Revision notes

Chapter 5 Security in the Contemporary World: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

What security means and the traditional view of external threats

Security: freedom from extremely dangerous threats that could damage a society's core values beyond repair if they were not dealt with.

— Definition in our words

Traditional security policy: four components

  • Deterrence
    • Preventing war
    • Raising the cost of attack to an unacceptable level
  • Defence
    • Limiting or ending war
    • Denying the attacker its objectives
  • Balance of power
    • Keeping the power balance favourable
    • Military, economic and technological strength
  • Alliance building
    • Coalitions to deter or defend
    • Based on national interests; can change

Key takeaways: security means freedom from extremely dangerous threats to core values. The traditional view sees military threats from other states, endangering sovereignty, independence and territorial integrity, as the main danger. Governments can surrender, deter or defend; traditional policy also relies on a favourable balance of power and on alliances, which follow national interests. Since no central authority stands above states, each must look after its own security.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Internal security, the Third World, and cooperation within the traditional view

Security concerns after 1945

  • Powerful Western states
    • Internal peace largely assured
    • Main fear: attack by the rival alliance
    • Some worried about colonial wars
  • Newly independent states
    • Conflicts with neighbours over borders and people
    • Internal separatist movements
    • External and internal threats often merged
    • Possible entanglement in Cold War wars
Three forms of cooperation
FormMeaningExamples in the textbook
DisarmamentAll states give up certain kinds of weaponsBiological Weapons Convention (1972) and Chemical Weapons Convention (1997), which banned producing and possessing these weapons and included all the great powers
Arms controlRegulates the acquisition or development of weaponsAnti-Ballistic Missile (ABM) Treaty 1972; SALT II; START; Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) 1968
Confidence buildingRivals share ideas and information on military intentions, plans, forces and deploymentsA process to ensure rivals do not go to war through misunderstanding or misperception

Disarmament removes a type of weapon altogether; arms control only regulates how weapons are acquired or developed; confidence building reduces the risk of war by misunderstanding.

— Key distinction in our words

Key takeaways: after 1945 powerful Western states focused on external threats because internal peace seemed assured, while new states in Asia and Africa faced both conflicts with neighbours and internal separatist wars. Traditional security still allows cooperation: limits on the ends and means of war, disarmament (BWC 1972, CWC 1997), arms control (ABM 1972, SALT II, START, NPT 1968) and confidence building. Military force remains its central concern.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Non-traditional security: human security and global security

Three versions of human security

  • Narrow concept
    • Focus on violent threats to individuals
    • Protection of communities and individuals from internal violence (a phrase the textbook attributes to Kofi Annan)
  • Broad concept
    • Adds hunger, disease and natural disasters
    • These kill far more people than war, genocide and terrorism combined
  • Broadest formulation
    • Adds economic security and threats to human dignity
    • Freedom from want and freedom from fear

Traditional and non-traditional security

  • Traditional
    • Referent: the state
    • Threat: military attack, mainly external
    • Core values: sovereignty, independence, territory
    • Means: military force, deterrence, alliances
  • Non-traditional
    • Referent: individuals, communities, humankind
    • Threats: violence, hunger, disease, disasters, global warming, terrorism
    • Values: life, dignity, freedom from want and fear
    • Means: mainly cooperation

Human security puts people, not states, at the centre: a state can be safe from invasion while its people remain unsafe from violence, hunger or disease.

— Key idea in our words

Key takeaways: non-traditional security widens the referent from the state to individuals, communities and humankind. Human security protects people more than states: the narrow view covers violence, the broad view adds hunger, disease and disasters, and the broadest adds economic security and dignity (freedom from want and fear). Global security, from the 1990s, addresses problems like global warming, terrorism and epidemics that only international cooperation can tackle.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

New sources of threats: terrorism, human rights, poverty, migration and epidemics

Low incomes and high population growth reinforce each other

  1. Low incomes Found in poor states and poor social groups
  2. High population growth Continues where incomes stay low
  3. Income shared among more people Income per person stays low

Then back to step 1: Low incomes

A simplified picture of the textbook's point; rich states and groups show the opposite pattern and get richer.
Distinctions in international law and norms
TermMeaning
MigrantsPeople who voluntarily leave their home countries, often for better economic opportunities
RefugeesPeople who flee their country because of war, natural disaster or political persecution
Internally displaced peoplePeople who have fled their homes but remain within national borders; the textbook's example is the Kashmiri Pandits who fled violence in the Kashmir Valley in the early 1990s

Terrorism: political violence that deliberately and indiscriminately targets civilians, aiming to change a political situation through fear.

— Definition in our words

Key takeaways: new threats include terrorism (political violence deliberately aimed at civilians), human rights abuses (with debate over UN intervention), global poverty (a widening North-South gap and conflict in the poorest regions), migration and refugee flows (migrants, refugees and internally displaced people differ in law) and epidemics (which show interdependence). To count as a security issue, a threat must endanger the very existence of a state or group, and this varies with context.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Cooperative security and India's security strategy

Cooperative security

  • Levels
    • Bilateral
    • Regional
    • Continental
    • Global
  • Actors
    • International organisations
    • NGOs
    • Businesses and corporations
    • Great personalities
  • Use of force
    • Only as a last resort
    • Better when sanctioned and applied collectively
Four components of India's security strategy
ComponentWhat it involves (as the textbook describes)
1. Strengthening military capabilitiesIndia has been in conflicts with Pakistan (1947-48, 1965, 1971, 1999) and China (1962). Surrounded by nuclear-armed countries, the government justified the 1998 nuclear tests in terms of safeguarding national security; India first tested a nuclear device in 1974
2. Strengthening international norms and institutionsNehru supported Asian solidarity, decolonisation, disarmament and the UN as a forum to settle conflicts; India sought a universal, non-discriminatory non-proliferation regime with equal rights and obligations on weapons of mass destruction; argued for a New International Economic Order (NIEO); used non-alignment to create an area of peace outside bloc politics; joined the 1997 Kyoto Protocol; sent troops on UN peacekeeping missions
3. Meeting security challenges within the countryMilitant groups in areas such as Nagaland, Mizoram, Punjab and Kashmir have at times sought to break away; India has tried to preserve unity through a democratic system that lets communities voice grievances and share power
4. Economic development with reduced inequalityLifting the mass of citizens out of poverty and preventing huge inequalities; democratic politics gives voice to the poor and presses governments to combine growth with human development

India's strategy covers both views of security

  • Traditional elements
    • Military capability
    • Nuclear deterrent (tests in 1974 and 1998)
    • Countering secessionist militancy
  • Non-traditional elements
    • Disarmament and fair non-proliferation
    • Kyoto Protocol on global warming
    • Poverty reduction and human development
    • Democracy as a source of security

Cooperative security: meeting threats such as poverty, epidemics, refugees and terrorism through joint action by states, international bodies, NGOs and others, with force used only as a collectively approved last resort.

— Key idea in our words

Key takeaways: non-traditional threats need cooperation, bilateral to global, involving international organisations, NGOs, businesses and prominent individuals; force is a last resort and better used collectively. India's strategy, as the textbook describes it, combines military strength (including nuclear tests in 1974 and 1998), support for international norms and institutions (non-alignment, fair non-proliferation, NIEO, Kyoto, peacekeeping), democratic handling of internal challenges, and development that reduces poverty and inequality.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery