- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
What an ethical dilemma is
Define an ethical dilemma, tell it apart from a moral temptation, and identify the conflicting duties or values in simple everyday and public-service situations.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Most of us know what we ought to do most of the time. The hard moments are those in which two things we ought to do cannot both be done. Those moments are ethical dilemmas. Learning to recognise them clearly is the first step in handling them well, and it is the foundation of every case study in ethics papers.
The definition
An ethical dilemma is a situation in which a person must choose between two or more courses of action, each supported by a genuine moral reason, where acting on one means failing the other. Whatever is chosen, something of moral value is lost. Three features mark a true dilemma:
- Two or more genuine obligations or values are in play, such as honesty and kindness.
- They cannot all be fully satisfied in the situation.
- Each option carries a moral cost, so the choice is hard even for a good person.
Dilemma or temptation?
The writer and ethicist Rushworth Kidder drew a helpful line between right versus wrong and right versus right. A choice between taking a bribe and refusing it is not a dilemma; it is a moral temptation, because one option is simply wrong even if it is attractive. A real dilemma is right versus right: both options are defensible, and the difficulty is deciding which right should prevail here.
| Situation | Type | Why |
|---|---|---|
| A clerk is offered money to move a file out of turn | Temptation (right versus wrong) | Taking the money is wrong; only self-interest pulls the other way |
| A doctor must decide whether to tell a frightened patient the full prognosis today | Dilemma (right versus right) | Honesty and compassion both matter |
| An officer is asked to falsify an attendance register | Temptation | Falsifying is wrong; pressure does not make it right |
| A teacher must decide whether to report a good student's first act of copying or to counsel him privately | Dilemma | Fairness to others and mercy to the student both matter |
Worked example 1
Situation: Priya, a nurse, promised a patient she would not tell his family that he had stopped taking his medicines. Now his condition is getting worse, and his daughter asks her directly whether he is taking them. Step 1: list the values. Keeping a promise and respecting the patient's confidentiality on one side; preventing harm to the patient and honesty to the daughter on the other. Step 2: can both be satisfied? Not fully. Step 3: each option has a cost. Conclusion: this is a genuine dilemma. (A possible way forward, explored later in the course, is to speak to the patient first and persuade him to tell his family himself.)
Worked example 2
Situation: Ramesh, a junior engineer, is told by a contractor that he will 'take care of him' if a weak foundation is passed. Step 1: values. Integrity and public safety on one side; on the other side, only personal gain. Step 2: there is no genuine moral reason supporting acceptance. Conclusion: this is a temptation, not a dilemma. The right action is clear even if it is hard: refuse and report.
Why the distinction matters
Calling a temptation a 'dilemma' is a common excuse: it makes wrongdoing sound like a difficult judgement. Calling a true dilemma a simple case of right and wrong leads to harsh, careless decisions. Getting the label right shapes the whole answer.
A dilemma is right versus right; a temptation is right versus wrong. Name the values on each side before you decide which you face.
Key takeaways
- An ethical dilemma involves genuine obligations that cannot all be met.
- Kidder's distinction: right versus right (dilemma) and right versus wrong (temptation).
- List the values on each side to classify the situation correctly.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which situation is a genuine ethical dilemma rather than a temptation?
- Deciding whether to accept a bribe offered to clear a contractor's pending bill without the usual checks
- Deciding whether to tell a grieving friend a painful truth now or later, when both honesty and kindness matter
- Deciding whether to falsify a bill so that a friend's company can be paid earlier than the rules allow
- Deciding whether to steal office stationery and a few small items for use by one's family at home
Show answer
Answer: B. Only telling a grieving friend a painful truth now or later involves two genuine values, honesty and compassion. The others are right versus wrong.
-
2. Who distinguished 'right versus right' choices from 'right versus wrong' choices?
- Rushworth Kidder
- Jeremy Bentham
- Thomas Hobbes
- Karl Marx
Show answer
Answer: A. Rushworth Kidder used this distinction to separate dilemmas from moral temptations.
-
3. Which is NOT a feature of a true ethical dilemma?
- Two or more genuine obligations are in play
- They cannot all be satisfied
- Each option has a moral cost
- One option is supported only by personal gain
Show answer
Answer: D. If one option is supported only by self-interest, it is a temptation, not a dilemma.
-
4. A junior engineer is offered favours to pass a weak foundation. This is best described as:
- a dilemma between loyalty and honesty
- a temptation, where the right action is clear
- a conflict of two duties
- a case of justice versus mercy
Show answer
Answer: B. No genuine moral reason supports passing the foundation. It is a right-versus-wrong temptation.
-
5. Why is it important not to call a temptation a dilemma?
- Because dilemmas are illegal and officers must never discuss them in an answer
- Because temptations are always harmless and need no ethical reasoning from an officer
- Because doing so can make wrongdoing sound like a hard judgement and serve as an excuse
- Because dilemmas never occur in public service, where the rules give every answer
Show answer
Answer: C. Mislabelling a temptation as a dilemma disguises a wrong choice as a legitimate difficulty.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.