- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Prejudice and the civil servant's attitude in case studies: choosing the best response
Diagnose stereotype, prejudice and discrimination in field situations, pick prejudice-reduction steps that meet Allport's conditions, and choose responses that show empathy, tolerance, compassion, neutrality and objectivity.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Case-based ethics questions usually end with 'what would you do?' or 'which option is best?'. The best answer is rarely the most dramatic one. It is lawful, fair to everyone, kind to the most vulnerable, recorded and likely to last. This lesson turns the concepts of prejudice and civil-service attitudes into a method for judging options.
A five-point check for any option
- Lawful: does it follow the Constitution, the law and the rules?
- Impartial and objective: would it treat every citizen the same way on the same facts?
- Compassionate: does it protect the weakest party in the case?
- Transparent: are reasons recorded and open to review?
- Durable: will it change attitudes over time, or only suppress conflict for a day?
Traps in the options
Favouritism disguised as compassion: bending the rules for one sympathetic applicant is not compassion if others in the same position are refused. Compassion works through discretion that is lawful, recorded and available to all in the same situation. Neutrality mistaken for indifference: neutrality means not taking sides between parties or communities; it does not mean doing nothing when someone's rights are violated. Strictness without empathy: a lawful order delivered with contempt can deepen resentment and defeat its own purpose. Contact without the right conditions: simply putting groups together, in competition or with unequal status, can increase prejudice.
Worked example 1: the midday meal cook
Case: in a fictional village school, some parents withdraw their children from the midday meal because the newly appointed cook is from a scheduled caste. They demand a new cook. Step 1, diagnose: the demand rests on prejudice (affective rejection) backed by a caste stereotype, and the withdrawal is discrimination. Step 2, options: (a) replace the cook to restore attendance; (b) ignore the parents; (c) keep the cook, explain the legal position firmly, and work on attitudes; (d) suspend the meal scheme until things calm down. Step 3, apply the check: (a) fails law and impartiality and rewards prejudice; (b) is passive and leaves children hungry; (d) punishes the children for the adults' prejudice. Step 4, choose (c) and build it out: meet parents with the panchayat, explain that untouchability is abolished and discrimination is an offence; officers, teachers and respected elders eat the meal together (contact with the support of authority); involve parents in a joint school committee (a common goal); follow up on attendance. Answer: (c), because it is lawful, impartial, protects the cook and the children, and aims at lasting change.
Worked example 2: dignity at the service counter
Case: a transgender applicant at a fictional ration office reports that counter staff mocked her and kept asking her to 'come back with a proper ID'. Her documents are valid. Step 1, diagnose: stereotype and prejudice expressed as discrimination in service. Step 2, empathy: hear her account privately and with respect. Step 3, objectivity: check the documents and the staff conduct on record. Step 4, act: process her entitlement immediately; take proportionate action against the staff under conduct rules; arrange sensitisation training, ideally including members of the community as trainers so that staff meet them on equal terms. Step 5, system: put clear written guidance on valid documents at the counter so discretion cannot be used to exclude.
Rule to remember: the best response is lawful, impartial, kind to the weakest, recorded and lasting. Compassion never means favour for one, and neutrality never means silence when rights are denied.
Key takeaways: diagnose the prejudice before choosing the response; eliminate options that break the law, reward prejudice or punish the victim; use Allport's conditions when bringing groups together; fix the system as well as the case.
Check your understanding
-
1. A block officer receives a complaint that people of one community are kept out of a village temple. Which response best shows neutrality as a civil servant understands it?
- Stay out of it entirely, because neutrality means not getting involved in any dispute between communities
- Side openly with the larger community to keep the peace and avoid an angry reaction from the majority
- Apply the law equally, protecting the excluded group's rights without taking sides in the communities' rivalry
- Close the temple to everyone permanently so that neither community can claim it, whatever the law says
Show answer
Answer: C. Neutrality means even-handedness, not indifference. Enforcing equal rights under law is the officer's duty; doing nothing or siding with the majority fails it.
-
2. An officer approves an incomplete application from a poor widow because he feels sorry for her, but refuses identical incomplete applications from others. This is best described as:
- Compassion towards weaker sections, so it is proper whenever the applicant is poor
- Objectivity, because he judged the single case on its own merits and individual facts
- Empathy in its truest form, since he felt the widow's distress and acted upon it
- Favouritism, because compassion must be applied equally to all in the same situation
Show answer
Answer: D. Compassion works through lawful, recorded discretion open to everyone in the same position. Helping one and refusing others in identical circumstances is favouritism.
-
3. To reduce tension between two communities in a town, which plan best meets Allport's conditions for contact?
- A joint committee with equal representation that works together to restore the town's water supply, backed by the district administration
- A competitive cricket match between the two communities, with a large prize for the winners and no joint work afterwards
- A public meeting in which leaders of one community lecture the other on how it should behave towards its neighbours
- Separate development programmes in each community's own area, run by different officers, so the two never meet
Show answer
Answer: A. Equal status, a common goal, cooperation and support of authorities are Allport's conditions. Competition, unequal status and separation do not meet them.
-
4. A manager believes that women 'cannot handle field postings' and therefore never sends women officers to the field. The belief and the act are, respectively:
- Prejudice and a stereotype
- Discrimination and prejudice
- A subjective norm and compliance
- A stereotype and discrimination
Show answer
Answer: D. The generalised belief about women is a stereotype (cognitive). Never posting women to the field because of it is discrimination (behavioural).
-
5. Which response to staff who mocked a citizen at a service counter is most likely to change attitudes in the long run, alongside proportionate disciplinary action?
- A one-line circular telling staff to be polite to citizens, issued by the department head
- Moving the citizen to a separate counter where he will not meet the staff who mocked him
- Publicly humiliating the staff in front of the citizens so that others learn the lesson
- Sensitisation sessions in which staff work with members of the community on equal terms
Show answer
Answer: D. Structured contact on equal terms addresses the prejudice itself. A circular may bring outward compliance only, a separate counter is itself discrimination, and humiliation tends to provoke defensiveness.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.