• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Consistency theories: Heider's balance theory and Bem's self-perception theory

Use Heider's triad of person, other and object to test whether a set of attitudes is balanced, see how imbalance is resolved, and compare Bem's view that people infer their own attitudes from their behaviour with dissonance theory.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

People like their views to fit together. We prefer to agree with friends we like, and we find it odd to admire someone while disliking everything they do. Psychologists call the family of ideas built on this preference cognitive consistency theories. You already know Festinger's cognitive dissonance. This lesson adds two more, Heider's balance theory and Bem's self-perception theory, and shows how all three explain how attitudes change.

Heider's balance theory

Fritz Heider looked at a triangle of three elements: P, the person whose view we study; O, another person; and X, an object, idea or issue. Each of the three links is either positive (+) when P likes O, P favours X, or O favours X, or negative (−) when it is a dislike or opposition. The triad is balanced when the product of the three signs is positive, which happens when all three links are positive or when exactly two are negative. It is unbalanced when the product is negative, which means one negative link or three. Heider proposed that an unbalanced triad creates tension, and people try to restore balance.

P–OP–XO–XProductState
++++Balanced: I like my friend and we both favour the plan
++−−Unbalanced: I like my friend and favour the plan, but my friend opposes it
+−−+Balanced: I like my friend and we both oppose the plan

There are several ways to restore balance. P can change the view of X, change the feeling about O, persuade O to change, or find a way of seeing O's position as different from what it seems.

Bem's self-perception theory

Daryl Bem proposed a different idea. When our attitudes are weak or unclear, we do not always look inside ourselves. Instead, we watch our own behaviour, and the situation in which it takes place, and conclude what our attitude must be, just as an outside observer would. A person who finds that she gives up her Saturdays to teach children may infer 'I must really care about this'. Bem argued that this inference needs no unpleasant tension. Dissonance theory, in contrast, says that clashing beliefs and acts produce discomfort, which we then reduce. Both can be true in different circumstances: dissonance is strong when the attitude was clear and the act clashes with it, while self-perception explains cases where the attitude was vague to begin with.

Bem's view also helps to explain why rewards can backfire. If a person who enjoys an activity begins to be paid for it, she may start to see her own behaviour as done for the pay, and her interest in the task can fall. Researchers call this the overjustification effect.

Rule to remember: balance means the three signs multiply to a positive; imbalance creates pressure to change one link. Self-perception means we may learn what we think by watching what we do.

Worked example 1: is the triad balanced?

Meena (P) likes her friend Ravi (O), so P–O is +. Meena favours a proposed bypass (X), so P–X is +. Ravi strongly opposes the bypass, so O–X is −. The product is (+)(+)(−) = −, so the triad is unbalanced. Meena has four options. She can turn against the bypass (P–X becomes −, product +). She can cool towards Ravi (P–O becomes −, product +). She can try to win Ravi over (O–X becomes +). Or she can think 'Ravi only opposes it because he lives nearby', which changes how she sees Ravi's stand.

Worked example 2: self-perception at work

Ashok, a new municipal engineer, had no strong view on cycling. Over a year he has repeatedly agreed to design cycle lanes, and he now spends weekends mapping safe routes. Asked about it, he says, 'I suppose I am a strong supporter of cycling.' By self-perception theory, he has inferred his attitude from his own conduct, since the conduct was freely chosen. No discomfort was needed; he simply read his own behaviour.

Why this matters for public servants

These theories warn against two traps. Rationalisation means changing a view to fit an act we have done, instead of correcting the act. Loyalty-driven balance means that wanting to agree with a boss or friend we like pulls our judgement towards theirs. An officer who knows these pulls can ask, 'Am I judging the issue, or protecting my comfort?'

Key takeaways. In Heider's triad, an odd number of negative links gives imbalance, and imbalance pushes towards change. Bem says that people can infer attitudes from their own behaviour. Dissonance, balance and self-perception all show that attitude change is often driven by the need for consistency.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In Heider's balance theory, a triad is balanced when:

    1. All three links are negative
    2. The product of the three signs is zero
    3. P and O disagree about X
    4. The product of the three signs is positive
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Balance requires an even number of negative links: all positive, or exactly two negative. In both cases the product of signs is positive.

  2. 2. P likes O, P opposes X, and O favours X. What is the state of the triad?

    1. Balanced, because P likes O
    2. Unbalanced
    3. Balanced, because P has a clear view
    4. Neutral, because the signs differ
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The signs are (+)(−)(+) = −, so there is one negative link and the triad is unbalanced. P is under pressure to change one of the links.

  3. 3. Which of these is NOT a way of restoring balance in an unbalanced triad?

    1. Changing one's feeling about the other person
    2. Changing one's own view of the object or issue
    3. Ignoring all three elements and acting at random
    4. Persuading O to change his view of the object
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Heider proposed that people restore balance by altering one of the links or by reinterpreting O's stand. Acting at random does not restore balance.

  4. 4. According to Bem's self-perception theory, a person who is unsure of an attitude often:

    1. Infers it from watching his own behaviour
    2. Waits for strong discomfort before forming it
    3. Copies the attitude of the nearest authority
    4. Refuses to form any view
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Bem's central claim is that people can read their own attitudes from their freely chosen behaviour, as an observer would.

  5. 5. What is the overjustification effect?

    1. People work harder when a reward is promised for everything
    2. Reward always raises liking for an activity
    3. Interest in an enjoyed task can fall when it begins to be rewarded
    4. Strong attitudes are easier to change than weak ones
    Show answer

    Answer: C. If a person starts to see her behaviour as done for a reward, she may infer that she did not do it for its own sake, and her interest can drop.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery