- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Dissonance and persuasion in practice: reading the reduction strategy and the persuasion route
Identify how a person is reducing dissonance, predict attitude change after effortful or freely chosen acts, and tell central from peripheral persuasion and Hovland's source, message and audience factors in scenarios.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Case questions often describe someone who has done something at odds with their beliefs, or a campaign designed to change minds, and ask what is going on psychologically. This lesson trains you to read both kinds of case quickly and to avoid the most common mistakes.
Reading dissonance in a case
| Strategy | What the person does | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Change behaviour | Stops or reverses the act | A doctor who prescribes needless tests stops doing so |
| Change attitude or belief | Revises the belief to fit the act | 'These tests are actually useful for every patient' |
| Add consonant cognitions | Adds justifications | 'Patients demand them; other doctors do it too' |
| Trivialise | Makes the clash seem unimportant | 'It is only a small extra cost' |
Three related findings appear often. Effort justification: in a study by Elliot Aronson and Judson Mills, people who went through a more embarrassing initiation to join a dull discussion group later rated the group more favourably, as if to justify the effort. Post-decision dissonance: after a hard choice, people tend to rate the chosen option higher and the rejected one lower. Insufficient justification: attitude change is greatest when the act was freely chosen and the outside reward or threat was small. A large bribe or a strong threat explains the act, so the attitude need not change.
Worked example 1: two dissonance cases
Case A: Rekha, a young officer, chose a hard posting in a remote block and spent two difficult years there. She now praises the posting to everyone. Step 1: her free choice and great effort create dissonance with the hardships. Step 2: she reduces it by valuing the posting more: effort justification and post-decision dissonance. Case B: a shop owner who paid a bribe for a licence says, 'It is the system; everyone pays.' Step 1: the clash is between 'I am honest' and 'I paid a bribe'. Step 2: he adds consonant cognitions (everyone does it, the system forced me). Exam trap: do not call Case B a change of behaviour; nothing he does has changed.
Reading persuasion in a case
For the elaboration likelihood model, first judge the audience's motivation (is the issue personally relevant?) and ability (time, knowledge, freedom from distraction). High on both points to the central route; then argument quality decides. Low on either points to the peripheral route; then cues decide. For Hovland's framework, name the variable that the case changes: the source (credibility, attractiveness), the message (one- or two-sided, fear appeal, order) or the audience (involvement, prior view).
Traps: a fear appeal without a clear, doable remedy tends to produce denial rather than action; a two-sided message suits educated or opposed audiences, not mainly those who already agree; a celebrity in a low-involvement setting is a peripheral cue, not an argument; and change by the peripheral route fades sooner.
Worked example 2: designing two messages
Case: a district health officer must promote oral rehydration for children with diarrhoea. Audience 1 is a meeting of mothers whose children recently fell ill; Audience 2 is the general public at a weekly market. Step 1: Audience 1 is highly motivated and, given a calm setting, able to follow: central route. Use clear reasons, a live demonstration of preparing the solution, and answers to their doubts (a two-sided message, because some believe water should be withheld). Step 2: Audience 2 is passing by and distracted: peripheral route. Use a respected local nurse, a short slogan and a simple picture. Step 3: any warning about dehydration must come with the remedy, or it will frighten without helping.
Rule to remember: dissonance changes attitudes most when the act was free and the outside reason small. Persuasion goes central when people care and can think, so argue well; it goes peripheral when they cannot or do not care, so use good cues and expect the change to fade.
Key takeaways: name the dissonance strategy from what the person actually does or says; effort and free choice increase liking for what was chosen; big rewards or threats prevent attitude change; judge motivation and ability before naming the persuasion route; pair fear with a remedy.
Check your understanding
-
1. A doctor who had argued against a new treatment is assigned to use it, freely chooses to stay in the project and, months later, says the treatment is 'actually quite effective'. Which dissonance strategy is this?
- Changing the behaviour to fit the attitude
- Changing the attitude to fit the behaviour
- Trivialising the clash
- Adding consonant cognitions about colleagues
Show answer
Answer: B. His behaviour (using the treatment) stays; what changes is his evaluation of it. That is attitude change to fit behaviour.
-
2. Which situation is most likely to produce attitude change through dissonance?
- A student writes the essay because she is threatened with expulsion if she refuses to do so
- A student writes the essay in return for a very large prize announced before she starts
- A student writes an essay supporting a view she already holds and has often defended in public
- A student freely agrees, for a token reward, to write an essay supporting a view she opposes
Show answer
Answer: D. Dissonance-driven change is greatest when the act is free and the external justification small. Big threats or big prizes justify the act, and writing what one already believes creates no dissonance.
-
3. A health poster shows frightening images of lung disease but gives no information on how to quit or where to get help. The most likely problem is that:
- Fear appeals never have any effect on people, whatever else the poster contains
- The poster uses the central route too heavily, with arguments that viewers cannot follow
- The poster is a two-sided message that gives equal space to arguments for and against
- Fear without a clear, doable remedy tends to produce denial rather than change
Show answer
Answer: D. Fear appeals work better when paired with a specific, achievable way of avoiding the danger. Without it, people tend to avoid or deny the message.
-
4. A busy commuter glances at a road-safety hoarding featuring a famous actor and feels favourable towards wearing seat belts. According to the elaboration likelihood model, this change:
- Came by the central route and is likely to be strong and long-lasting
- Is an example of effort justification, where a costly choice is valued more
- Came by the peripheral route and is likely to be weaker and shorter-lived
- Is an example of the sleeper effect, where the source is forgotten over time
Show answer
Answer: C. Low motivation and ability (busy, glancing) plus a celebrity cue indicate the peripheral route, which produces less durable change.
-
5. A campaign against a harmful practice will address an educated audience that largely disagrees with it at first. Following the Yale findings, the message should be:
- One-sided, presenting only the campaign's arguments
- Delivered by an unknown source to avoid bias
- Two-sided, acknowledging the opposing view and answering it
- Built on a fear appeal with no suggested action
Show answer
Answer: C. Two-sided messages were found to work better with better-informed audiences and with those initially opposed, because ignoring the other side looks biased to them.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.