• Foundation
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Classic dilemmas explained

Understand five classic dilemmas, the Heinz dilemma, the trolley problem, Arjuna at Kurukshetra, Antigone, and Sartre's student, and the lesson each teaches about moral choice.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Some dilemmas have become famous because they capture a problem in its purest form. Examiners often refer to them, and using them accurately adds depth to answers. This lesson explains five, what each is about, and the lesson it teaches.

1. The Heinz dilemma

Used by the psychologist Lawrence Kohlberg to study moral reasoning: a man named Heinz cannot afford a drug that could save his dying wife, because the chemist who discovered it charges far more than it costs to make and will not reduce the price. Heinz steals the drug. Should he have? Kohlberg was interested less in the answer than in the reason given, which reveals the stage of moral development. Lesson: the reasons behind a choice matter, not only the choice.

2. The trolley problem

Introduced by the philosopher Philippa Foot in 1967 and developed by Judith Jarvis Thomson: a runaway trolley will kill five people unless it is diverted to a side track, where it will kill one. Most people think diverting is permissible. In Thomson's variant, the only way to stop the trolley is to push a large man off a footbridge into its path; most people think this is wrong, though the numbers are the same. Lesson: outcomes are not everything; how harm is caused, and whether a person is used as a means, also matters.

3. Arjuna at Kurukshetra

In the Bhagavad Gita, the warrior Arjuna, facing his own relatives and teachers across the battlefield, loses the will to fight. Krishna counsels him to perform his duty as a warrior (his svadharma) without attachment to the fruits of action (nishkama karma). Lesson: duty performed with a detached, unselfish mind; a classic Indian treatment of the conflict between personal feeling and role-based duty.

4. Antigone

In Sophocles' tragedy, Antigone buries her brother Polynices against the decree of King Creon, who had forbidden his burial as a traitor. She appeals to a higher, unwritten law of the gods and of family duty. Lesson: the conflict between the law of the state and the demands of conscience or a higher law, still central to debates on civil disobedience.

5. Sartre's student

In his lecture Existentialism is a Humanism, Jean-Paul Sartre describes a young man during the Second World War torn between staying to care for his lonely mother and leaving to join the Free French forces. Sartre argued that no ethical doctrine could settle it for him; he had to choose, and in choosing, take full responsibility for who he became. Lesson: some dilemmas cannot be resolved by formula; responsibility for the choice remains with the chooser.

Five classic dilemmas at a glance
DilemmaCore conflictLesson
HeinzLaw and property versus lifeReasons reveal moral maturity
TrolleyNumbers saved versus how harm is doneOutcomes are not everything
ArjunaPersonal feeling versus role dutyAct on duty without selfish attachment
AntigoneState law versus conscience and family dutyLimits of obedience
Sartre's studentTwo duties with no formula to chooseWe remain responsible for our choices

Use classic dilemmas to illuminate a point, describe them accurately, and never invent their details or quotations.

Key takeaways

  • Heinz (Kohlberg): reasons matter.
  • Trolley (Foot, Thomson): means as well as outcomes matter.
  • Arjuna (Gita): duty without attachment to results.
  • Antigone (Sophocles): conscience against state law.
  • Sartre's student: responsibility when no formula decides.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The Heinz dilemma was used by Kohlberg mainly to study:

    1. whether stealing is legal in some cases of need
    2. the reasons people give, which reveal their stage of moral development
    3. the price of medicines in different countries
    4. the trolley problem and the doctrine of double effect
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Kohlberg focused on the reasoning behind the answer, not the answer itself.

  2. 2. Who first introduced the trolley problem in 1967?

    1. Philippa Foot
    2. Immanuel Kant
    3. Lawrence Kohlberg
    4. Jean-Paul Sartre
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Philippa Foot introduced the case in 1967; Judith Jarvis Thomson developed variants including the footbridge case.

  3. 3. Why do many people judge the footbridge case differently from the side-track case, though the numbers are the same?

    1. Because five lives matter less when they are on a bridge than on the side-track
    2. Because trolleys cannot be stopped by pushing a person in front of them in any case
    3. Because pushing the man uses him as a means to stop the trolley, which seems a different kind of act
    4. Because the law forbids diverting trolleys onto a side-track, but allows a push from a bridge
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The footbridge case involves directly using a person as a means, which most people see as morally different.

  4. 4. Krishna's counsel to Arjuna in the Bhagavad Gita emphasises:

    1. abandoning one's duty when it is painful or conflicts with family
    2. acting only for reward and the praise of others
    3. avoiding all action in the world and its duties
    4. performing one's duty without attachment to the fruits of action
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Nishkama karma means acting according to duty without selfish attachment to results.

  5. 5. Antigone's dilemma is most closely about:

    1. state law versus conscience and a higher duty
    2. short term versus long term benefit to the citizens
    3. efficiency versus equity in the use of public funds
    4. promise-keeping versus profit in a business matter
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Antigone defies Creon's decree to honour what she sees as a higher law of family and the gods.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery