• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Non-traditional security: human security and global security

Explain how non-traditional notions widen the referent of security beyond the state, distinguish the narrow, broad and broadest ideas of human security, and explain the idea of global security.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain what is meant by the 'referent' of security and how non-traditional views expand it.
  • Distinguish narrow, broad and broadest conceptions of human security.
  • Explain why global security emerged in the 1990s, with the textbook's examples.

Non-traditional notions of security go beyond military threats to include a wide range of dangers affecting the conditions of human existence. They begin by questioning the traditional answer to the question 'Security for whom?', and in doing so also question what is being secured, from which threats, and by what approach.

The referent: security for whom?

The referent of security means the thing being secured. In the traditional view, the referent is the state, with its territory and governing institutions. Non-traditional views expand it to individuals, communities and indeed all humankind. These views are called human security or global security.

Human security

Human security is about protecting people more than states. Ideally the two coincide, and often they do; but secure states do not automatically mean secure people. Protection from foreign attack may be a necessary condition for individual security, but it is not a sufficient one. The textbook makes a striking point: during the last 100 years, more people have been killed by their own governments than by foreign armies. The textbook also cites the 1994 UNDP Human Development Report's criticism that security had long been interpreted too narrowly, tied to nation states rather than the daily concerns of ordinary people.

Three versions of human security

  • Narrow concept
    • Focus on violent threats to individuals
    • Protection of communities and individuals from internal violence (a phrase the textbook attributes to Kofi Annan)
  • Broad concept
    • Adds hunger, disease and natural disasters
    • These kill far more people than war, genocide and terrorism combined
  • Broadest formulation
    • Adds economic security and threats to human dignity
    • Freedom from want and freedom from fear

All supporters of human security agree that its primary goal is the protection of individuals. They differ on which threats to include.

Global security

The idea of global security emerged in the 1990s in response to threats that are global in nature: global warming, international terrorism, and health epidemics such as AIDS and bird flu. No country can solve these alone, and sometimes one country bears a disproportionate share of a global problem. The textbook's example: a sea level rise of 1.5-2.0 metres due to global warming would flood 20 per cent of Bangladesh, inundate most of the Maldives and threaten nearly half the population of Thailand. Since such problems are global, international cooperation is vital, though difficult to achieve.

Traditional and non-traditional security

  • Traditional
    • Referent: the state
    • Threat: military attack, mainly external
    • Core values: sovereignty, independence, territory
    • Means: military force, deterrence, alliances
  • Non-traditional
    • Referent: individuals, communities, humankind
    • Threats: violence, hunger, disease, disasters, global warming, terrorism
    • Values: life, dignity, freedom from want and fear
    • Means: mainly cooperation

Human security puts people, not states, at the centre: a state can be safe from invasion while its people remain unsafe from violence, hunger or disease.

— Key idea in our words

Worked example 1: narrow, broad or broadest?

Question: Which version of human security would include each concern? (i) Protecting a minority from attack by armed gangs. (ii) Preventing deaths in a famine. (iii) Ensuring workers are not forced into humiliating conditions to survive. Reasoning: (i) is protection from violence: all versions, including the narrow one. (ii) adds hunger: broad version. (iii) concerns economic security and dignity: broadest formulation. Answer: narrow; broad; broadest.

Worked example 2: why a secure state may have insecure people

Question: Explain the textbook's claim that state security is necessary but not sufficient for human security. Step 1: without protection from foreign attack, individuals are clearly at risk, so state security is necessary. Step 2: but threats also come from within: violence by one's own government (which, the textbook notes, has killed more people over the last century than foreign armies), as well as hunger and disease. Conclusion: a state safe from invasion can still leave its people insecure, so state security is not sufficient.

Key takeaways: non-traditional security widens the referent from the state to individuals, communities and humankind. Human security protects people more than states: the narrow view covers violence, the broad view adds hunger, disease and disasters, and the broadest adds economic security and dignity (freedom from want and fear). Global security, from the 1990s, addresses problems like global warming, terrorism and epidemics that only international cooperation can tackle.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In non-traditional conceptions, the referent of security includes:

    1. individuals, communities and all humankind as well as the state
    2. only the state and its territory
    3. only the armed forces
    4. only international organisations
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Non-traditional views reply to 'Security for whom?' with 'not just the state but also individuals or communities or indeed all of humankind'.

  2. 2. The 'broad' concept of human security adds which threats to violence?

    1. Only terrorism
    2. Only nuclear war
    3. Hunger, disease and natural disasters
    4. Trade disputes
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Proponents of the broad concept argue that hunger, disease and natural disasters should be included because they kill far more people than war, genocide and terrorism combined.

  3. 3. 'Freedom from want' and 'freedom from fear' are associated with:

    1. the narrow concept of human security
    2. the broadest formulation of human security
    3. the traditional notion of security
    4. balance of power
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The textbook says the broadest formulation of human security encompasses economic security and threats to human dignity, stressing freedom from want and freedom from fear.

  4. 4. Global security as an idea emerged in the 1990s mainly because:

    1. the Cold War began
    2. nuclear weapons were abolished
    3. the UN was founded
    4. threats like global warming, terrorism and epidemics are global and no country can resolve them alone
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter says global security emerged in response to the global nature of such threats, which no country can resolve alone.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Secure states do not automatically mean secure peoples. Reason (R): During the last 100 years, more people have been killed by their own governments than by foreign armies.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: if governments themselves have killed more people than foreign armies, then a state safe from invasion may still leave its people insecure.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery