is a non-governmental organisation named in the chapter's discussion of cooperative security?

    1. The World Bank
    2. The WHO
    3. The IMF
    4. The Red Cross
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The Red Cross is listed among NGOs; the World Bank, IMF and WHO are listed as international organisations.

  3. 3. India first tested a nuclear device in:

    1. 1974
    2. 1971
    3. 1962
    4. 1998
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The textbook says India first tested a nuclear device in 1974; the 1998 tests were justified by the government in terms of national security.

  4. 4. Which belongs to the second component of India's security strategy, strengthening international norms and institutions?

    1. Holding elections in states facing militancy
    2. Building up the army after 1962
    3. Using non-alignment to create an area of peace outside bloc politics
    4. Lifting citizens out of poverty
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter lists support for the UN, disarmament, a non-discriminatory non-proliferation regime, the NIEO, non-alignment, the Kyoto Protocol and peacekeeping under this component.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): A democratic government can be a way to provide greater security. Reason (R): Democratic politics gives voice to the poor and pressures elected governments to combine economic growth with human development.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: the textbook says democracy lets the deprived be heard and pushes governments towards human development, so it is also a source of security.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery