- Foundation
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
What security means and the traditional view of external threats
Define security as freedom from threats to core values, explain the traditional notion of external security, and describe its four components: deterrence, defence, balance of power and alliance building.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why security is limited to extremely dangerous threats to core values.
- Describe the government's three choices when facing the threat of war, and the meaning of deterrence and defence.
- Explain balance of power and alliance building, and why states must look after their own security.
We often hear that something is a 'security issue', and the phrase is sometimes used to close a discussion, as if the matter were too secret or important to debate. In a democracy, the textbook argues, citizens need to understand what security means. This chapter introduces two broad ways of thinking about it, traditional and non-traditional, and stresses that context shapes which view makes sense.
What is security?
At its most basic, security implies freedom from threats. But life is full of threats, and if every risk counted, the world would be saturated with security issues and we would be paralysed. So those who study security usually say that only threats to core values count. That raises questions: whose core values, the country's or ordinary people's? And how serious must a threat be? The textbook's conclusion is that security relates only to extremely dangerous threats: those that could damage core values beyond repair if nothing were done. Even so, it remains a slippery idea, since conceptions of security differ across societies and change over time.
Security: freedom from extremely dangerous threats that could damage a society's core values beyond repair if they were not dealt with.
The traditional notion: external threats
In the traditional (national security) conception, the greatest danger to a country comes from military threats by another country, which endanger the core values of sovereignty, independence and territorial integrity. War also endangers ordinary citizens: civilians are often made targets to break their support for the war.
A government's three choices
- Surrender (governments may do this when actually confronted by war, but none will advertise it as policy).
- Prevent the other side from attacking by promising to raise the costs of war to an unacceptable level: this is deterrence.
- Defend itself when war breaks out, denying the attacker its objectives and turning back or defeating its forces: this is defence.
Balance of power
Countries notice that some others are bigger and stronger, which hints at who might become a threat in future, even if a powerful neighbour gives no sign of preparing to attack. Governments are therefore sensitive to the balance of power and work to keep it favourable, especially with neighbours, rivals and past adversaries. Building up military power is a large part of this, but economic and technological power matter too, because they are the basis of military power.
Alliance building
An alliance is a coalition of states that coordinate their actions to deter or defend against military attack. Most are formalised in written treaties and identify fairly clearly who the threat is. States join alliances to increase their effective power relative to another country or alliance. Alliances rest on national interests and change when those interests change. The textbook's example: the US backed Islamic militants in Afghanistan against the Soviet Union in the 1980s, but later attacked them after Al Qaeda launched terrorist strikes on America on 11 September 2001.
Traditional security policy: four components
-
Deterrence
- Preventing war
- Raising the cost of attack to an unacceptable level
-
Defence
- Limiting or ending war
- Denying the attacker its objectives
-
Balance of power
- Keeping the power balance favourable
- Military, economic and technological strength
-
Alliance building
- Coalitions to deter or defend
- Based on national interests; can change
Why states must rely on themselves
Within a country, the threat of violence is regulated by an acknowledged central authority, the government. In world politics there is no acknowledged central authority above everyone else. The UN might seem to be one, but as presently constituted it is a creature of its members and has authority only to the extent they allow and obey it. So, in the traditional view, each country has to be responsible for its own security, and most threats are seen as coming from outside its borders.
Worked example 1: deterrence or defence?
Question: Classify each made-up action. (i) Country P announces that any attack will be met with a crushing counter-strike. (ii) Country Q's army pushes back invading forces at its border. Reasoning: (i) aims to stop a war from starting by raising its costs, so it is deterrence. (ii) takes place after war has begun and aims to defeat the attacker, so it is defence.
Worked example 2: why alliances shift
Question: Using the textbook's example, explain why alliances are not permanent. Answer: alliances are based on national interests. In the 1980s US interests lay in opposing the Soviet Union in Afghanistan, so it backed Islamic militants there; after the 11 September 2001 attacks by Al Qaeda, its interests changed and it attacked them. When interests change, alliances change.
Key takeaways: security means freedom from extremely dangerous threats to core values. The traditional view sees military threats from other states, endangering sovereignty, independence and territorial integrity, as the main danger. Governments can surrender, deter or defend; traditional policy also relies on a favourable balance of power and on alliances, which follow national interests. Since no central authority stands above states, each must look after its own security.
Check your understanding
-
1. In the traditional conception, the core values endangered by a military threat are:
- food, clothing and shelter
- sovereignty, independence and territorial integrity
- free trade and investment
- literacy and health
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook says the source of danger is another country whose military action endangers the core values of sovereignty, independence and territorial integrity.
-
2. Preventing war by promising to raise its costs to an unacceptable level is called:
- defence
- surrender
- disarmament
- deterrence
Show answer
Answer: D. Security policy concerned with preventing war is called deterrence; limiting or ending war once it starts is called defence.
-
3. An alliance, as defined in the chapter, is:
- a coalition of states coordinating actions to deter or defend against military attack
- a trade agreement between two firms
- a UN agency for refugees
- a treaty banning all weapons
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter defines an alliance as a coalition of states that coordinate their actions to deter or defend against military attack.
-
4. Why, in the traditional view, must each country be responsible for its own security?
- Because the UN is a world government
- Because alliances are illegal
- Because there is no acknowledged central authority above states in world politics
- Because wars never affect civilians
Show answer
Answer: C. Unlike inside a country, world politics has no acknowledged central authority; the UN has authority only as far as its members allow, so each country must look after itself.
-
5. Assertion (A): Economic and technological power matter for maintaining a balance of power. Reason (R): They are the basis for military power.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: the textbook says building military power is a big part of the balance of power, and economic and technological power matter because military power rests on them.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.