• Foundation
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Deep ecology and intergenerational equity

Explain Arne Naess's deep ecology and its contrast with shallow ecology, and the idea that we owe fairness to future generations.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By now you know three ways to draw the moral circle. This lesson adds two ideas that appear often in questions on environmental ethics. The first, deep ecology, is a whole philosophy of how humans should see themselves in nature. The second, intergenerational equity, is about fairness between people alive today and people not yet born.

Shallow and deep ecology

The Norwegian philosopher Arne Naess introduced the terms in a short paper in 1973. He called the mainstream environmental movement 'shallow': it fights pollution and resource depletion mainly to protect the health and wealth of people in rich countries. Shallow ecology is therefore human-centred. 'Deep' ecology asks deeper questions about why we value nature at all, and answers that all living beings have value in themselves, independent of their usefulness to humans.

Naess's contrast
FeatureShallow ecologyDeep ecology
Main concernPollution and resources, for human benefitThe flourishing of all life for its own sake
Value of natureMostly instrumentalIntrinsic
Typical responseTechnical fixes within the present way of lifeDeep change in values, lifestyles and the scale of human impact

Key ideas of deep ecology

  • Intrinsic value of all life: the richness and diversity of life forms are valuable in themselves.
  • Vital needs: humans have no right to reduce this richness and diversity except to satisfy vital needs.
  • Self-realisation: a person matures by identifying with ever wider circles, from family to community to all living things, so that harming nature comes to feel like harming oneself.
  • Biospheric egalitarianism (in principle): no life form is ranked above another merely because of its usefulness to humans.
  • Ecosophy: Naess's word for a personal philosophy of ecological harmony.

Deep ecology is usually classed with ecocentric thinking, because it values the whole web of life and calls for wide changes in society. In exams, remember the pairing: Naess, 1973, shallow versus deep, self-realisation. Do not confuse Naess with Leopold, whose key words are land ethic, biotic community, integrity, stability and beauty.

Intergenerational equity

Equity means fairness. Intergenerational equity is the idea that each generation should use the earth in a way that is fair to the generations that follow. We inherited forests, soils, rivers and a stable climate from earlier generations; we hold them, in a sense, in trust for those who come after. Using them up, or leaving behind long-lasting pollution, passes costs to people who had no say.

The idea lies behind the most quoted definition of sustainable development, from the Brundtland Commission's report Our Common Future (1987). In paraphrase: development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs. Fairness among people of the same generation, for example between rich and poor today, is called intragenerational equity. Notice the prefixes: inter means between generations, intra means within one.

Worked example 1: deep or shallow?

A city plans to reduce smog by switching buses to cleaner fuel 'so that residents breathe easier and hospital costs fall'. Step 1: what is the reason given? Human health and costs. Step 2: is the value of nature intrinsic here? No, the air matters as it affects people. Step 3: the reasoning is shallow ecology in Naess's sense. It is a good policy, but its justification is human-centred.

Worked example 2: inter or intra?

Case A: a rule that a mine must leave enough groundwater for villages that will exist fifty years from now. Case B: a rule that clean drinking water must reach poor and rich neighbourhoods of a town equally today. Step 1: Case A compares present and future people, so it concerns intergenerational equity. Step 2: Case B compares groups living now, so it concerns intragenerational equity. Step 3: sustainable development needs both kinds of fairness.

Naess (1973): shallow ecology protects nature for human benefit; deep ecology values all life in itself and seeks self-realisation. Intergenerational equity: be fair to future generations; intragenerational: be fair within the present one.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

Deep ecology, founded by Arne Naess, contrasts with human-centred 'shallow' environmentalism and holds that all life has intrinsic value and may be reduced only for vital needs. Intergenerational equity asks each generation to leave the earth fit for the next; it underlies the Brundtland idea of sustainable development.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The terms 'shallow ecology' and 'deep ecology' were introduced by:

    1. Arne Naess
    2. Aldo Leopold
    3. Rachel Carson
    4. Albert Schweitzer
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The Norwegian philosopher Arne Naess introduced the contrast in 1973.

  2. 2. In Naess's sense, shallow ecology is mainly concerned with:

    1. The intrinsic value of all life forms
    2. Changing the basic values of society
    3. Fighting pollution and resource depletion for the benefit of people
    4. Treating every species as sacred
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Shallow ecology is human-centred: it protects nature mostly for human health and wealth.

  3. 3. According to deep ecology, humans may reduce the richness and diversity of life only to:

    1. Increase profits
    2. Meet any human preference
    3. Build more cities
    4. Satisfy vital needs
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Deep ecology's principle is that the richness and diversity of life may be reduced only to satisfy vital needs.

  4. 4. A rule requiring today's farmers to leave the soil fertile for farmers a hundred years from now expresses:

    1. Intergenerational equity
    2. Intragenerational equity
    3. Strong anthropocentrism
    4. Shallow ecology
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Fairness between present and future generations is intergenerational equity; intragenerational equity is fairness within the present generation.

  5. 5. The definition of sustainable development as meeting present needs without compromising the ability of future generations to meet theirs comes from:

    1. Aldo Leopold's A Sand County Almanac (1949)
    2. The Brundtland Commission's report Our Common Future (1987)
    3. Arne Naess's 1973 paper
    4. Rachel Carson's Silent Spring (1962)
    Show answer

    Answer: B. This widely quoted definition is from Our Common Future, the 1987 report of the Brundtland Commission.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery