• Foundation
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

A step-by-step method for resolving dilemmas

Apply a seven-step method to resolve ethical dilemmas, using quick tests such as the publicity test, the golden rule and Gandhi's talisman, and look for a creative third option.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Knowing theories is not enough when a decision is needed. A clear method stops you from jumping to conclusions and helps you explain your reasoning. This lesson gives a seven-step method and a set of quick tests you can use in exams and in life.

The seven steps

  1. Get the facts. What exactly happened? What is known and what is assumed?
  2. Identify stakeholders. Who is affected, and how much? Who is most vulnerable?
  3. Name the values in conflict. Use Kidder's patterns where they fit.
  4. Check law and rules. What does the law require or forbid? Law sets the outer limit.
  5. List options, including a creative 'third way' that partly honours both values.
  6. Test the options with the theories and quick tests below.
  7. Decide, act and reflect. Choose, explain the reasons, act, and learn from the outcome.

Quick tests

Quick tests for options
TestQuestion
Publicity (newspaper) testWould I be comfortable if my decision and my reasons were reported on the front page?
Golden ruleWould I accept this decision if I were in the other person's place?
UniversalityWhat if everyone in my position did this?
Gandhi's talismanWill this step help the poorest and weakest person affected?
Mirror testCan I respect myself after doing this?

The third way

Kidder encouraged looking for a 'trilemma' option: a third path that avoids the forced choice. Many apparent dilemmas soften once you ask whether the two values can be partly satisfied together, whether timing can change, or whether someone else can help.

Worked example 1: the nurse's promise

Facts: a patient has stopped his medicines, made the nurse promise not to tell his family, and is getting worse. Stakeholders: patient (most affected), daughter, nurse, doctor. Values: promise and confidentiality versus preventing harm and honesty. Law: medical confidentiality rules generally allow disclosure to prevent serious harm, and the doctor must be informed in any case. Options: (a) keep silent; (b) tell the daughter directly; (c) third way: inform the doctor, speak to the patient again, explain the danger, and encourage him to tell his daughter himself, with the nurse present. Tests: (c) passes the publicity test and the golden rule. Decision: (c), with (b) as a fallback if his life is at immediate risk.

Worked example 2: the delayed transfer

Facts: an honest, efficient tahsildar is told to delay a transfer order for a colleague whose child has board exams next month; the rules require the order to be issued now. Values: rule-following versus compassion. Options: (a) issue at once; (b) quietly hold it; (c) issue the order but request, through proper channels, that joining be deferred until after the exams, which the competent authority can permit. Option (c) honours both values, uses legitimate procedure, and passes the publicity test.

Facts, stakeholders, values, law, options, tests, decision: and always look for the third way before accepting a forced choice.

Key takeaways

  • Use the seven steps in order; they prevent hasty choices.
  • Law sets the outer limit; ethics works within and sometimes beyond it.
  • Quick tests (publicity, golden rule, universality, talisman, mirror) check options fast.
  • The best answer is often a third way that partly honours both values.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which step should come first when resolving a dilemma?

    1. Choosing the most popular option
    2. Getting the facts
    3. Testing the options
    4. Reflecting on the outcome
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Decisions built on wrong or assumed facts go wrong. Facts come first.

  2. 2. The question 'Would I be comfortable if my decision and reasons appeared on the front page?' is the:

    1. golden rule
    2. mirror test
    3. publicity test
    4. universality test
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The publicity or newspaper test checks whether a decision can withstand public scrutiny.

  3. 3. In the nurse's case, which option is the 'third way'?

    1. Keep silent forever and let the patient decide what his daughter should know
    2. Tell the daughter at once without speaking to the patient or the doctor first
    3. Leave the job rather than take a decision on the patient's privacy and care
    4. Inform the doctor and encourage the patient to tell his daughter himself
    Show answer

    Answer: D. It respects the patient's autonomy as far as possible while preventing harm.

  4. 4. Gandhi's talisman asks a decision-maker to:

    1. consider whether the step will help the poorest and weakest person affected
    2. choose the option that most pleases superiors and keeps the department secure
    3. follow tradition and the practice of earlier officers in the office
    4. avoid any decision until the situation has become clear to all
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The talisman focuses attention on the poorest and weakest.

  5. 5. What role does law play in the seven-step method?

    1. It is irrelevant to ethics, which depends only on conscience and values
    2. It sets the outer limit within which ethical options are considered
    3. It always gives the full answer, so no further ethical reasoning is needed
    4. It should be ignored if one feels strongly that the law is unfair to people
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Law marks boundaries; ethics guides choices within and sometimes beyond them.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Classic dilemmas explained

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery