- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Social influence case studies: conformity, obedience and compliance in the office
Tell normative from informational influence, apply Asch's and Milgram's findings and the idea of groupthink to office situations, name compliance techniques, and use Kelman's processes to judge how deep a change is.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A good deal of wrongdoing in public offices is done not by villains but by ordinary people going along with a group or following an instruction. Exam cases test whether you can name the kind of influence and, more importantly, propose a response that keeps personal responsibility intact.
Telling the three kinds apart
| Kind | Pressure comes from | Is there an explicit request? | Classic study or idea |
|---|---|---|---|
| Conformity | A group of peers | No, the pressure is implied | Asch's line judgements; Sherif's studies of norms in an ambiguous situation |
| Obedience | A person with authority | Yes, an order | Milgram's studies of obedience |
| Compliance | Anyone, without formal authority | Yes, a request | Foot-in-the-door, door-in-the-face, low-ball |
What raises and lowers each kind
- Conformity rises when the group is unanimous, when the task is ambiguous or difficult (informational influence), when answers are public, and when the person values the group. It falls with one dissenting ally and when answers are given privately. Muzafer Sherif showed that in an ambiguous situation people's judgements converge on a shared group norm.
- Obedience rises when the authority is close, legitimate and takes responsibility, and when the victim is distant. It falls when the authority is absent or remote, when the harm is close and visible, and when others refuse.
- Groupthink, described by Irving Janis, is a failure of decision-making in cohesive groups: the urge for agreement leads to self-censorship, an illusion of unanimity, pressure on dissenters and poor examination of alternatives. Remedies include a leader who holds back their own view at first, an appointed devil's advocate and independent written assessments.
- Kelman's depth test: compliance lasts only while the reward or surveillance lasts; identification lasts while the relationship with the admired person matters; internalisation lasts because it is part of the person's own values.
Worked example 1: a tender committee
Case: in a fictional municipal tender committee, the chair opens by praising one bidder. Two members quickly agree. Farhan, the junior member, has noticed that this bidder's experience certificate does not match the requirement, but he stays silent and signs. Step 1, name it: Farhan conforms; his silence is normative (not wanting to stand out) and the chair's early view adds authority. Step 2, groupthink signs: leader states a preference first; self-censorship; illusion of unanimity. Step 3, remedies from the research: members score bids independently in writing before discussion (private responses lower conformity); one member dissenting breaks unanimity and makes it easier for others; the chair speaks last. Step 4, ethical duty: Farhan should record his objection in the minutes; signing a flawed evaluation makes him responsible for it.
Worked example 2: an order that should not be followed
Case: a station house officer tells a constable, Ravi, to keep a man in the lock-up overnight 'to teach him a lesson', without any arrest record. Step 1, name it: an order from authority: obedience. Step 2, Milgram's insight: Ravi may feel the responsibility lies with the officer (the agentic state), and obedience is likely because the authority is present and legitimate-seeming. Step 3, ethical analysis: an illegal order does not become lawful because it comes from a superior, and following it does not shift Ravi's own responsibility. Step 4, response: respectfully point out the legal requirement, ask for the instruction in writing, refuse to detain without lawful basis, and report through proper channels if pressed.
Rule to remember: one dissenting voice, private judgement and a leader who speaks last weaken conformity; distance from authority and closeness to the harm weaken obedience. In every case the person who acts remains responsible.
Key takeaways: conformity follows a group, obedience an authority, compliance a request; informational influence grows when the situation is ambiguous; groupthink is prevented by structure, not goodwill; only internalised change lasts without supervision.
Check your understanding
-
1. In an unfamiliar situation where no one is sure of the right answer, people's judgements gradually converge on a common group view. This describes:
- Normative influence, as in Milgram's studies of shock and obedience
- Obedience to authority, where people follow a legitimate commander
- Door-in-the-face compliance, where a big request precedes a small one
- Informational influence, as in Sherif's studies of norm formation
Show answer
Answer: D. When a situation is ambiguous, people use others as a source of information, and a shared norm forms. Sherif demonstrated this; Milgram studied obedience.
-
2. A committee chair wants to avoid groupthink. Which step is most useful?
- Ask the chair to state a preferred option at the start of the meeting
- Have members record independent assessments before the chair gives a view
- Discourage dissent so that the meeting finishes quickly and without delay
- Make all votes public and immediate, with each member speaking in turn
Show answer
Answer: B. Independent, private assessments before discussion reduce the pressure for agreement. A leader stating a view first and suppressing dissent encourage groupthink.
-
3. A salesman offers an office a printer at a low price; once the order is agreed, he adds charges for installation and cartridges. This technique is:
- Foot-in-the-door
- Door-in-the-face
- Sleeper effect
- Low-ball
Show answer
Answer: D. Low-ball gets a commitment on attractive terms and then makes the terms worse, relying on people sticking to their decision.
-
4. In Milgram's research, obedience fell when:
- The experimenter stood next to the participant
- The learner was in a separate room out of sight
- The experimenter gave orders by telephone instead of in person
- The participant was told the experimenter took full responsibility
Show answer
Answer: C. Distance from the authority reduced obedience. Close authority, a distant victim and the authority taking responsibility all tend to increase it.
-
5. Staff in an office follow a new rule on courteous behaviour only when the head of office is present. In Kelman's terms, this is:
- Internalisation
- Identification
- Compliance
- Informational influence
Show answer
Answer: C. Behaviour that depends on surveillance and disappears without it is compliance, the shallowest level. Internalised behaviour continues without supervision.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.