- Practice
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
Strengthening and weakening: what supports a claim
Identify which statement supports or undermines an argument, a common inference-style question.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Some inference questions give an argument and ask which statement supports or weakens it. Find the claim and the reason; then see what the new statement does to the link between them.
Method
- Identify the conclusion (the claim).
- Identify the reason offered.
- A supporting statement makes the reason more likely to lead to the claim.
- A weakening statement breaks the link or offers an alternative explanation.
Worked example 1
Argument: The school's pass percentage rose after it introduced weekly tests, so weekly tests improve results. Which weakens it? 'In the same year, the school hired more teachers and reduced class size.' This gives another possible reason for the rise. It weakens the argument.
Worked example 2
Same argument. Which strengthens it? 'In other schools that introduced weekly tests but changed nothing else, results also rose.' This supports the link between tests and results.
To weaken: offer another explanation or show the link fails. To strengthen: rule out alternatives or show the link elsewhere.
Practice
Argument: Ravi grew more tomatoes this year because he used a new fertiliser.
Frequently asked questions
Which weakens the argument? (A) The fertiliser is costly (B) Rainfall this year was much higher than usual (C) Ravi likes tomatoes (D) The fertiliser is organic
(B). Rain could explain the higher yield.
Which strengthens it? (A) Neighbours who did not use it had the same yield as last year (B) Neighbours who did not use it also grew more (C) Ravi lives in a village (D) Tomatoes are sold at market
(A). If others without it saw no change, the fertiliser is more likely the cause.
The conclusion of the argument is: (A) Ravi used a new fertiliser (B) Ravi grew more tomatoes because of it (C) Tomatoes are good (D) Ravi sells tomatoes
(B).
The reason offered is: (A) Ravi grew more tomatoes (B) he used a new fertiliser (C) the soil was good (D) the weather was dry
(B).
Key takeaways
- Find claim and reason first.
- Weakening statements break the link.
- Strengthening statements remove alternative explanations.
Check your understanding
-
1. Argument: Sales at the corner shop rose after it began opening an hour earlier in the morning, so the early opening caused the rise in sales.
Which statement most WEAKENS the argument?- The shopkeeper likes to wake up early
- In the same month, a large office opened next door to the shop
- The shop sells newspapers and milk
- Other shops that opened earlier also saw higher sales
Show answer
Answer: B. A new office next door offers another explanation for higher sales, breaking the link with the early opening. Other early-opening shops also selling more strengthens the argument instead.
-
2. Argument: Sales at the corner shop rose after it began opening an hour earlier in the morning, so the early opening caused the rise in sales.
Which statement most STRENGTHENS the argument?- In the same month the shop hired a cheerful new helper
- In the same month the shop cut its prices
- Most of the extra sales were made during the new early hour
- The shop's walls are painted green
Show answer
Answer: C. If the extra sales came in the new hour, the early opening is very likely the cause. A new helper or lower prices would be other explanations that weaken it.
-
3. 'More children in the town are reading books because a new library has opened.' What is the conclusion of this argument?
- A new library has opened in the town
- Libraries are good for every town
- Children enjoy stories
- More children are reading books because of the new library
Show answer
Answer: D. The claim being argued is the causal one: the library led to more reading. 'A new library has opened' is the reason offered, not the conclusion.
-
4. What does a weakening statement usually do to an argument?
- Offers another explanation or shows that the link fails
- Repeats the claim in other words
- Praises the person making the argument
- Restates the reason more strongly
Show answer
Answer: A. To weaken, you break the link between reason and claim - often by giving a different possible cause.
-
5. Argument: 'Priya's marks improved because she joined a coaching class.' Which statement STRENGTHENS it?
- Priya changed nothing else in her study routine during that time
- Priya also began studying three extra hours a day at home
- The coaching class charges high fees
- Priya's best friend joined the same class
Show answer
Answer: A. Ruling out other changes makes the class the more likely cause. Extra home study would be another explanation (weakening); fees and friends are irrelevant.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.