• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Changing attitudes and social influence: persuasion, conformity, obedience and compliance

Describe Hovland's Yale approach and the elaboration likelihood model of persuasion, and explain conformity (Asch), obedience (Milgram) and compliance techniques in plain language.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Public administration is constantly trying to change attitudes: towards girls' education, road safety, tax compliance, sanitation. At the same time, officers themselves are subject to pressure from groups and from superiors. This lesson introduces the main ideas on persuasion and on social influence that later lessons apply.

Persuasion: the Yale approach

Carl Hovland and his colleagues at Yale University studied persuasion as a question of who says what to whom. Their findings are grouped under source, message and audience.

  • Source: credible sources (expert and trustworthy) persuade more, and so do attractive or likeable ones.
  • Message: a two-sided message that admits and answers the other view works better with well-informed audiences and with those who start out disagreeing; a one-sided message can suffice for those who already agree. Fear appeals work better when they also show a clear, doable way to avoid the danger.
  • Audience: prior attitudes, involvement, self-esteem and intelligence affect how people respond.
  • Sleeper effect: a message from a low-credibility source may gain impact over time, as people remember the message but forget where it came from.

The elaboration likelihood model

Richard Petty and John Cacioppo proposed that persuasion takes one of two routes, depending on how much a person thinks about (elaborates on) the message.

Two routes to persuasion
FeatureCentral routePeripheral route
When it is usedPerson is motivated (the issue matters to them) and able (time, knowledge, no distraction) to thinkMotivation or ability is low
What persuadesQuality of the argumentsCues: attractive or famous source, number of arguments, music, what others seem to think
ResultLasting change that resists counter-argument and predicts behaviourWeaker, shorter-lived change
ExampleA farmer studies soil-test results before changing fertiliserA farmer joins a scheme because a film star appears in its advertisement

Worked example 1: which route?

Case: a district runs a campaign on rainwater harvesting. Lata, whose well dried up last summer, reads the technical leaflet carefully and asks the engineer about costs. Dev, who has a reliable piped supply, glances at a poster showing a popular cricketer and thinks 'seems a good idea'. Step 1: Lata has high personal relevance and makes the effort to think: central route. Strong arguments will produce lasting change. Step 2: Dev has low relevance and reacts to a celebrity: peripheral route. His favourable view may fade. Lesson: the same campaign should carry solid arguments for involved people and simple, positive cues for the rest.

Social influence: conformity, obedience and compliance

Conformity is changing one's behaviour or beliefs to match a group. In Solomon Asch's line-judgement studies, a participant sat among people secretly working with the experimenter and judged which of three lines matched a standard line. On some trials everyone else unanimously gave an obviously wrong answer. Many participants went along with the group at least once, although most answers stayed correct and some people never yielded. When even one other person gave the right answer, conformity fell sharply. Morton Deutsch and Harold Gerard distinguished normative influence (conforming to be accepted) from informational influence (conforming because one thinks the group knows better).

Obedience is following the direct orders of an authority. In Stanley Milgram's studies at Yale, participants acting as 'teachers' were told to give increasingly strong electric shocks to a 'learner' for each wrong answer. The learner was an actor and no real shocks were given. In the basic version a majority continued to the highest level when the experimenter insisted, despite visible distress. Obedience dropped when the learner was closer, when the experimenter gave orders by telephone, and when fellow participants refused. Milgram explained the results partly by the agentic state: people come to see themselves as instruments carrying out another's will. The studies are also criticised for deception and the stress they caused.

Compliance is agreeing to a request from someone without formal authority. Known techniques include foot-in-the-door (a small request first, then a larger one), door-in-the-face (a large request that is refused, then a smaller one) and low-ball (agreement is secured, then the terms are made worse). Herbert Kelman distinguished three depths of influence: compliance (outward agreement to gain reward or avoid punishment), identification (adopting a view to be like someone admired) and internalisation (genuine acceptance because it fits one's own values).

Worked example 2: naming the influence

Case: Arun, a new clerk in a fictional district office, sees colleagues leave at four though duty ends later. At first he stays; after a week of jokes about him, he leaves early too. Later his section officer orders him to back-date a file, and he does it, saying he only followed orders. Step 1: leaving early to fit in with the group after teasing is conformity through normative influence. Step 2: back-dating on a superior's command is obedience, with an agentic excuse. Step 3: judge it: neither the group nor the order removes Arun's own responsibility for breaking rules.

Rule to remember: persuasion changes minds through arguments (central route) or cues (peripheral route). Conformity follows a group, obedience follows an authority, compliance follows a request, and none of them moves moral responsibility away from the person who acts.

Key takeaways: the Yale approach looks at source, message and audience; the elaboration likelihood model separates the central and peripheral routes; Asch studied conformity and Milgram obedience; compliance techniques work without authority; Kelman's internalisation is the deepest form of change.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Hovland's Yale approach organises the study of persuasion around:

    1. Source, message and audience: who says what to whom
    2. Attitude, subjective norm and perceived control
    3. Affect, behaviour and cognition
    4. Utilitarian, ego-defensive, value-expressive and knowledge needs
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The Yale programme asked which features of the communicator, the communication and the audience change attitudes. The other options are the planned behaviour model, the ABC model and Katz's functions.

  2. 2. According to the elaboration likelihood model, the central route is used when:

    1. The message has a famous spokesperson
    2. The person is distracted and in a hurry
    3. The message is repeated many times with catchy music
    4. The person is both motivated and able to think about the arguments
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Central processing needs both motivation (personal relevance) and ability (time, knowledge, no distraction). Celebrity, distraction and jingles point to the peripheral route.

  3. 3. In Asch's line-judgement studies, conformity fell sharply when:

    1. The group was made much larger
    2. The lines were made harder to tell apart
    3. The participant was told the others were experts
    4. One other person in the group gave the correct answer
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Breaking the group's unanimity with a single ally reduced conformity sharply. A harder task or apparently expert group would push conformity up, and size beyond a few members added little.

  4. 4. Milgram's experiments were designed mainly to study:

    1. Conformity to a group in judging lines
    2. Persuasion through mass media
    3. Prejudice between competing groups
    4. Obedience to authority
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Milgram examined how far people would follow an experimenter's orders to harm another person. Line judgements belong to Asch.

  5. 5. A volunteer first agrees to put a small road-safety sticker on her window. Two weeks later she agrees to a large road-safety board in her front yard. Which technique is this?

    1. Door-in-the-face
    2. Foot-in-the-door
    3. Low-ball
    4. Sleeper effect
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A small request accepted first makes a larger later request more likely. Door-in-the-face starts with a large refused request; low-ball worsens terms after agreement.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery