• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

The waste hierarchy in practice: ranking options and diversion rates

Place any action correctly in the waste hierarchy, avoid the reuse-recycle and recycle-recover traps, and calculate recycling and diversion rates with the right denominator.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Knowing the order reduce, reuse, recycle, recover, dispose is not enough. Exam questions describe a real action and ask where it fits, or give a town's figures and ask for a rate. This lesson sharpens both: the boundaries between steps, and the arithmetic of rates.

Drawing the boundaries

Reduce (prevention) acts before waste exists: lighter packaging, buying only what is needed, repairing, sharing. Reuse means using an item again as it is, for the same or a new purpose, with no reprocessing of its material: refilling bottles, using jars as containers, passing on clothes. Recycling breaks the item down into raw material for a new product: pulping paper, melting glass and metals, regranulating plastic. Composting is usually counted with recycling, because the material of organic waste returns to the soil. Recovery gets energy (or other value) from waste that is not recycled, such as incineration with electricity generation. Disposal is landfilling with nothing recovered.

Three boundary traps recur. First, 'recycling is the best option' is wrong; reduction and reuse rank higher. Second, burning waste to make electricity is recovery, not recycling - the material is destroyed, only energy is captured. Third, the test for reuse versus recycling is whether the material is reprocessed. A plastic tub kept as a lunch box is reused; the same tub shredded into pellets is recycled. Also note downcycling: recycling into a lower-grade product, for example office paper into tissue or egg trays, which cannot easily be recycled again.

Rates and the denominator trap

A recycling (or diversion) rate is a share: amount recycled and composted divided by a total, times 100. The trap is the total. 'Of waste generated' includes waste never collected; 'of waste collected' leaves it out, so the second figure always looks better. Read the question for which total it wants, and write the fraction before calculating. Speed tip: if both parts are in tonnes, cancel common factors first.

Worked example 1: ranking options for old clothes

Rank these from best to worst: (a) buying fewer, longer-lasting clothes; (b) giving old clothes to a relative; (c) shredding old clothes into fibre for mattress stuffing; (d) burning them in a waste-to-energy plant; (e) landfilling them. (a) prevents waste - reduce. (b) uses them again unchanged - reuse. (c) reprocesses the material - recycle, in fact downcycling. (d) captures only energy - recover. (e) disposal. Order: a, b, c, d, e.

Worked example 2: rates for a town

Illustrative figures: a town generates 120 tonnes of waste a day and collects 100 tonnes. Of the collected waste, 30 tonnes are composted, 15 tonnes are recycled, 10 tonnes go to a waste-to-energy plant and 45 tonnes are landfilled. Recycling plus composting = 45 tonnes. As a share of waste collected: 45 / 100 = 45%. As a share of waste generated: 45 / 120 = 37.5%. Diversion from landfill, counting energy recovery as well: (45 + 10) / 100 = 55% of collected waste. The uncollected 20 tonnes are not landfilled, but they are not managed either - they are likely dumped or burnt - so they should never be counted as 'diverted'.

Reuse keeps the material as it is; recycling reprocesses it; recovery keeps only energy. Always check whether a rate is of waste generated or of waste collected.

Key takeaways

  • Composting counts with recycling; waste-to-energy is recovery.
  • Reuse versus recycle: was the material reprocessed?
  • Downcycling gives a lower-grade product.
  • The same tonnage gives a lower rate against waste generated than against waste collected.

Key takeaways: identify the step by asking what happens to the material, and write the fraction with its correct denominator before you divide.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A city burns non-recyclable waste in a plant that generates electricity. In the waste hierarchy this is

    1. Recycling
    2. Reuse
    3. Recovery
    4. Reduction
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The material is destroyed and only energy is captured, so it is recovery, which ranks below recycling.

  2. 2. Using an empty jam jar to store spices at home is

    1. Reuse
    2. Recycling
    3. Recovery
    4. Disposal
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The jar is used again as it is, without reprocessing its glass, so it is reuse.

  3. 3. Which pair is in the correct order, more preferred first?

    1. Recycle, then reduce
    2. Reuse, then recycle
    3. Dispose, then recover
    4. Recover, then reuse
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The hierarchy is reduce, reuse, recycle, recover, dispose. Only 'reuse, then recycle' follows it.

  4. 4. Illustrative figures: a town generates 200 tonnes of waste; 30 tonnes are recycled and 50 tonnes are composted. What is the combined recycling and composting rate as a share of waste generated?

    1. 25%
    2. 15%
    3. 60%
    4. 40%
    Show answer

    Answer: D. (30 + 50) / 200 x 100 = 80 / 200 x 100 = 40%. 25% uses composting alone; 15% uses recycling alone.

  5. 5. Illustrative figures: a town generates 150 tonnes, collects 120 tonnes, and recycles or composts 36 tonnes. What share of the waste GENERATED is recycled or composted?

    1. 24%
    2. 30%
    3. 80%
    4. 36%
    Show answer

    Answer: A. 36 / 150 x 100 = 24%. 30% is the share of waste collected (36 / 120), and 80% is the collection rate.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery