- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Conditional statements: if-then reasoning and what follows
Use if-then statements correctly, and recognise the two valid and two invalid ways of drawing a conclusion from them.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Many passages and puzzles contain conditional statements: 'If it rains, the match will be cancelled.' Such sentences link one event to another, and exam questions ask what must follow. Students often draw the wrong conclusion because the reverse of an if-then sentence sounds natural but is not guaranteed. Learning the four patterns below will make these questions quick and safe.
The shape of a conditional
A conditional statement has the form If P, then Q. P is the condition and Q is the result. 'If it rains (P), the match will be cancelled (Q).' The statement promises something only about what happens when P is true.
| What you are told | Conclusion | Valid? | Example (rule: if it rains, the match is cancelled) |
|---|---|---|---|
| P is true | Q is true | Valid | It rains, so the match is cancelled |
| Q is false | P is false | Valid | The match was not cancelled, so it did not rain |
| Q is true | P is true | Invalid | The match was cancelled, so it rained (it might have been cancelled for another reason) |
| P is false | Q is false | Invalid | It did not rain, so the match was not cancelled (it may be cancelled for another reason) |
Why the two moves are invalid
The rule says rain is enough to cancel the match. It does not say rain is the only thing that can cancel it. So a cancelled match does not prove rain, and a dry day does not prove the match will be played. Think of the rule as one door into a room. Finding someone in the room does not tell you which door they came through.
Worked example 1
Statement: 'If a number is divisible by 4, then it is even.' Question: Which must be true? (A) 18 is divisible by 4. (B) If a number is odd, it is not divisible by 4. (C) If a number is even, it is divisible by 4. (D) 10 is divisible by 4. Working: Option (B) is the second valid move: not Q (odd) means not P (not divisible by 4). Check with numbers: 7 is odd and not divisible by 4. Option (C) is invalid: 6 is even but is not divisible by 4. Option (A) is false because 18 is not divisible by 4, and option (D) is also false because 10 is not. Answer: (B).
Worked example 2
Statement: 'If the bell rings before 8:30 a.m., then the students go to the hall.' The bell did not ring before 8:30 a.m. Question: What can be concluded? (A) The students went to the hall. (B) The students did not go to the hall. (C) Nothing definite about the hall can be concluded. (D) The bell rang at 9 a.m. Working: P (bell before 8:30) is false. Denying P does not tell us about Q. The students might have gone to the hall for another reason, or might not. The bell might have rung at 8:45 or not at all, so (D) is not proved. Answer: (C).
Worked example 3: chains
Statements: 'If Asha studies, she passes. If she passes, her teacher is pleased.' Asha studied. Question: What follows? Working: From P (Asha studies) we reach Q (she passes). From Q we reach R (the teacher is pleased). So the teacher is pleased. Now reverse the question: the teacher is not pleased. Then Asha did not pass, and so she did not study. Valid moves work in a chain, forwards from a true condition and backwards from a false result. If instead we are told that the teacher is pleased, we cannot say that Asha studied, because the teacher may be pleased for another reason.
From 'If P then Q': P true gives Q true; Q false gives P false. Nothing else is guaranteed.
'Only if' and 'unless'
- 'P only if Q' means that if P is true then Q is true: Q is necessary for P. ('You can enter only if you have a ticket.' Having a ticket does not alone guarantee entry.)
- 'Unless Q, P' means 'if not Q, then P'. ('Unless it rains, we will play' means 'if it does not rain, we will play'.)
Key takeaways
- Memorise the two valid moves and refuse the two invalid ones.
- Test a doubtful conclusion with a simple number or situation.
- A false condition does not make the result false.
Check your understanding
-
1. Rule: 'If it rains, the match is cancelled.' The match was not cancelled. What follows?
- It did not rain
- It rained
- The match was played in the rain
- Nothing can be said
Show answer
Answer: A. Not Q gives not P. If it had rained, the match would have been cancelled, but it was not.
-
2. Rule: 'If a figure is a square, it has four sides.' A figure has four sides. What can we say?
- It must be a square
- It cannot be a square
- It must be a triangle
- It need not be a square
Show answer
Answer: D. Having four sides is the result, not the condition. A rectangle also has four sides, so the move is invalid.
-
3. 'If the tank is full, the pump stops.' The tank is not full. What can be concluded?
- The pump must be running now
- Nothing certain about the pump
- The pump must have stopped
- The tank must be empty now
Show answer
Answer: B. A false condition tells us nothing about the result. The pump may be running or stopped for another reason.
-
4. 'You can enter only if you have a ticket.' Rani has a ticket. Which is safest?
- She has paid a double price
- She will certainly be allowed in
- She meets the ticket requirement
- She is not allowed to enter
Show answer
Answer: C. Only if makes the ticket necessary, not sufficient. Other rules may still apply, so only the requirement can be confirmed.
-
5. 'If Asha studies, she passes. If she passes, her teacher is pleased.' The teacher is not pleased. What follows?
- Asha studied but failed
- Asha passed easily
- Asha will study tomorrow
- Asha did not study
Show answer
Answer: D. Teacher not pleased means she did not pass, and not passing means she did not study. The valid moves run backwards along the chain.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.