• Foundation
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

A method for environmental dilemmas: stakeholders, values and options

Work through a real-life environmental dilemma in steps, name those affected, weigh the values, and justify a decision.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Questions in ethics papers and interviews often give a short case: a dam, a road through a forest, wild animals raiding crops, a plastic ban. There is no single correct answer, but there are better and worse ways of reasoning. This lesson gives a six-step method that you can apply to any case and shows it at work.

The six steps

  1. Facts. What is actually happening, and what is uncertain? Do not mix facts with opinions.
  2. Who is affected? List all stakeholders: people now, people in the future, animals, plants and ecosystems. Ask who has moral standing on different views.
  3. Values at stake. Which are instrumental (livelihood, water, money) and which intrinsic (the life of a species, a sacred place)?
  4. Options. List at least three: do nothing, a full solution and a middle path. Avoid choosing between only two extremes.
  5. Test. Apply the principles: fairness within this generation (intragenerational equity), fairness to the future, precaution, polluter pays, minimising harm.
  6. Decide and justify. State the choice, who gains and who bears costs, and how the costs will be reduced or shared.

Worked example 1: elephants and crops

Facts. Elephants raid the fields of 40 families near a forest and each family loses about Rs 15,000 of crops a year (illustrative), so the total loss is 40 × 15,000 = Rs 6,00,000. Affected: farmers, elephants, other forest animals, and the forest itself. Values: livelihoods (instrumental) and the elephants' own lives (intrinsic, on a sentientist or biocentric view). Options: (a) kill or drive away the elephants; (b) pay the farmers compensation each year; (c) build a fence and a warning system at a one-time cost of Rs 2,00,000 and keep a path open for the elephants to pass. Test: (a) harms the elephants and may break the law and moral standing. (b) is fair to the farmers, but the conflict continues. (c) costs a third of one year's loss (2,00,000 ÷ 6,00,000 = 1/3 of a year, so it repays itself in about four months) and protects both sides. Decision: choose (c), with compensation during the first season while the fence is built.

Worked example 2: banning plastic bags in a town

Facts: plastic bags choke drains and are eaten by stray cattle. Affected: shopkeepers, poor households that use cheap bags, rag-pickers who earn from waste, cattle, and the river downstream. Values: health and clean drains (instrumental), animals' welfare (intrinsic). Options: (a) ban at once; (b) a small charge for bags; (c) a ban with an advance period, cheap cloth or paper alternatives, and support for those who lose income. Test: (a) is fast, but may harm the poor unfairly. (b) uses a price signal but may not reach the poorest. (c) respects fairness among people now while protecting animals and the future. Decision: choose (c), and review the results after a year.

Common mistakes

  • Choosing the first idea without listing options.
  • Counting only humans, or only nature, but not both.
  • Ignoring who pays the costs, especially poor people.
  • Treating uncertainty as proof of safety.

Facts, stakeholders, values, options, test with principles, decide and justify. Always list at least three options and ask who bears the cost.

— Method to remember

Key takeaways: separate facts from values, list everyone affected, compare options, test them with principles such as equity and precaution, and give a reasoned decision that shares costs fairly.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What is the first step of the method?

    1. Establish the facts
    2. Choose the preferred option
    3. Ask who should pay
    4. Announce the decision
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Reasoning starts with the facts of the situation and what is uncertain.

  2. 2. Why should at least three options be listed?

    1. Because three is a legal requirement
    2. To delay the decision as long as possible
    3. To avoid a choice between two extremes
    4. Because stakeholders dislike short lists
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A middle path is often better than either extreme.

  3. 3. In the elephants case, a one-time cost of Rs 2,00,000 is compared with a yearly loss of Rs 6,00,000. The cost equals what fraction of a year's loss?

    1. One-half
    2. One-third
    3. Three times
    4. One-sixth
    Show answer

    Answer: B. 2,00,000 ÷ 6,00,000 = 1/3.

  4. 4. Which question belongs to the 'stakeholders' step?

    1. What did the budget cost last year?
    2. Which law was passed first in time?
    3. How tall is the tallest tree here?
    4. Who is affected, now and in future?
    Show answer

    Answer: D. This step lists everyone and everything affected by the decision.

  5. 5. Which is a common mistake in dilemma reasoning?

    1. Ignoring who bears the costs
    2. Listing several options
    3. Separating facts from values
    4. Applying the precautionary principle
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Overlooking who bears the cost, especially poor people, leads to unfair decisions.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery