- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Attitude, belief, opinion and value: telling them apart
Distinguish an attitude from a belief, an opinion and a value, use Rokeach's terminal and instrumental values, and see how values stand behind attitudes and conduct.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Everyday speech uses 'attitude', 'belief', 'opinion' and 'value' as if they meant the same thing. In ethics papers they do not. Mixing them up leads to muddled answers, such as calling honesty an attitude or a passing remark a value. This lesson separates the four ideas, shows how they connect, and explains why values matter most for a public servant.
Four ideas, four jobs
A belief is a conviction that something is true or false: 'regular exercise improves health', 'the bridge will be ready by monsoon'. A belief states what a person takes to be a fact. It need not carry any approval or dislike, and it can be right or wrong. An attitude, as you know, is a lasting evaluation of an object as favourable or unfavourable. Beliefs about the object often feed it, but the attitude adds the 'for' or 'against'. An opinion is a particular judgement that a person states about a particular issue at a particular time, for example 'this flyover is a waste of money'. An opinion is the visible, often verbal, expression of an attitude, and it is usually easier to change. A value is a deep and lasting conviction about what is worth striving for or what conduct is right, for example honesty, equality or freedom.
The psychologist Milton Rokeach defined a value as an enduring belief that a particular way of behaving, or a particular end-state of existence, is personally or socially preferable to its opposite. He divided values into two kinds. Terminal values are goals worth reaching, such as freedom, equality, peace or a sense of accomplishment. Instrumental values are preferred ways of behaving that help us reach those goals, such as being honest, responsible, courageous, helpful or broad-minded.
| Idea | What it is | Scope | How stable |
|---|---|---|---|
| Value | A deep conviction about what is worth striving for or how to act | General, few in number | Very stable |
| Attitude | A lasting favourable or unfavourable evaluation of an object | Tied to an object, many in number | Fairly stable |
| Belief | A conviction that something is true | Any statement of fact | Varies with evidence |
| Opinion | A stated judgement on a current issue | Specific, on the surface | Changes easily |
How they fit together
Values sit at the base. Because we value fairness, we form favourable attitudes towards institutions and people we see as fair, and unfavourable ones towards those we see as unfair. Attitudes in turn produce opinions in conversation, and together with the situation they shape behaviour. This is why the value-expressive function in Katz's list matters: many attitudes exist to show what a person cares about. It also explains why changing a surface opinion is easy, changing an attitude is harder, and changing a value is slow and often painful.
Rule to remember: values are few, deep and lasting; attitudes are many and aimed at objects; beliefs say what is true; opinions are attitudes put into words on a particular issue.
Worked example 1: which is which?
Classify four statements. (a) 'Regular exercise improves health.' This claims a fact, so it is a belief. (b) 'I find working under a much younger boss unpleasant.' This is a lasting evaluation of an object (a type of boss), so it is an attitude. (c) 'I think the new parking rule is unfair, and I will say so at today's meeting.' This is a judgement on one issue put into words, so it is an opinion. (d) 'Honesty must come before success.' This states a preferred way of acting that applies across situations, so it is an (instrumental) value.
Worked example 2: a value in conflict with an attitude
Deepak is a district official who values fairness in public dealing, an instrumental value. Over the years he has also formed an unfavourable attitude towards a particular group of contractors, based on a few bad experiences. A fresh bid from one of these contractors arrives with the lowest price and complete papers. Step 1: name the conflict, which is between a value (fairness) and an attitude (distrust of the group). Step 2: ask which should guide the decision. Values stand behind attitudes and are more central, so the value of fairness should decide, and he should judge this bid on evidence. Step 3: later, examine where the attitude came from, because a prejudice formed from a few experiences may need to change. The ethical officer lets the value correct the attitude, not the reverse.
Key takeaways. A belief is about truth, an attitude is about favour, an opinion is a stated judgement, and a value is a deep standard of what matters. Rokeach separated terminal values (goals) from instrumental values (ways of acting). In a conflict, a public servant lets deep values correct narrow attitudes.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of these statements is best described as a belief rather than an attitude?
- I dislike night shifts intensely
- Lack of sleep reduces alertness
- Night shifts are an unfair burden
- I will never accept a night posting
Show answer
Answer: B. A belief claims that something is true or false. "Lack of sleep reduces alertness" states a factual claim (a belief). The others express dislike, a judgement of unfairness or a decision, which belong to attitudes and opinions.
-
2. In Rokeach's classification, being honest or responsible is an example of:
- A terminal value
- A belief about facts
- A short-term opinion
- An instrumental value
Show answer
Answer: D. Instrumental values are preferred ways of behaving, such as honesty and responsibility. Terminal values are end-states such as freedom or equality.
-
3. 'I think the new fee structure is wrong and I will say so.' Which term fits best?
- An opinion
- A terminal value
- A habit
- A trait
Show answer
Answer: A. It is a judgement on a particular issue, put into words. Such a stated judgement is an opinion, and it expresses an underlying attitude.
-
4. Which of the four ideas is the most stable and the most central to a person's identity?
- Opinions
- Beliefs about current events
- Values
- Attitudes towards a single product
Show answer
Answer: C. Values are few, general and deeply held, so they change slowly. Opinions change most easily, and attitudes towards specific objects lie between.
-
5. A manager values fairness but dislikes a certain group of applicants without good reason. What should an ethical manager do?
- Follow the dislike, since attitudes are stronger
- Ignore the value, since it is only an opinion
- Avoid deciding, since both are equal
- Test the dislike against the value and decide on evidence
Show answer
Answer: D. Values are deeper than attitudes and should correct them. The manager should examine the dislike, set it aside and decide on the merits of each applicant.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.