• Foundation
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Internal security, the Third World, and cooperation within the traditional view

Explain why internal security mattered less to the great powers after 1945, how the security challenges of newly independent states differed, and the forms of cooperation the traditional view accepts: limits on war, disarmament, arms control and confidence building.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain how context shaped the importance of internal security after the Second World War.
  • Describe the two ways in which the security challenges of new states in Asia and Africa differed from Europe's.
  • Distinguish disarmament, arms control and confidence building, with the treaties the textbook names.

Security surely depends on peace inside a country too: a society torn by internal violence can hardly prepare to face an external threat. So traditional security must also cover internal security. The textbook explains why, for a time, it received less attention, and why that was not true everywhere.

Why internal security seemed less pressing after 1945

After the Second World War, the US and the Soviet Union appeared united at home and could expect peace within their borders, and most powerful Western European countries faced no serious threats from groups inside their borders. So these countries focused on external threats, above all a military attack by the rival Cold War alliance. Some European powers also worried about violence in their colonies: the textbook mentions the French fighting in Vietnam in the 1950s and the British in Kenya in the 1950s and early 1960s.

Security challenges of the newly independent states

As colonies became free from the late 1940s, some of their concerns resembled Europe's: some joined Cold War alliances and feared being dragged into a hot war, and some feared attack by former colonial rulers. The textbook notes that the Cold War was responsible for about one-third of all wars after the Second World War, most fought in the Third World. But the new states of Asia and Africa differed from Europe in two ways:

  • They faced the prospect of military conflict with neighbouring countries, quarrelling over borders, territory or control of populations; many came to fear neighbours more than the superpowers or former colonial powers.
  • They had to worry about internal military conflict, especially separatist movements wanting independent countries. Sometimes external and internal threats merged, when a neighbour helped or instigated a separatist movement.

The textbook adds that internal wars now make up more than 95 per cent of armed conflicts, and that between 1946 and 1991 there was a twelve-fold rise in the number of civil wars, the greatest jump in 200 years.

Security concerns after 1945

  • Powerful Western states
    • Internal peace largely assured
    • Main fear: attack by the rival alliance
    • Some worried about colonial wars
  • Newly independent states
    • Conflicts with neighbours over borders and people
    • Internal separatist movements
    • External and internal threats often merged
    • Possible entanglement in Cold War wars

Cooperation within traditional security

Traditional security accepts that limiting violence through cooperation is possible. Limits apply to the ends of war (countries should go to war only for the right reasons, mainly self-defence or protecting others from genocide) and to its means (armies must avoid harming non-combatants and unarmed or surrendering combatants, must not be excessively violent, and should use force only after alternatives fail). Beyond this, there are three main forms of cooperation:

Three forms of cooperation
FormMeaningExamples in the textbook
DisarmamentAll states give up certain kinds of weaponsBiological Weapons Convention (1972) and Chemical Weapons Convention (1997), which banned producing and possessing these weapons and included all the great powers
Arms controlRegulates the acquisition or development of weaponsAnti-Ballistic Missile (ABM) Treaty 1972; SALT II; START; Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) 1968
Confidence buildingRivals share ideas and information on military intentions, plans, forces and deploymentsA process to ensure rivals do not go to war through misunderstanding or misperception

The superpowers did not want to give up the third kind of weapon of mass destruction, nuclear weapons, so they pursued arms control rather than disarmament. The ABM Treaty stopped the US and the Soviet Union from large-scale production of missile defence systems (allowing only a very limited number). The NPT (1968) let countries that had tested and manufactured nuclear weapons before 1967 keep them, while others gave up the right to acquire them. It did not abolish nuclear weapons; it limited the number of countries that could have them.

Disarmament removes a type of weapon altogether; arms control only regulates how weapons are acquired or developed; confidence building reduces the risk of war by misunderstanding.

— Key distinction in our words

Overall, the textbook sums up, traditional conceptions are principally concerned with the use or threat of use of military force: force is both the main threat to security and the main means of achieving it.

Worked example 1: classifying cooperation

Question: Classify these made-up arrangements. (i) Two rival states agree to notify each other before large military exercises. (ii) All states agree never to produce or keep a certain poison gas. (iii) Two powers agree to cap the number of a particular missile each may build. Reasoning: (i) is sharing information to avoid misperception: confidence building. (ii) is giving up a kind of weapon entirely: disarmament. (iii) is regulating, not abolishing, a weapon: arms control.

Worked example 2: reading the NPT

Question: Why does the textbook call the NPT an arms control treaty rather than a disarmament treaty? Step 1: disarmament would require all states to give up nuclear weapons. Step 2: the NPT let states that had tested and manufactured them before 1967 keep them and barred others from acquiring them. Conclusion: it regulated who could have nuclear weapons without abolishing them, which is arms control.

Key takeaways: after 1945 powerful Western states focused on external threats because internal peace seemed assured, while new states in Asia and Africa faced both conflicts with neighbours and internal separatist wars. Traditional security still allows cooperation: limits on the ends and means of war, disarmament (BWC 1972, CWC 1997), arms control (ABM 1972, SALT II, START, NPT 1968) and confidence building. Military force remains its central concern.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The new states of Asia and Africa differed from European powers in their security challenges because they faced:

    1. no threats at all
    2. only threats from former colonial rulers
    3. only threats from the superpowers
    4. conflicts with neighbours and internal military conflict
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The textbook says the new countries faced the prospect of military conflict with neighbours and had to worry about internal military conflict, both differences from Europe.

  2. 2. Which treaty allowed countries that had tested and manufactured nuclear weapons before 1967 to keep them?

    1. The Biological Weapons Convention
    2. The Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) of 1968
    3. The Chemical Weapons Convention
    4. The Kyoto Protocol
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The NPT of 1968 regulated nuclear weapons: states that had them before 1967 could keep them; others gave up the right to acquire them.

  3. 3. Giving up certain kinds of weapons altogether, as in the 1997 Chemical Weapons Convention, is called:

    1. arms control
    2. confidence building
    3. disarmament
    4. balance of power
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Disarmament requires all states to give up certain kinds of weapons; the BWC and CWC banned the production and possession of those weapons.

  4. 4. According to the textbook, between 1946 and 1991 the number of civil wars:

    1. rose twelve-fold
    2. fell by half
    3. stayed the same
    4. doubled
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter says there was a twelve-fold rise in the number of civil wars between 1946 and 1991, the greatest jump in 200 years.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): The US and the Soviet Union pursued arms control for nuclear weapons rather than disarmament. Reason (R): The superpowers did not want to give up nuclear weapons.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: unwilling to abandon nuclear weapons, the superpowers chose to regulate them through treaties such as the ABM Treaty, SALT II and START.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery