- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Spotting the ABC components and Katz's functions in case statements
Classify statements by attitude component and by function at speed, handle mixed and disguised statements, and avoid the traps that confuse beliefs with feelings and values with ego-defence.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Exam questions on attitude rarely ask for a definition. They give a statement or a short case and ask which component it shows, which function an attitude serves, or how an officer should respond. The concepts are simple; the marks are lost on wording. This lesson gives two quick tests and the traps examiners build into the options.
A three-question test for components
- Is the phrase about what is true or false, a cause or an effect, a fact or an opinion about facts? Then it is cognitive.
- Is it about liking, disliking or an emotion (fear, pride, disgust, comfort, irritation)? Then it is affective.
- Is it about doing, intending or being ready to act (will, plan to, always, refuse, avoid, sign up)? Then it is behavioural.
| Signal words | Usually | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|
| believe, think, know, is effective, causes, leads to | Cognitive | 'I feel that X causes Y' uses 'feel' loosely for a belief |
| love, hate, fear, proud, uneasy, disgusted, comfortable | Affective | 'I hate to say it, but the data show...' introduces a belief |
| will, intend, always, never go, refuse to, avoid, volunteer | Behavioural | An intention ('I will vote') is behavioural even before the act |
A test for Katz's functions
Ask: what would the person lose if the attitude were dropped? If they would lose a benefit or face a cost, the function is utilitarian. If they would feel exposed to a threat to their self-image, it is ego-defensive. If they would feel untrue to themselves, it is value-expressive. If they would lose a simple way of making sense of things, it is knowledge.
Trap 1, value-expressive versus ego-defensive. Both involve the self. Value-expressive attitudes openly display a positive self-concept ('this is what I stand for'). Ego-defensive attitudes hide an inner insecurity, often through hostility to an outgroup, denial or blaming others. Trap 2, noble words. A person may use the language of principle while the real reason is a benefit; go by the reason the case actually gives. Trap 3, stereotypes. A stereotype usually serves the knowledge function (it simplifies), but if the case stresses that it shields the holder from feeling inferior, choose ego-defensive.
Worked example 1: a mixed statement
Statement: Mr Bhatia, a senior clerk, says, 'Computerised records will make the office error-free, but honestly I dread the change, and I keep postponing my training.' Step 1: 'will make the office error-free' is a belief: cognitive, favourable. Step 2: 'I dread the change' is an emotion: affective, unfavourable. Step 3: 'keep postponing training' is action: behavioural, unfavourable. Step 4: the behaviour follows the feeling, not the belief. Exam point: if asked which component a training programme should target, the answer is the affective one: reduce fear through hands-on practice and support, because he is already convinced of the benefit.
Worked example 2: same attitude, different functions
Case: in a fictional collectorate, four officers react to a move to paperless files. Officer A supports it because it carries a performance incentive. Officer B supports it because she believes transparency is a public servant's duty. Officer C supports it because it lets him see exactly where every file is. Officer D opposes it, insisting that 'these machines are for youngsters who cannot draft a proper note'. Step 1: A gains a benefit: utilitarian. Step 2: B expresses a value: value-expressive. Step 3: C makes sense of a confusing system: knowledge. Step 4: D's scorn hides a fear of being exposed as unfamiliar with computers: ego-defensive. Step 5, apply Katz: for D, public pressure will harden resistance; private, patient training that protects his dignity is the better route.
Speed rule: belief means cognitive, feeling means affective, action or intention means behavioural. For functions, ask what the person would lose by dropping the attitude: a benefit, a shield, an identity or a map.
Key takeaways: use signal words but read the whole phrase; intentions are behavioural; separate the open self-expression of value-expressive attitudes from the hidden insecurity of ego-defensive ones; go by the reason the case gives, not by noble-sounding words.
Check your understanding
-
1. 'I feel that strict enforcement of helmet rules will reduce road deaths.' Which component does this statement show?
- Affective, because it uses the word 'feel'
- Cognitive, because it is a belief about cause and effect
- Behavioural, because it mentions enforcement
- None, because it is an opinion and not an attitude
Show answer
Answer: B. 'Feel' is used loosely here; the content is a belief that enforcement causes fewer deaths. Cause-and-effect beliefs are cognitive.
-
2. 'From next month I will cycle to the office instead of driving.' This statement shows the:
- Cognitive component
- Behavioural component
- Affective component
- Knowledge function
Show answer
Answer: B. An intention to act belongs to the behavioural (conative) component even before the act takes place.
-
3. A landowner loudly backs a canal project, citing 'national progress', but the case notes that the canal will pass his fields and raise their value. The function his attitude mainly serves is:
- Value-expressive
- Knowledge
- Ego-defensive
- Utilitarian
Show answer
Answer: D. The case gives the real reason as a benefit to him. Noble-sounding words do not change the function; go by the reason stated.
-
4. A worker who feels insecure about his own job blames migrant workers for every problem in the factory. Which function does his attitude mainly serve?
- Ego-defensive
- Utilitarian
- Value-expressive
- Knowledge
Show answer
Answer: A. Blaming an outgroup to protect oneself from inner insecurity is the classic ego-defensive function (scapegoating).
-
5. A clerk is convinced that a new software is useful but is anxious about using it and avoids it. To change his behaviour, a training plan should mainly target the:
- Cognitive component, by giving him more evidence that the software is useful
- Affective component, by reducing his anxiety through supported practice
- Utilitarian function, by threatening a penalty
- Knowledge function, by giving him a stereotype of software users
Show answer
Answer: B. His beliefs are already favourable; his avoidance follows his anxiety. Reducing the fear through guided practice targets the component that is actually blocking the behaviour.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.