- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Formation routes and the attitude-behaviour gap: case studies with planned behaviour
Name the formation route in a case, break a decision into attitude, subjective norm and perceived control, choose the matching intervention, and explain why what people say differs from what they do.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Many case studies describe a public programme that people support in words but do not use. Others ask how a particular attitude was learned. Both can be answered systematically: name the formation route, then diagnose the step from attitude to action with the theory of planned behaviour.
Telling the formation routes apart
| Route | Key sign in the case | Common confusion |
|---|---|---|
| Classical conditioning | An object is repeatedly paired with a feeling until the object alone arouses it | Mistaken for operant: here nothing follows the person's own action |
| Operant conditioning | The person's own expression of the attitude is rewarded or punished | Mistaken for observational: here the person, not a model, gets the consequence |
| Observational learning | The person watches a model, often one who is rewarded | Mistaken for socialisation: observation is a mechanism, socialisation the broad process |
| Socialisation | Values passed on by family, school, peers, religion, media, workplace | Too general when a case clearly names a specific mechanism |
| Direct experience | Personal contact with the object | Gives strong, accessible attitudes; often the answer for 'why is this attitude so firm?' |
Diagnosing the gap with planned behaviour
When people approve of an action but do not do it, find the weak element and match the intervention to it. Remember the trap: in this model the attitude is towards the behaviour, not the object in general, and the subjective norm is what the person thinks important others expect, not the person's own moral view.
| Weak element | How it shows in a case | Matching intervention |
|---|---|---|
| Attitude towards the behaviour | 'I don't see the point' | Information, demonstration, visible benefits |
| Subjective norm | 'No one in my family or village does this' | Involve respected local figures; show what others are actually doing |
| Perceived behavioural control | 'I can't: too far, too costly, too complicated' | Remove barriers: simplify forms, bring the service closer, train |
Worked example 1: built but not used
Case: in the fictional village of Rampur Khurd, household toilets were built under a scheme, yet many families still go to the fields. A survey finds three kinds of reasons: some elders say the open field is cleaner than having a toilet near the house; many say 'our elders have always gone outside'; others say there is no water to keep the toilet clean. Step 1: 'the field is cleaner' is an unfavourable attitude towards the behaviour. Step 2: 'our elders have always gone outside' is the subjective norm. Step 3: 'no water' is low perceived control. Step 4: prescribe for each: health demonstrations for the attitude; involve respected elders, women's groups and children for the norm; a water source for control. Step 5: note a limit of the theory: long habits run almost automatically, so cues and follow-up visits are needed to break them, not only intentions.
Worked example 2: saying versus doing
Case: most staff in a fictional office say in a questionnaire that they support punctuality, yet late arrival continues. Step 1, compatibility: the questionnaire asked about punctuality in general, not about 'reaching by 9.30 every day this month', so a general attitude is a weak predictor of a specific act. Step 2, norm: if the senior staff come late, the real subjective norm favours lateness. Step 3, control: the only bus may arrive at 9.45, so control is low. Step 4, strength: a vague, rarely considered attitude is weakly held. Link: this is LaPiere's lesson in an office setting; a questionnaire answer is not a forecast of conduct.
Diagnosis rule: when approval does not become action, check three things in order: does the person value this act, do the people around them expect it, and can they actually do it? Fix the weakest of the three.
Key takeaways: in classical conditioning nothing follows the person's own act; in operant conditioning the person's own act is rewarded or punished; in observational learning a model is rewarded; the planned behaviour model locates the gap in attitude, norm or control; habits and general questions weaken the link between attitude and behaviour.
Check your understanding
-
1. A child is praised by her teacher every time she speaks up for classmates who are teased, and she develops a strong attitude against bullying. The main formation route is:
- Classical conditioning
- Operant conditioning
- Observational learning
- Mere exposure
Show answer
Answer: B. Her own expression of the attitude is followed by a reward (praise), which strengthens it. That is operant conditioning; she is not watching a model.
-
2. Villagers support a pension scheme but few apply, saying the office is far away and the forms are too complicated. The theory of planned behaviour suggests the best first step is to:
- Run advertisements explaining why pensions are good
- Bring application help to the village and simplify the forms
- Ask religious leaders to tell people that applying is expected
- Fine those who do not apply
Show answer
Answer: B. Attitude is already favourable; what is weak is perceived behavioural control (distance and complexity). Removing these barriers targets the weak element.
-
3. In the theory of planned behaviour, the subjective norm refers to:
- The person's own moral view of the act and its likely results
- What the person believes important others expect them to do
- The laws and rules that officially govern the act in question
- How easy the person thinks the act will be to carry out
Show answer
Answer: B. The subjective norm is perceived social pressure from people who matter to the person. Ease of action is perceived control; one's own evaluation is the attitude.
-
4. A survey shows that residents strongly value a clean environment, yet they do not segregate household waste. The most likely explanation using the principle of compatibility is that:
- A general attitude to the environment is a weak predictor of a specific daily act like segregating waste
- Residents were deliberately lying in the survey about how much they value a clean environment
- Attitudes never affect behaviour, so the survey result has no bearing on what residents do
- Segregating waste is a value-expressive function, which attitude theory says always predicts action
Show answer
Answer: A. Attitudes predict best when measured at the same level of specificity as the behaviour. A broad environmental attitude does not translate reliably into one specific act.
-
5. Young trainees in a district office start speaking rudely to visitors after watching a senior officer do so and seeing him get quick results without any reprimand. The process is:
- Observational learning
- Classical conditioning
- Cognitive dissonance
- Internalisation
Show answer
Answer: A. The trainees watch a model whose behaviour is rewarded (quick results, no reprimand) and copy it. This is Bandura's observational learning.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.