- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Four common patterns of dilemmas
Recognise Kidder's four patterns of right-versus-right dilemmas, truth versus loyalty, individual versus community, short term versus long term, and justice versus mercy, in personal and public-service settings.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Dilemmas come in endless variety, but many of them follow a few repeating patterns. Rushworth Kidder identified four that cover most cases. Learning them helps you name the conflict quickly, which is the first thing a good case-study answer does.
The four patterns
| Pattern | The conflict | Everyday example | Public-service example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Truth versus loyalty | Honesty and transparency against faithfulness to a person or group | Telling a teacher that your friend cheated | Reporting a respected senior's irregularity |
| Individual versus community | The good of one person against the good of the many | Lending your only scooter to a neighbour when your family needs it | Acquiring one farmer's land for a road that serves thousands |
| Short term versus long term | Present needs against future needs | Spending savings on a festival or keeping them for education | Giving immediate cash relief or investing in long-term livelihood |
| Justice versus mercy | Fairness and rules against compassion and forgiveness | Punishing a child equally for a first and a tenth mistake | Penalising a poor vendor strictly for an encroachment |
Dilemmas special to public service
Public servants face these patterns in particular forms. Common examples include: law versus conscience (a lawful order that seems unjust), efficiency versus equity (fastest delivery versus reaching the most vulnerable), confidentiality versus transparency (official secrets versus the public's right to know), loyalty to superiors versus duty to the public, and personal values versus professional duty (a religious belief against a lawful duty to serve everyone).
Worked example 1
Situation: Sunita, a block officer, finds that her driver, a poor man who has served loyally for years, has been filling extra fuel and selling it. Pattern: justice versus mercy (rules require action; compassion pulls towards leniency), and also truth versus loyalty. Naming both patterns helps her see the full picture. A balanced response might report the matter as the rules require while speaking up for a proportionate penalty and helping the driver understand the consequences, rather than covering it up.
Worked example 2
Situation: A district collector must decide whether to spend a limited budget on an immediate food distribution in a drought-hit area or on repairing irrigation channels that would protect against future droughts. Pattern: short term versus long term. Neither choice is wrong. Naming the pattern prompts the obvious next question: can both be partly met, for example through food-for-work on the irrigation channels?
Naming the pattern in an answer
Begin your analysis by stating the pattern in one line: 'This case presents a conflict between truth and loyalty, and between justice and mercy.' It shows the examiner that you have seen the core of the problem before discussing options. Be careful not to force a pattern onto a temptation: if one side is supported only by self-interest or by pressure to break a rule, say so plainly instead of dressing it up as a dilemma.
Truth versus loyalty, individual versus community, short term versus long term, justice versus mercy: name the pattern before you solve it.
Key takeaways
- Kidder's four patterns cover most right-versus-right dilemmas.
- Public service adds forms such as law versus conscience and efficiency versus equity.
- A case may involve more than one pattern; name each.
- Naming the pattern often points to a creative middle option.
Check your understanding
-
1. A villager's land is needed for a highway that will benefit a whole district. Which pattern is this?
- Truth versus loyalty
- Justice versus mercy
- Individual versus community
- Short term versus long term
Show answer
Answer: C. The good of one landowner conflicts with the good of the many who will use the road.
-
2. An officer must decide whether to report his mentor's irregularity. Which pattern is most central?
- Truth versus loyalty
- Short term versus long term
- Individual versus community
- Efficiency versus equity
Show answer
Answer: A. Honesty to the institution conflicts with loyalty to a person.
-
3. Choosing between immediate cash relief and long-term livelihood investment is mainly:
- justice versus mercy to the poor
- truth versus loyalty to friends
- law versus conscience of the officer
- short term versus long term
Show answer
Answer: D. Present needs compete with future benefits.
-
4. A traffic officer must decide whether to fine a poor first-time offender the full amount or let him off with a warning. Which pattern?
- Individual versus community
- Justice versus mercy
- Truth versus loyalty
- Confidentiality versus transparency
Show answer
Answer: B. The rule calls for a fine (justice), compassion suggests leniency (mercy).
-
5. Why is naming the pattern useful at the start of a case-study answer?
- It replaces the need to suggest options and reasons for a final decision
- It shows the core conflict and often points to a creative middle option
- It is required by law in every case study answer written for the exam
- It proves that one option is wrong and the other option is right in the case
Show answer
Answer: B. Identifying the conflict focuses the answer and helps generate options that partly satisfy both sides.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.