• Foundation
  • About 12 min
  • 5 practice questions

What environmental ethics is: values and moral standing

Understand what environmental ethics studies, the difference between intrinsic and instrumental value, and what it means for something to have moral standing.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Every day people make choices that affect rivers, forests, animals and the air: whether to cut a tree for a new road, whether to throw waste into a stream, whether to protect a wetland that floods farmland. Science can tell us what will happen if we make each choice. It cannot, by itself, tell us which choice is right. That second question belongs to ethics. Environmental ethics is the branch of ethics that asks how human beings ought to behave towards the natural world, and why. This lesson gives you the basic vocabulary that the rest of the course uses.

Ethics in one sentence

Ethics is the study of right and wrong, good and bad, and the reasons behind our judgements. Ordinary ethics mostly deals with how people should treat other people: do not lie, do not steal, help those in need. Environmental ethics widens the question. It asks whether animals, plants, rivers, species and whole ecosystems also matter morally, and if they do, how much and in what way.

Environmental ethics grew into a separate field of study in the 1970s, when pollution, loss of forests and the extinction of species made many thinkers ask whether the old human-only ethics was enough. But the questions themselves are much older. Many religious and folk traditions, including several in India, have long taught respect for trees, rivers and animals.

Two kinds of value

The single most important idea in this subject is the difference between two kinds of value. Something has instrumental value when it is valuable as a means to something else. A forest has instrumental value because it gives timber, fuel, medicine and clean water to people. Something has intrinsic value when it is valuable in itself, as an end, whatever use it may or may not have for anyone. A person who says a tiger matters even if no human ever sees it or earns money from it is claiming that the tiger has intrinsic value.

Instrumental and intrinsic value
Kind of valueMeaningExample statement
InstrumentalValuable as a means to something elseMangroves are valuable because they protect coastal villages from storms.
IntrinsicValuable in itself, as an endA wild river is worth protecting for its own sake.

Moral standing

To have moral standing means to be the kind of thing whose interests or good must be taken into account when we decide what to do. Everyone agrees that human beings have moral standing. The big debates in environmental ethics are about who or what else has it. Different answers to this one question give the main schools of thought you will meet in the next lessons: human-centred views, life-centred views and ecosystem-centred views.

It also helps to separate moral agents from moral patients. A moral agent is someone who can understand right and wrong and be held responsible, such as an adult human. A moral patient is anything that can be wronged, even if it cannot itself act morally. A baby, a dog or, on some views, a tree can be a moral patient without being a moral agent.

Worked example 1: sorting the value claims

Classify each statement. Statement one: 'We must save the bees because without pollination our crops will fail.' Step 1: ask what the bees are valued for. Step 2: they are valued for crops, which serve people. Step 3: so this is an instrumental value claim. Statement two: 'Even an insect that is useless to us has a good of its own that we should respect.' Step 1: the insect is said to matter whether or not it is useful. Step 2: that is value in itself. Step 3: so this is an intrinsic value claim.

Worked example 2: who has moral standing?

A village debates draining a pond to build a market. Rekha argues that the pond should be kept because the villagers' cattle drink from it. Imran argues that the frogs and birds living there would be harmed, and that their harm counts even apart from the villagers. Step 1: Rekha only counts the interests of people, since the cattle matter as the villagers' property. Step 2: Imran gives moral standing to the frogs and birds themselves. Step 3: so Rekha's argument is human-centred, while Imran's extends moral standing beyond humans. Both may reach the same decision, to keep the pond, for very different reasons.

Instrumental value = valuable as a means (useful to someone). Intrinsic value = valuable in itself. Moral standing = deserving to be counted when we decide what to do.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

Environmental ethics asks how humans ought to treat nature and why. Separate the factual question (what will happen) from the ethical question (what we should do). Learn the two kinds of value thoroughly, because almost every question in this subject turns on whether something is valued for its use or for itself. Finally, the main schools differ mainly in how widely they draw the circle of moral standing.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Environmental ethics mainly asks which of these questions?

    1. How fast a forest grows each year
    2. How humans ought to behave towards the natural world, and why
    3. Which rocks are found in a river bed
    4. How rainfall is measured
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Measuring growth, rocks or rainfall are scientific questions. Environmental ethics asks the moral question of how we ought to act towards nature and the reasons for it.

  2. 2. 'Wetlands are valuable because they clean water for nearby towns.' What kind of value does this statement give wetlands?

    1. Intrinsic value
    2. No value at all
    3. Aesthetic value only
    4. Instrumental value
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The wetland is valued for what it does for the towns, that is as a means to clean water. Value as a means is instrumental value.

  3. 3. Something that is valuable in itself, whatever its usefulness, is said to have:

    1. Intrinsic value
    2. Instrumental value
    3. Market value
    4. Exchange value
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Intrinsic value is value as an end, in itself. Instrumental, market and exchange value all depend on usefulness to someone.

  4. 4. A newborn baby cannot judge right from wrong but can certainly be harmed. In ethical terms the baby is:

    1. A moral agent but not a moral patient
    2. Neither a moral agent nor a moral patient
    3. A moral patient but not a moral agent
    4. Without any moral standing
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A moral agent can be held responsible for actions; a baby cannot. A moral patient can be wronged; a baby can. So the baby is a moral patient only.

  5. 5. Two people both oppose cutting an old grove. One says the grove gives shade to travellers; the other says the trees have a good of their own. What is the correct conclusion?

    1. They disagree on the decision
    2. Both are giving intrinsic value reasons
    3. They agree on the decision but give different kinds of value as reasons
    4. Both are giving instrumental value reasons
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Both oppose cutting, so the decision is the same. Shade for travellers is instrumental value; the trees' own good is intrinsic value.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery