- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Biocentrism, ecocentrism and Leopold's land ethic
Distinguish life-centred (biocentric) and ecosystem-centred (ecocentric) ethics and explain Aldo Leopold's land ethic.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
In the last lesson the circle of moral standing contained only humans. Many environmental thinkers argued that this circle is drawn too small. This lesson widens it in two steps: first to every living thing, which is biocentrism, and then to whole ecosystems, which is ecocentrism. The most famous ecocentric idea, Aldo Leopold's land ethic, is a favourite topic in exams.
Biocentrism: every living thing counts
Biocentrism (from Greek bios, life) says that every individual living organism has intrinsic value and moral standing, because each one has a good of its own. A plant grows towards light, repairs damage and reproduces; things can go well or badly for it, even though it feels nothing. On this view, a tree, an ant and a human all have value in themselves.
Two names are linked with this view. The thinker and doctor Albert Schweitzer taught 'reverence for life': all life deserves respect, and we should not destroy it without real necessity. The philosopher Paul Taylor later argued that every living organism is a 'teleological centre of life', meaning it pursues its own good in its own way, and that no species is inherently superior to another.
Notice what biocentrism counts: individual organisms. It does not by itself give value to a species as such, to a river, or to a whole forest considered as a system.
Ecocentrism: the whole system counts
Ecocentrism (from Greek oikos, house or home, the same root as ecology) gives moral standing to ecological wholes: ecosystems, species, landscapes and the biosphere. It includes the non-living parts too, such as soil, water and air, since these are part of the system. Ecocentrism is called a holistic view, because it puts the good of the whole first. Biocentrism and anthropocentrism, by contrast, are individualistic: they count individual beings.
Aldo Leopold's land ethic
Aldo Leopold was an American forester and ecologist. His book A Sand County Almanac, published in 1949 shortly after his death, contains an essay called 'The Land Ethic'. Leopold argued that ethics has gradually widened over history and should now widen once more, to include soils, waters, plants and animals, which he called collectively 'the land'. Humans should see themselves not as conquerors of the land community but as plain members and citizens of it.
Leopold's test of right action, in paraphrase: an action is right when it tends to preserve the integrity, stability and beauty of the biotic community, and wrong when it tends to do otherwise. This test judges an action by its effect on the whole community, which is why the land ethic is the classic example of ecocentrism.
| View | Who has moral standing | Individual or holistic |
|---|---|---|
| Anthropocentrism | Humans only | Individualistic |
| Biocentrism | Every living organism | Individualistic |
| Ecocentrism (e.g. land ethic) | Ecosystems, species and the biotic community as a whole | Holistic |
Worked example 1: classify the reasons
A team argues about removing a weed that has spread through a lake and is choking native fish and plants. Arun: 'Each weed plant is alive and has its own good, so killing them is a real loss.' Meena: 'The lake as a whole is losing its stability and variety of life, so the weed should be cleared.' Step 1: Arun counts individual living plants, so his reasoning is biocentric. Step 2: Meena counts the health of the whole lake community, so her reasoning is ecocentric. Step 3: notice they reach opposite conclusions here, which shows that the two views can clash.
Worked example 2: apply Leopold's test
Should a company drain a marsh to build a factory? Step 1: Leopold's test asks about integrity (are the native parts kept?), stability (will the system keep functioning?) and beauty. Step 2: draining removes the marsh's plants, birds and water flow, so integrity and stability are lost. Step 3: by the land ethic the drainage is wrong. Notice that profit or jobs are not part of Leopold's test, although an anthropocentrist would weigh them.
Biocentrism counts every individual living thing. Ecocentrism counts the whole: ecosystems, species, the land. Leopold: right = tends to preserve the integrity, stability and beauty of the biotic community.
Key takeaways
Biocentrism (Schweitzer's reverence for life, Taylor's centres of life) gives intrinsic value to each living organism. Ecocentrism gives value to ecological wholes and is holistic. Aldo Leopold's land ethic, from A Sand County Almanac (1949), asks humans to be plain members of the land community and judges actions by integrity, stability and beauty.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which view gives intrinsic value to every individual living organism?
- Anthropocentrism
- Biocentrism
- Ecocentrism
- Strong anthropocentrism
Show answer
Answer: B. Biocentrism (bios = life) gives moral standing to each living organism. Ecocentrism focuses on wholes; anthropocentrism on humans.
-
2. Aldo Leopold's land ethic appears in which book?
- Silent Spring
- Our Common Future
- The Population Bomb
- A Sand County Almanac
Show answer
Answer: D. 'The Land Ethic' is an essay in A Sand County Almanac (1949). Silent Spring is by Rachel Carson; Our Common Future is the Brundtland Report.
-
3. According to Leopold, an action is right when it tends to preserve:
- The greatest happiness of the greatest number of people
- The economic value of the land
- The life of every individual organism
- The integrity, stability and beauty of the biotic community
Show answer
Answer: D. Leopold's test looks at the whole biotic community: integrity, stability and beauty.
-
4. Why is ecocentrism called a holistic view?
- It counts only whole human beings
- It gives priority to the good of ecological wholes such as ecosystems and species
- It treats every individual plant as equal to a human
- It says nature has no value
Show answer
Answer: B. Holistic views judge by the good of the whole system, not of each individual member.
-
5. 'Reverence for life' is the idea most associated with:
- Aldo Leopold
- Arne Naess
- Albert Schweitzer
- Garrett Hardin
Show answer
Answer: C. Albert Schweitzer taught reverence for life, a biocentric attitude of respect for all living things.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.