- Foundation
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
New sources of threats: terrorism, human rights, poverty, migration and epidemics
Explain the new threats that non-traditional views focus on, as the textbook describes them, and the test an issue must meet to count as a security problem.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define terrorism and international terrorism and explain the debate over human rights and intervention.
- Explain how global poverty, migration and refugee flows create insecurity, and distinguish migrants, refugees and internally displaced people.
- Explain how epidemics show interdependence, and the criterion for treating an issue as a security problem.
Both human security and global security focus on the changing nature of threats. The textbook discusses five: terrorism, human rights, global poverty, migration, and health epidemics. It then warns against stretching 'security' so far that it loses meaning.
Terrorism
Terrorism is political violence that targets civilians deliberately and indiscriminately. International terrorism involves the citizens or territory of more than one country. Terrorist groups seek to change a political situation they dislike by force or the threat of force, choosing civilian targets to terrorise the public and use its unhappiness as a weapon against governments. Classic forms include hijacking planes and bombing trains, cafes, markets and crowded places. Since the attack on the World Trade Centre on 11 September 2001, governments and the public have paid more attention to terrorism, though it is not new; the textbook says most past attacks occurred in the Middle East, Europe, Latin America and South Asia.
Human rights
Human rights are classified into three types: political rights (such as freedom of speech and assembly); economic and social rights; and the rights of colonised people or ethnic and indigenous minorities. There is broad agreement on this classification, but no agreement on which rights are universal or what the international community should do when rights are violated. Since the 1990s, events such as Iraq's invasion of Kuwait, the genocide in Rwanda and the Indonesian military's killing of people in East Timor have fuelled debate about whether the UN should intervene. Some argue the UN Charter empowers the international community to take up arms in defence of human rights; others argue that the national interests of powerful states will decide which violations the UN acts on.
Global poverty
High per capita income and low population growth make rich states and groups richer, while low incomes and high population growth reinforce each other to make poor states and groups poorer. Globally this widens the gap between the North and the South; within the South, disparities have also sharpened. The textbook notes that most of the world's armed conflicts now take place in sub-Saharan Africa, also the poorest region, and that around the turn of the 21st century more people were being killed in wars there than in the rest of the world combined.
Low incomes and high population growth reinforce each other
- Low incomes Found in poor states and poor social groups
- High population growth Continues where incomes stay low
- Income shared among more people Income per person stays low
Then back to step 1: Low incomes
Migration and refugees
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Migrants | People who voluntarily leave their home countries, often for better economic opportunities |
| Refugees | People who flee their country because of war, natural disaster or political persecution |
| Internally displaced people | People who have fled their homes but remain within national borders; the textbook's example is the Kashmiri Pandits who fled violence in the Kashmir Valley in the early 1990s |
States are generally supposed to accept refugees, but they do not have to accept migrants. Poverty in the South has led to large-scale migration to the North, creating international political friction. The textbook notes that the world refugee map tallies almost perfectly with the conflict map: from 1990 to 1995, 70 states were involved in 93 wars that killed about 55 lakh people, and in the 1990s all but three of 60 refugee flows coincided with an internal armed conflict.
Health epidemics
Epidemics such as HIV-AIDS, bird flu and SARS have spread rapidly across countries through migration, business, tourism and military operations, so one country's success or failure in controlling a disease affects others. The textbook records that by 2003 an estimated 4 crore people were infected with HIV-AIDS, two-thirds of them in Africa; new drug therapies lowered deaths in industrialised countries in the late 1990s but were too expensive for poor regions. New diseases have emerged and old ones like tuberculosis, malaria, dengue and cholera have become drug-resistant. Animal epidemics, such as mad-cow disease in Britain and bird flu affecting poultry exports from Asia, have big economic effects. Such epidemics show growing interdependence, which makes borders less meaningful and cooperation more necessary.
A limit: what counts as a security problem?
Expanding the concept does not mean any disease or distress is a security issue; otherwise the idea loses coherence. To qualify, an issue must meet a minimum common criterion, such as threatening the very existence of the referent (a state or a group of people), though the nature of the threat varies. The textbook's examples: global warming threatens the Maldives, much of whose territory may be submerged; HIV-AIDS has been a severe threat in Southern Africa; and in 1994 the Tutsi in Rwanda faced a threat to their existence when nearly five lakh people were killed by the rival Hutu within weeks. So non-traditional security, like traditional security, varies with local context.
Terrorism: political violence that deliberately and indiscriminately targets civilians, aiming to change a political situation through fear.
Worked example 1: migrant, refugee or displaced?
Question: Classify these made-up cases. (i) Ravi moves abroad for a better-paid job. (ii) A family crosses a border to escape a civil war. (iii) Villagers flee fighting to a camp in another part of their own country. Reasoning: voluntary movement for work is migration; fleeing war across a border makes one a refugee; fleeing but staying inside the country is internal displacement. Answer: (i) migrant, (ii) refugees, (iii) internally displaced people.
Worked example 2: applying the criterion
Question: Does a rise in seasonal colds count as a security threat, while rising sea levels for a low-lying island state do? Reasoning: the textbook's test is whether the issue threatens the very existence of the referent. Seasonal colds do not threaten the existence of a people or state. Rising seas could submerge much of a low-lying state's territory, as the textbook says of the Maldives. Answer: the first is not a security issue; the second is.
Key takeaways: new threats include terrorism (political violence deliberately aimed at civilians), human rights abuses (with debate over UN intervention), global poverty (a widening North-South gap and conflict in the poorest regions), migration and refugee flows (migrants, refugees and internally displaced people differ in law) and epidemics (which show interdependence). To count as a security issue, a threat must endanger the very existence of a state or group, and this varies with context.
Check your understanding
-
1. Terrorism, as defined in the chapter, is political violence that:
- targets only soldiers
- occurs only between two armies
- targets civilians deliberately and indiscriminately
- is always approved by the UN
Show answer
Answer: C. The textbook defines terrorism as political violence that targets civilians deliberately and indiscriminately.
-
2. People who have fled their homes but remain within their own country's borders are called:
- internally displaced people
- refugees
- migrants
- diaspora
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter calls them internally displaced people, citing Kashmiri Pandits who fled violence in the Kashmir Valley in the early 1990s.
-
3. Which is NOT one of the three types of human rights in the chapter's classification?
- Political rights such as freedom of speech
- Economic and social rights
- Rights of colonised people or ethnic and indigenous minorities
- The right of a state to acquire nuclear weapons
Show answer
Answer: D. The three types are political rights, economic and social rights, and the rights of colonised people or ethnic and indigenous minorities.
-
4. According to the textbook, to count as a security problem an issue must:
- affect at least one person
- threaten the very existence of the referent, a state or group of people
- involve an army
- be discussed in the UN
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter says an issue must share a minimum common criterion, such as threatening the very existence of the referent, or the concept loses coherence.
-
5. Assertion (A): States are generally supposed to accept refugees but not necessarily migrants. Reason (R): Refugees flee war, natural disaster or political persecution, while migrants leave voluntarily.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: international law distinguishes those forced to flee from those who leave by choice, which is why the obligation applies to refugees.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.