• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

From attitude to action: LaPiere, planned behaviour and cognitive dissonance

Explain why attitudes do not always predict behaviour, use Fishbein and Ajzen's reasoned action and Ajzen's planned behaviour models, and describe Festinger's cognitive dissonance and how people reduce it.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

If attitudes always decided behaviour, changing attitudes would be enough to change society. Experience says otherwise: people who say corruption is wrong still pay bribes, and people who say they value cleanliness still litter. This lesson explains when attitudes predict behaviour, how to model the step from attitude to action, and what happens inside a person when action and belief clash.

The gap between saying and doing: LaPiere's study

In the early 1930s the American sociologist Richard LaPiere travelled across the United States with a young Chinese couple, at a time when prejudice against Chinese people was common there. They were served at almost every hotel and restaurant they visited and were refused only once. Some months later LaPiere wrote to the same places asking whether they would accept Chinese guests. Most of those that replied said they would not. What people said and what they had done did not match. Critics later noted limits: the person who answered the letter may not have been the one who served the couple, and a polite, well-dressed couple in person is not the same as a general question about a whole group. Even so, the study became the classic warning that stated attitudes can be poor guides to behaviour.

When do attitudes predict behaviour?

  • When the attitude is strong and accessible, especially if formed by direct experience.
  • When the attitude and the behaviour are measured at the same level of specificity (the principle of compatibility): an attitude towards 'donating blood at this camp this week' predicts that act far better than an attitude towards 'health'.
  • When situational pressures such as orders, norms or lack of means are weak.
  • When the person is self-aware and thinking about their own values at the moment of acting.

Reasoned action and planned behaviour

Martin Fishbein and Icek Ajzen proposed the theory of reasoned action. The best predictor of a behaviour is the intention to perform it. Intention depends on two things: the attitude towards the behaviour (not towards the object in general) and the subjective norm, which is the person's sense of what important others expect, weighed by how much they want to comply. Ajzen later added a third element, perceived behavioural control: how easy or hard the person believes the behaviour is. This extended model is the theory of planned behaviour. Perceived control shapes intention, and where it reflects real control it can also affect behaviour directly.

The three elements of the theory of planned behaviour
ElementQuestion the person asksExample: using a household toilet
Attitude towards the behaviourIs doing this good or bad for me?'Using the toilet keeps my family healthy'
Subjective normDo the people who matter to me want me to?'My elders and the panchayat expect it'
Perceived behavioural controlCan I actually do it?'There is water nearby to keep it clean'

Worked example 1: predicting with planned behaviour

Case: Kavita, a health worker in a fictional village, wants mothers to bring infants for vaccination. Mother A believes vaccines protect children (attitude favourable) and her husband supports it (subjective norm favourable), but the clinic is far away and there is no transport (perceived control low). Step 1: reasoned action looks only at attitude and norm, both favourable, and predicts she will go. Step 2: planned behaviour adds control, which is low, so it predicts a weak intention and a blocked behaviour. Step 3: the remedy follows: a mobile vaccination camp in the village raises control. Lesson: when people cannot act, persuading them harder achieves little.

Cognitive dissonance

Leon Festinger proposed that when a person holds two cognitions that do not fit together, or acts against their own attitude, they feel an unpleasant tension called cognitive dissonance, and they are motivated to reduce it. The more important the cognitions, the stronger the dissonance. It can be reduced by changing the behaviour, changing the attitude or belief, adding consonant cognitions (justifications), or reducing the importance of the clash (trivialising).

In a classic experiment by Festinger and James Carlsmith, participants did a very dull task and were then paid either one dollar or twenty dollars to tell the next participant that it was interesting. Afterwards, those paid one dollar rated the task as more enjoyable than those paid twenty. Twenty dollars was enough to justify the lie; one dollar was not, so the poorly paid group reduced their dissonance by changing their view of the task.

Worked example 2: reducing dissonance

Case: Vikram, a junior officer in a fictional district, sees himself as honest. He accepts an expensive gift from a contractor whose bill he must clear. Step 1: the clash is between 'I am honest' and 'I took a gift from someone whose file I handle'. Step 2: list the exits. He can return the gift (change behaviour); tell himself gifts are just courtesy (change belief); say everyone does it and it did not influence him (add consonant cognitions); or call it a small matter (trivialise). Step 3: judge them ethically. Only the first removes the wrong; the others protect his self-image while his standards slide, which is how small compromises grow into a habit. Answer: return the gift and record it.

Rule to remember: intention grows from attitude to the act, the norm around it and the control one feels over it. When act and belief clash, people feel dissonance and change one of them; integrity means changing the act, not the belief.

Key takeaways

  • LaPiere's study showed that stated attitudes may not match behaviour.
  • Attitudes predict behaviour best when strong, specific to the act and free of strong situational pressure.
  • Reasoned action: attitude to the behaviour plus subjective norm lead to intention; planned behaviour adds perceived behavioural control.
  • Festinger's dissonance is reduced by changing behaviour, changing belief, adding justifications or trivialising.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. LaPiere's study of hotels and restaurants is cited mainly to show that:

    1. Stated attitudes may differ from actual behaviour
    2. Attitudes always predict behaviour accurately
    3. Prejudice disappears when people travel
    4. Obedience to authority is surprisingly high
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Establishments that served the Chinese couple in person later said, in letters, that they would not accept Chinese guests. The gap between words and deeds is the point of the study.

  2. 2. Which element did Ajzen add to the theory of reasoned action to form the theory of planned behaviour?

    1. Subjective norm
    2. Attitude towards the behaviour
    3. Cognitive dissonance
    4. Perceived behavioural control
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Reasoned action already had attitude towards the behaviour and subjective norm. Planned behaviour added perceived behavioural control, the person's sense of how easy or hard the act is.

  3. 3. Raju says, 'My parents and friends all expect me to vote.' In the theory of planned behaviour, this is:

    1. Perceived behavioural control
    2. Attitude towards the behaviour
    3. The value-expressive function
    4. The subjective norm
    Show answer

    Answer: D. What important others expect the person to do is the subjective norm. It says nothing about ease of voting (control) or his own evaluation of voting (attitude).

  4. 4. In Festinger and Carlsmith's experiment, which participants later rated the dull task as more enjoyable?

    1. Those paid the large sum, because money makes any task pleasant
    2. Both groups rated it equally
    3. Those paid the small sum, because they had too little outside justification for the lie
    4. Neither group, because the lie made everyone dislike the task more
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The one-dollar group could not explain their lie by the payment, so they reduced dissonance by deciding the task was not so dull. The twenty-dollar group had a sufficient external reason.

  5. 5. Which example shows dissonance being reduced by adding a consonant cognition?

    1. A smoker gives up smoking
    2. A smoker decides the research on smoking is simply wrong
    3. A smoker who never believed smoking was harmful feels no tension
    4. A smoker tells himself that his daily walk cancels out the harm
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Adding a new justifying thought (the walk cancels the harm) keeps both behaviour and belief but reduces the clash. Quitting changes behaviour; rejecting the research changes the belief; the last case has no dissonance at all.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery