• Foundation
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Indian traditions: need versus greed, the Bishnois and Chipko

Connect environmental ethics to Indian ideas and examples: Gandhi's distinction between need and greed, the Bishnoi tradition and the Chipko movement.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Environmental ethics is not only a Western subject. Indian thought and Indian village communities have long expressed respect for nature, and two Indian examples, the Bishnois and the Chipko movement, are known around the world. This lesson links them to the concepts you have learnt, so that you can explain not just what happened but which ethical idea it shows.

Gandhi: need versus greed

Mahatma Gandhi is widely remembered for the idea, often quoted in paraphrase, that the earth provides enough to satisfy every person's needs but not every person's greed. The point is a distinction between need, what is required for a decent, simple life, and greed, the endless wish for more. Gandhi favoured simple living, self-reliant village economies and limiting wants, and he held that the rich should regard their wealth as held in trust for society, an idea known as trusteeship.

Notice how close this is to ideas you have met. Limiting consumption to genuine needs echoes deep ecology's 'vital needs' principle. Holding wealth in trust echoes stewardship and intergenerational equity: what we have is not simply ours to use up.

The Bishnoi tradition

The Bishnoi community of western Rajasthan follows the teachings of Guru Jambheshwar, also called Jambhoji, who founded the sect in the late fifteenth century. The name is commonly explained as 'twenty-nine', for the twenty-nine principles followers keep. Several of these principles protect nature: do not cut green trees, and show compassion to all living beings. Bishnoi villages are known for protecting the khejri tree and animals such as the blackbuck and chinkara.

The most famous event is the Khejarli sacrifice of 1730. When soldiers came to cut khejri trees for the ruler of Jodhpur, a woman named Amrita Devi hugged a tree to protect it and was killed; many other Bishnois followed her example and lost their lives, and the cutting was finally stopped. The story shows a community treating trees as worthy of protection even at the cost of human life.

The Chipko movement

The Chipko movement began in 1973 in the hills of what is now Uttarakhand. 'Chipko' means 'to stick' or 'to hug': villagers, many of them women, hugged trees to stop them from being felled by contractors. Well-known names linked with it include Chandi Prasad Bhatt, Gaura Devi, who led the women of Reni village, and Sunderlal Bahuguna, who carried its message far and wide. The movement drew attention to the link between forests and the soil, water, fodder and fuel on which hill communities depend.

Indian examples and the ideas they show
ExampleMain actorsEthical ideas it illustrates
Bishnoi tradition and Khejarli (1730)Bishnoi community, Amrita DeviReligious respect for trees and animals; moral standing beyond humans
Chipko movement (from 1973)Hill villagers, especially womenCommunity rights to forests; non-violent protest; nature and livelihood linked
Gandhian thoughtMahatma GandhiNeed versus greed, simple living, trusteeship

Worked example 1: name the ethical idea

Question: a Bishnoi family refuses to cut a khejri tree even though it blocks light from their field. Which idea fits best? Step 1: the tree is not being kept for profit or use; it is kept because harming it is seen as wrong in itself. Step 2: respecting a living thing for itself is a claim of intrinsic value and moral standing beyond humans. Step 3: so the action reflects a biocentric attitude, rooted in religious principle, not a strong anthropocentric one.

Worked example 2: Chipko read two ways

Chipko women said their forests gave them fodder, fuel, water and soil. Step 1: these are reasons based on human livelihoods, so part of Chipko's ethics is enlightened anthropocentric: forests matter to communities in the long run. Step 2: the movement's non-violent methods and its respect for the forest also drew on Gandhian ideas. Step 3: so the best description is a non-violent, community-led movement joining livelihood and conservation, not simply a 'nature-only' movement. Real movements often mix ethical reasons.

Gandhi: the earth is enough for need, not for greed. Bishnois: twenty-nine principles, Khejarli 1730, Amrita Devi. Chipko: 1973, hugging trees, hill villagers and especially women, non-violent.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

Indian ideas and movements give clear examples of environmental ethics in practice. Gandhi's need-versus-greed distinction and trusteeship connect to simple living and fairness to others. The Bishnoi tradition shows religious protection of trees and animals; the Chipko movement shows non-violent community action that joined forest protection with livelihoods.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The idea that the earth provides enough for everyone's needs but not for everyone's greed is associated with:

    1. Aldo Leopold
    2. Mahatma Gandhi
    3. Arne Naess
    4. Sunderlal Bahuguna
    Show answer

    Answer: B. This need-versus-greed idea is widely attributed to Gandhi and fits his ideal of simple living.

  2. 2. Gandhi's idea that the rich should hold their wealth in trust for the good of society is called:

    1. Stewardship
    2. Self-realisation
    3. Land ethic
    4. Trusteeship
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Gandhi called this idea trusteeship. Stewardship is a related idea about caring for the earth; self-realisation belongs to deep ecology.

  3. 3. The Bishnoi community follows the teachings of:

    1. Guru Jambheshwar
    2. Mahatma Gandhi
    3. Chandi Prasad Bhatt
    4. Sunderlal Bahuguna
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Guru Jambheshwar (Jambhoji) founded the Bishnoi sect in the late fifteenth century.

  4. 4. Amrita Devi is remembered for:

    1. Starting the Chipko movement in 1973
    2. Writing A Sand County Almanac
    3. Giving her life to protect khejri trees at Khejarli in 1730
    4. Leading the women of Reni village
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Amrita Devi led the Bishnoi sacrifice at Khejarli in 1730. Gaura Devi led the women of Reni during Chipko.

  5. 5. The word 'Chipko' refers to the protesters' method of:

    1. Planting new trees each year
    2. Writing petitions to the government
    3. Hugging trees to stop them being cut
    4. Blocking roads with stones
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Chipko means to stick or hug: villagers hugged trees to prevent felling.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery