Revision notes

Environmental Ethics: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 9 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

What environmental ethics is: values and moral standing

Instrumental and intrinsic value
Kind of valueMeaningExample statement
InstrumentalValuable as a means to something elseMangroves are valuable because they protect coastal villages from storms.
IntrinsicValuable in itself, as an endA wild river is worth protecting for its own sake.

Instrumental value = valuable as a means (useful to someone). Intrinsic value = valuable in itself. Moral standing = deserving to be counted when we decide what to do.

— Rule to remember

Environmental ethics asks how humans ought to treat nature and why. Separate the factual question (what will happen) from the ethical question (what we should do). Learn the two kinds of value thoroughly, because almost every question in this subject turns on whether something is valued for its use or for itself. Finally, the main schools differ mainly in how widely they draw the circle of moral standing.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Anthropocentrism: the human-centred view

Two versions of the human-centred view
FeatureStrong anthropocentrismWeak (enlightened) anthropocentrism
Who countsHumans onlyHumans only
Which human interestsPresent wants and preferencesLong-term, considered interests, including future people
Typical attitude to a forestUse it if people want its timber nowUse it wisely so that it keeps serving people for generations

Anthropocentrism answers 'who counts?' with 'humans only'. It does not by itself decide whether to protect or use nature: the strong version counts present wants, the weak (enlightened) version counts long-term human interests.

— Rule to remember

Anthropocentrism gives intrinsic value and full moral standing only to humans. Strong anthropocentrism looks at present wants; weak anthropocentrism looks at long-term, considered human interests, including those of future generations. Stewardship pictures humans as responsible caretakers. Never equate anthropocentrism with destruction: read carefully which human interests an argument counts.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Biocentrism, ecocentrism and Leopold's land ethic

Three ways of drawing the moral circle
ViewWho has moral standingIndividual or holistic
AnthropocentrismHumans onlyIndividualistic
BiocentrismEvery living organismIndividualistic
Ecocentrism (e.g. land ethic)Ecosystems, species and the biotic community as a wholeHolistic

Biocentrism counts every individual living thing. Ecocentrism counts the whole: ecosystems, species, the land. Leopold: right = tends to preserve the integrity, stability and beauty of the biotic community.

— Rule to remember

Biocentrism (Schweitzer's reverence for life, Taylor's centres of life) gives intrinsic value to each living organism. Ecocentrism gives value to ecological wholes and is holistic. Aldo Leopold's land ethic, from A Sand County Almanac (1949), asks humans to be plain members of the land community and judges actions by integrity, stability and beauty.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Deep ecology and intergenerational equity

Naess's contrast
FeatureShallow ecologyDeep ecology
Main concernPollution and resources, for human benefitThe flourishing of all life for its own sake
Value of natureMostly instrumentalIntrinsic
Typical responseTechnical fixes within the present way of lifeDeep change in values, lifestyles and the scale of human impact

Naess (1973): shallow ecology protects nature for human benefit; deep ecology values all life in itself and seeks self-realisation. Intergenerational equity: be fair to future generations; intragenerational: be fair within the present one.

— Rule to remember

Deep ecology, founded by Arne Naess, contrasts with human-centred 'shallow' environmentalism and holds that all life has intrinsic value and may be reduced only for vital needs. Intergenerational equity asks each generation to leave the earth fit for the next; it underlies the Brundtland idea of sustainable development.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Indian traditions: need versus greed, the Bishnois and Chipko

Indian examples and the ideas they show
ExampleMain actorsEthical ideas it illustrates
Bishnoi tradition and Khejarli (1730)Bishnoi community, Amrita DeviReligious respect for trees and animals; moral standing beyond humans
Chipko movement (from 1973)Hill villagers, especially womenCommunity rights to forests; non-violent protest; nature and livelihood linked
Gandhian thoughtMahatma GandhiNeed versus greed, simple living, trusteeship

Gandhi: the earth is enough for need, not for greed. Bishnois: twenty-nine principles, Khejarli 1730, Amrita Devi. Chipko: 1973, hugging trees, hill villagers and especially women, non-violent.

— Rule to remember

Indian ideas and movements give clear examples of environmental ethics in practice. Gandhi's need-versus-greed distinction and trusteeship connect to simple living and fairness to others. The Bishnoi tradition shows religious protection of trees and animals; the Chipko movement shows non-violent community action that joined forest protection with livelihoods.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 6

Animal ethics: sentience, welfare and rights

Three positions
ViewWhat it allowsKey idea
Animal welfareUsing animals for human purposes, as long as suffering is kept lowBe humane; avoid unnecessary cruelty
Singer (equal consideration)Actions whose total benefit outweighs the suffering, counting animals' interests equallyCount suffering equally, whoever suffers
Regan (animal rights)Does not allow treating subjects-of-a-life merely as meansAnimals have inherent value and rights

Sentience = ability to feel. Singer: equal consideration of interests (utilitarian). Regan: subjects-of-a-life have rights. Welfare: use but do not be cruel.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: sentientism draws the moral circle at the capacity to suffer; Singer and Regan both defend animals but for different reasons; and animal welfare allows use, while animal rights does not allow treating animals merely as means.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 7

Indian traditions of respect for nature: ahimsa, compassion and sacred living

Connecting old ideas to modern concepts
IdeaSourceLink to modern concept
AhimsaJain, Buddhist and Hindu traditions; GandhiMoral standing beyond humans; sentientism
InterdependenceBuddhist thoughtEcology; ecocentrism
Sacred groves and riversHindu and tribal traditionsCommunity conservation; intrinsic value
ModerationBuddhist middle way; Gandhi's need versus greedDeep ecology's vital needs; sustainability

Ahimsa = non-violence. Jainism takes it furthest; Buddhism stresses compassion and interdependence; Hindu and tribal traditions protect sacred trees, rivers and groves; Ashoka's edicts protected animals and forests.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: Indian traditions provide ideas of non-violence, compassion, interdependence and moderation that support environmental care; match each to its modern parallel; and remember that belief alone is not enough without practice.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 8

Principles that put ethics into practice: precaution, polluter pays and public trust

Three working principles
PrincipleCore ideaSimple test question
PrecautionAct to prevent serious or irreversible harm even without full proofCould the harm be grave and permanent?
Polluter paysThe one who pollutes bears the costWho caused the harm and who is paying?
Public trustShared natural resources are held in trust for the publicIs a common resource being given away for private use?

Precaution: do not wait for certainty when harm may be grave and irreversible. Polluter pays: the one who causes it bears the cost. Public trust: the state holds shared resources for the public.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: these three principles turn ethical ideas, such as fairness and responsibility to the future, into usable tests; apply them by asking the simple test questions in the table.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 9

A method for environmental dilemmas: stakeholders, values and options

Facts, stakeholders, values, options, test with principles, decide and justify. Always list at least three options and ask who bears the cost.

— Method to remember

Key takeaways: separate facts from values, list everyone affected, compare options, test them with principles such as equity and precaution, and give a reasoned decision that shares costs fairly.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery