- Practice
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
Inference versus assumption: the line you must not cross
Learn what makes a valid inference, how it differs from an assumption or an opinion, and how to test any conclusion against the text.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
An inference is a conclusion that the text makes certain, or very likely, even though it is not stated. An assumption is something you bring from outside. Exam questions reward the first and punish the second.
The three-question test
- Can I point to words in the passage that support this?
- Would the conclusion still follow if I knew nothing outside the passage?
- Is the conclusion no stronger than what the passage says?
Stated, inferred, assumed
| Level | Passage | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Stated | The shop closed at noon. | The shop closed at noon. |
| Inferred | Every shop in the lane had its shutters down by noon. | The lane had no open shop after noon. |
| Assumed | The shop closed at noon. | The owner had gone home ill (not supported). |
Worked example 1
Passage: Asha left her wet umbrella at the door and hung her dripping coat on the hook. Valid inference: it had been raining. Not valid: it was raining heavily for hours. 'Heavily' and 'for hours' go beyond the text.
Worked example 2
Passage: Only members may borrow books from the club library. Karan borrowed three books last week. Valid inference: Karan is a member. Not valid: Karan reads a lot. That is an opinion about his habits, not a conclusion from the rule.
A valid inference needs no outside knowledge; it follows from the passage alone.
Practice
Passage: The notice at the gate said that the park would close at six in the evening. At seven, the gate was still locked and the lights were off.
Frequently asked questions
Which can be inferred? (A) The park was closed at seven (B) A festival was held there (C) The park never opens (D) The notice was wrong
(A). The locked gate and lights off after six support it.
Which is an assumption? (A) The park was closed after six (B) The guard had gone home early due to illness (C) The notice announced closing at six (D) The gate was locked at seven
(B). Nothing in the passage mentions the guard.
Which is stated directly? (A) The park would close at six (B) The park was empty (C) It was raining (D) The guard was away
(A).
Choose the safest inference: (A) The park closes in the evening (B) The park closes forever at six (C) The park is dangerous (D) The park is private
(A).
Key takeaways
- Inference follows from the text; assumption comes from outside.
- Use the three-question test.
- Choose the mildest conclusion.
Check your understanding
-
1. What is the key difference between an inference and an assumption?
- An inference is always stated; an assumption is always hinted
- An inference follows from the passage; an assumption brings in something from outside it
- An assumption is always false; an inference is always exciting
- There is no difference; the words mean the same
Show answer
Answer: B. An inference is made certain or very likely by the text itself. An assumption depends on knowledge or guesses the passage does not give, which exams punish.
-
2. 'Only ticket-holders may enter the hall. Mira is inside the hall.' Which is a valid inference?
- Mira has a ticket
- Mira loves music
- Mira bought her ticket yesterday
- Mira came with her friends
Show answer
Answer: A. The rule allows only ticket-holders in, and Mira is in, so she holds a ticket. When she bought it, who she came with and what she likes are not in the passage.
-
3. Passage: The school canteen usually serves lunch at one o'clock. At half past one today its counters were empty and its door was shut.
Which of these is an assumption rather than an inference?- The canteen was not serving lunch at half past one
- The cook had fallen ill
- The counters were empty at half past one
- The door was shut at half past one
Show answer
Answer: B. Empty counters and a shut door are stated, and that lunch was not being served follows from them. The reason (an ill cook) is not mentioned anywhere - it is an assumption.
-
4. Which of these is NOT one of the lesson's three tests for a valid inference?
- Can I point to words in the passage that support it?
- Would it still follow if I knew nothing outside the passage?
- Is it no stronger than what the passage says?
- Does the conclusion agree with my own experience?
Show answer
Answer: D. The three tests are support in the text, no need for outside knowledge, and no extra strength. Agreement with your own experience is exactly the outside knowledge to avoid.
-
5. 'Every seat in the hall was taken, and some people stood at the back.' Which inference is no stronger than the text?
- The hall is full every day of the week
- The speaker is the most famous in the country
- The hall was full
- Nobody left before the end
Show answer
Answer: C. Every seat taken plus people standing means the hall was full on that occasion. 'Every day', 'most famous' and 'nobody left' all go beyond the text.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.