- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
A method for environmental dilemmas: stakeholders, values and options
Work through a real-life environmental dilemma in steps, name those affected, weigh the values, and justify a decision.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Questions in ethics papers and interviews often give a short case: a dam, a road through a forest, wild animals raiding crops, a plastic ban. There is no single correct answer, but there are better and worse ways of reasoning. This lesson gives a six-step method that you can apply to any case and shows it at work.
The six steps
- Facts. What is actually happening, and what is uncertain? Do not mix facts with opinions.
- Who is affected? List all stakeholders: people now, people in the future, animals, plants and ecosystems. Ask who has moral standing on different views.
- Values at stake. Which are instrumental (livelihood, water, money) and which intrinsic (the life of a species, a sacred place)?
- Options. List at least three: do nothing, a full solution and a middle path. Avoid choosing between only two extremes.
- Test. Apply the principles: fairness within this generation (intragenerational equity), fairness to the future, precaution, polluter pays, minimising harm.
- Decide and justify. State the choice, who gains and who bears costs, and how the costs will be reduced or shared.
Worked example 1: elephants and crops
Facts. Elephants raid the fields of 40 families near a forest and each family loses about Rs 15,000 of crops a year (illustrative), so the total loss is 40 × 15,000 = Rs 6,00,000. Affected: farmers, elephants, other forest animals, and the forest itself. Values: livelihoods (instrumental) and the elephants' own lives (intrinsic, on a sentientist or biocentric view). Options: (a) kill or drive away the elephants; (b) pay the farmers compensation each year; (c) build a fence and a warning system at a one-time cost of Rs 2,00,000 and keep a path open for the elephants to pass. Test: (a) harms the elephants and may break the law and moral standing. (b) is fair to the farmers, but the conflict continues. (c) costs a third of one year's loss (2,00,000 ÷ 6,00,000 = 1/3 of a year, so it repays itself in about four months) and protects both sides. Decision: choose (c), with compensation during the first season while the fence is built.
Worked example 2: banning plastic bags in a town
Facts: plastic bags choke drains and are eaten by stray cattle. Affected: shopkeepers, poor households that use cheap bags, rag-pickers who earn from waste, cattle, and the river downstream. Values: health and clean drains (instrumental), animals' welfare (intrinsic). Options: (a) ban at once; (b) a small charge for bags; (c) a ban with an advance period, cheap cloth or paper alternatives, and support for those who lose income. Test: (a) is fast, but may harm the poor unfairly. (b) uses a price signal but may not reach the poorest. (c) respects fairness among people now while protecting animals and the future. Decision: choose (c), and review the results after a year.
Common mistakes
- Choosing the first idea without listing options.
- Counting only humans, or only nature, but not both.
- Ignoring who pays the costs, especially poor people.
- Treating uncertainty as proof of safety.
Facts, stakeholders, values, options, test with principles, decide and justify. Always list at least three options and ask who bears the cost.
Key takeaways: separate facts from values, list everyone affected, compare options, test them with principles such as equity and precaution, and give a reasoned decision that shares costs fairly.
Check your understanding
-
1. What is the first step of the method?
- Establish the facts
- Choose the preferred option
- Ask who should pay
- Announce the decision
Show answer
Answer: A. Reasoning starts with the facts of the situation and what is uncertain.
-
2. Why should at least three options be listed?
- Because three is a legal requirement
- To delay the decision as long as possible
- To avoid a choice between two extremes
- Because stakeholders dislike short lists
Show answer
Answer: C. A middle path is often better than either extreme.
-
3. In the elephants case, a one-time cost of Rs 2,00,000 is compared with a yearly loss of Rs 6,00,000. The cost equals what fraction of a year's loss?
- One-half
- One-third
- Three times
- One-sixth
Show answer
Answer: B. 2,00,000 ÷ 6,00,000 = 1/3.
-
4. Which question belongs to the 'stakeholders' step?
- What did the budget cost last year?
- Which law was passed first in time?
- How tall is the tallest tree here?
- Who is affected, now and in future?
Show answer
Answer: D. This step lists everyone and everything affected by the decision.
-
5. Which is a common mistake in dilemma reasoning?
- Ignoring who bears the costs
- Listing several options
- Separating facts from values
- Applying the precautionary principle
Show answer
Answer: A. Overlooking who bears the cost, especially poor people, leads to unfair decisions.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.