• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

NOT and EXCEPT questions: finding what cannot be inferred

Handle questions that ask which statement is not supported by the passage, using a tick-and-cross method that avoids careless slips.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Many students lose marks on inference questions that are worded in the negative: 'All of the following can be inferred EXCEPT...' or 'Which of the following cannot be concluded?' The thinking is the same as in an ordinary inference question, but the answer is the odd one out. Because the question reverses your habit, careless reading is the main danger. This lesson gives a simple method and shows the usual shapes of the wrong options.

The tick-and-cross method

  1. Underline the negative word in the question: except, not, cannot, least.
  2. Go through the options one at a time and mark each one tick (supported by the passage) or cross (not supported or contradicted).
  3. Three ticks and one cross is the pattern you expect. The cross is your answer.
  4. If you find two crosses, re-read: one of them is probably supported in a way you missed.
  5. Before marking, say the question aloud in your head: 'I am looking for the one that is NOT supported.'

Why an option earns a cross

Options that cannot be inferred
ReasonWhat it looks like
Contradicts the passageThe passage says prices rose; the option says prices fell
Goes beyond the passageThe passage describes one town; the option talks about the whole country
Too extremeThe passage says 'many'; the option says 'all' or 'none'
UnrelatedThe option may be true in life but the passage never touches it

Worked example 1

Passage: 'The new library opened in March. In the first month, more than half of the borrowers were students, and the reading room was full every evening. Several retired teachers volunteered to help at the issue desk.' Question: All of the following can be inferred EXCEPT: (A) The library opened before April. (B) Students formed a large share of borrowers. (C) No adults other than students used the library. (D) Some teachers who had retired worked there as helpers. Working: (A) The library opened in March, so before April: tick. (B) More than half of the borrowers were students: tick. (C) 'More than half' means others were also borrowers, and retired teachers visited too: cross. (D) Retired teachers volunteered: tick. Only (C) is not supported. Answer: (C).

Worked example 2

Passage: 'Because the river rose after three days of rain, the bridge was closed. Buses were diverted by a longer road, which added about twenty minutes to each journey.' Question: Which of the following CANNOT be inferred? (A) The rain continued for some days. (B) Travelling by bus became slower. (C) The river's rising caused the closure. (D) The new road is shorter than the bridge route. Working: (A) Three days of rain: tick. (B) Twenty minutes added: tick. (C) The word because gives the cause: tick. (D) The diversion is described as a 'longer road' and adds time, so it is not shorter: cross. Answer: (D).

Worked example 3: when two options look wrong

Passage: 'Most of the farmers in the village grow rice, though a few have shifted to vegetables because they sell more quickly.' Question: Which of the following is LEAST supported? (A) Rice is the main crop of the village. (B) A small number of farmers grow vegetables. (C) Vegetables are said to be sold faster than rice. (D) All the farmers prefer vegetables. Working: (A) 'Most... grow rice': tick. (B) 'A few have shifted': tick. (C) The passage says vegetables sell more quickly, which in this setting is the reason given: tick. (D) 'All' contradicts 'most grow rice': cross. Notice that (C) might seem doubtful at first, but the reason given in the passage supports it. Answer: (D).

In a NOT question, three options are supported; the one that is contradicted, extreme or new is the answer.

— Rule to remember

Speed tips

  • Circle the words except, not, cannot before reading the options.
  • Check options with extreme words (all, never, only) first: they are often the crosses.
  • Do not reject an option because it sounds boring: supported options often look plain.
  • If two options seem unsupported, compare them with the passage line by line.

Key takeaways

  • Convert the question into 'which one fails the test'.
  • Mark each option tick or cross, and expect one cross.
  • The cross is usually a contradiction, an extreme claim or a new idea.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In a question that says 'All of the following can be inferred EXCEPT', the correct answer is the option that is

    1. supported strongly by the passage
    2. repeated word for word in it
    3. not supported by the passage
    4. the longest of the four options
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The word EXCEPT asks for the odd one out. Three options are supported and the one that is not supported is the answer.

  2. 2. A passage says 'Most players practised daily.' Which option is most likely to be the cross in a NOT question?

    1. Every player practised daily
    2. Many players practised daily
    3. A good number of players practised daily
    4. Some players practised every day
    Show answer

    Answer: A. 'Every' is stronger than 'most' and is not supported. The others agree with the passage.

  3. 3. A passage says the bridge was closed because the river rose. Which cannot be inferred?

    1. The river level went up
    2. Traffic had to find another route
    3. The closure was due to the water
    4. The bridge was closed for a year
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The passage gives no length for the closure. The other statements follow from the rising river and the diversion.

  4. 4. What is the first thing to do with the question stem of a NOT question?

    1. Read only the last option
    2. Underline the negative word
    3. Skip the passage
    4. Pick the shortest option
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Marking the negative word reminds you to look for the unsupported option and prevents a careless slip.

  5. 5. If you find two options that both seem unsupported, you should

    1. choose the first of the two
    2. choose the longer of the two
    3. re-read the passage line by line
    4. leave the question unanswered
    Show answer

    Answer: C. One of the two is probably supported in a way you missed. Checking against the passage will show which one fails.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery