- Practice
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
Cause, effect and logical inference in short passages
Draw conclusions from cause-and-effect statements and short logical passages, avoiding the common reversals.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Short passages often state a rule or a cause-and-effect link and ask what follows. These are logic questions in disguise. Keep strictly to what is given.
Common patterns
| Statement | Valid conclusion | Invalid conclusion |
|---|---|---|
| If it rains, the match is cancelled. | It rained, so the match is cancelled. | The match was cancelled, so it rained (other reasons possible). |
| All members get a card. | Ravi is a member, so he gets a card. | Ravi has a card, so he is a member (cards may be given to others). |
| Only adults may vote. | A child may not vote. | All adults vote. |
Worked example 1
Passage: Whenever the power fails, the lift stops working. The lift is not working today. Can we conclude the power failed? No. The lift may have stopped for another reason. The conclusion that follows is only that if the power failed, the lift would not work.
Worked example 2
Passage: Students who submit the form before the last date get a receipt. Priya submitted the form on time. Valid inference: Priya received a receipt.
From 'if A then B' you may conclude B when A is true, but not A when B is true.
Practice
Passage: Plants kept in the dark for many days turn pale and weak. A gardener found that his pot plants had turned pale.
Frequently asked questions
Which is a safe inference? (A) The plants were kept in the dark (B) The plants might have lacked light (C) The gardener was careless (D) The plants were dead
(B). Lack of light is one possible cause, but not the only one stated.
Rule: All students in the hall have passes. Ravi is a student in the hall. Conclusion: (A) Ravi has a pass (B) Ravi has no pass (C) Ravi is a teacher (D) No one has a pass
(A).
Rule: Only members may enter. Sunita entered. Conclusion: (A) Sunita is a member (B) Sunita is a guest (C) Sunita is not a member (D) Nothing
(A).
Rule: If the signal is red, vehicles stop. Vehicles stopped. Which is certain? (A) The signal was red (B) The signal was green (C) We cannot be certain (D) There was an accident
(C). Vehicles may stop for other reasons.
Key takeaways
- Do not reverse an if-then statement.
- Other causes may exist.
- Pick conclusions the passage forces.
Check your understanding
-
1. 'If the river rises above the danger mark, the bridge is closed.' The bridge is closed today. What can be concluded?
- The river rose above the danger mark
- We cannot be sure that the river rose above the danger mark
- The river is very low today
- The bridge has been broken
Show answer
Answer: B. From 'if A then B' you cannot conclude A just because B is true. The bridge may be closed for another reason, such as repairs.
-
2. 'All players in the team wear blue caps. Arjun is a player in the team.' Which conclusion follows?
- Arjun wears a blue cap
- Arjun is the captain
- Anyone wearing a blue cap is a player in the team
- We cannot say anything about Arjun's cap
Show answer
Answer: A. The rule applies to every player and Arjun is a player, so he wears a blue cap. Reversing the rule (anyone in a blue cap is a player) is not valid.
-
3. 'Only staff may park in this area.' Which conclusion is valid?
- All staff members park there
- Everyone who parks there is a manager
- Staff may park anywhere they like
- A visitor who is not staff may not park there
Show answer
Answer: D. 'Only staff' limits who may park; it does not say every staff member does park there. The safe conclusion is that non-staff may not.
-
4. From a rule 'if A, then B', which conclusion may you draw?
- A, when you know that B is true
- Not B, when you know that A is false
- B, when you know that A is true
- That A and B are always both true
Show answer
Answer: C. The rule guarantees B whenever A happens. It says nothing about what happens when A is false, and B may have other causes, so B does not prove A.
-
5. 'Milk left out of the fridge on a hot day turns sour. The milk in Rina's jug has turned sour.' What is the safest inference?
- The milk was certainly left out on a hot day
- Rina bought spoiled milk
- Milk never turns sour inside a fridge
- The milk may have been left out of the fridge
Show answer
Answer: D. Being left out is one possible cause, but milk can sour for other reasons, so 'certainly' reverses the rule. The rule says nothing about milk kept in a fridge.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.