• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Biases that distort judgement: halo, confirmation, attribution error, self-fulfilling prophecy and in-group favouritism

Recognise five named biases that distort how officers judge people and evidence, apply each to a workplace case, and use simple safeguards such as structured criteria and written reasons.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Attitudes do not only sit in the mind; they shape what we notice, what we remember and how we explain what we see. When an officer interviews a candidate, inspects an office or investigates a complaint, hidden biases can tilt the outcome without any bad intention. This lesson names five well-known biases, shows how each appears in public service, and gives a safeguard for each.

Five biases

BiasWhat happensSafeguard
Halo effect (described by Edward Thorndike)One good trait colours the judgement of everything else; one bad trait does the reverse (the horn effect)Score each criterion separately, before forming an overall view
Confirmation biasWe look for, notice and remember evidence that supports what we already believeList evidence against the view as well as for it
Fundamental attribution error (a term from Lee Ross)We explain other people's actions by their character and overlook the situation they were inAsk what situation the person faced before judging the person
Self-fulfilling prophecy (Robert Merton)An expectation leads to behaviour that makes it come trueGive every person the same chance, and check expectations against results
In-group favouritism (studied by Henri Tajfel)We favour people we see as 'one of us', even when the grouping is trivialUse fixed, published criteria and consider who is left out

The first three are errors in judging people and evidence. The last two are errors that change reality: a prophecy can create the very result it predicts, and favouritism can hand benefits to one group and deny them to another. The self-serving bias is a close relative: we tend to take credit for success and blame circumstances for failure.

Rule to remember: halo spreads one trait over everything; confirmation looks only for support; the attribution error blames character and forgets the situation; a prophecy can fulfil itself; favouritism rewards the in-group. Structure and written reasons are the cure.

Worked example 1: the halo at an interview

A panel interviews a candidate who is neatly dressed and speaks fluently. The members rate her highly on 'knowledge of rules', 'integrity' and 'decision making', although her answers on rules were thin. The smart first impression has spread to every criterion: a halo effect. A safeguard is to score each criterion on its own evidence, in writing, before the overall discussion, and to ask the same questions of every candidate.

Worked example 2: the inspector who is already sure

An inspector believes that a certain clerk is lazy. In the following week he notices every late arrival and every pending file, but he does not notice the clerk's two quick disposals or the extra hours she worked on Friday. This is confirmation bias: the belief steers attention. The remedy is to decide beforehand what would count as evidence for and against, and to record both lists. If the lists are lopsided, he should ask why.

Worked example 3: the late file

A section officer finds that a file from a colleague is a week late and thinks, 'He is careless.' Step 1: he has explained the delay by the colleague's character. Step 2: he has not asked about the situation, for example a sudden rise in workload, missing information from another office, or illness. This is the fundamental attribution error. When the officer is late himself, he is likely to blame the situation, which is the related actor–observer difference. A fair judgement asks about the situation first.

Worked example 4: a prophecy that fulfils itself

A head of office is told that a transferred assistant 'does not perform'. He gives the assistant only routine tasks and little feedback. The assistant, with no chance to show ability, turns in dull work and loses interest. The head says, 'I was right.' The expectation led to behaviour that produced the result: a self-fulfilling prophecy. Studies of expectation effects in classrooms, led by Robert Rosenthal, are often described as the Pygmalion effect. The remedy is to treat the report as a claim to test: give a fair task, set clear targets and judge by results.

Key takeaways. Biases work quietly and operate even in people of good will. Name the bias, and then use a structure that does not depend on goodwill alone: separate criteria, evidence on both sides, the situation first, equal chances and published rules.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. An interviewer rates a smartly dressed candidate high on every criterion, including those where the answers were poor. This is:

    1. The halo effect
    2. Confirmation bias
    3. The self-serving bias
    4. In-group favouritism
    Show answer

    Answer: A. One favourable impression has spread to all the judgements, which is the halo effect. The reverse, where one poor trait lowers every rating, is the horn effect.

  2. 2. An officer who has decided a vendor is unreliable notices only its late deliveries. This is best called:

    1. The halo effect
    2. A self-fulfilling prophecy
    3. Confirmation bias
    4. Social loafing
    Show answer

    Answer: C. He gives weight to evidence that fits his belief and misses evidence against it, which is confirmation bias.

  3. 3. A manager explains a colleague's missed deadline as 'laziness' without asking about the colleague's workload. This is:

    1. A self-fulfilling prophecy
    2. The fundamental attribution error
    3. The overjustification effect
    4. Obedience
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The cause has been assigned to character, and the situation has been ignored. That is the fundamental attribution error.

  4. 4. Which safeguard best reduces the halo effect in a selection panel?

    1. Let the senior member speak first
    2. Select the candidate who made the best first impression
    3. Avoid recording any scores
    4. Score each criterion separately before the overall discussion
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Scoring criteria one by one, on written evidence, stops one trait from colouring all the others.

  5. 5. A teacher expects a pupil to do badly, gives him little attention, and he does badly. The term for this chain is:

    1. Cognitive dissonance
    2. A self-fulfilling prophecy
    3. Positive discrimination
    4. Mere exposure
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The expectation caused behaviour that produced the very result expected. Robert Merton named this idea, and the classroom form is often called the Pygmalion effect.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Final self-assessment: Attitude

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery