• Foundation
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Ethical theories as tools for dilemmas

Use the main ethical theories, consequentialism, duty ethics, virtue ethics, care ethics and justice as fairness, as lenses to analyse a dilemma and see what each one highlights.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Ethical theories are not just names to memorise. Each is a lens that brings some features of a situation into focus. Looking through several lenses at the same dilemma helps you see it fully and justify your choice. This lesson introduces five lenses in plain language.

Five lenses

Five ethical lenses
LensKey thinkersCentral questionStrengthWeakness
Consequentialism (utilitarianism)Jeremy Bentham, John Stuart MillWhich option produces the best overall outcome for everyone affected?Takes results and welfare seriouslyMay sacrifice individuals for the majority
Duty ethics (deontology)Immanuel KantWhat do my duties require, regardless of outcome? Could my rule be a universal law? Am I treating people as ends?Protects rights and dignityRigid when duties conflict
Virtue ethicsAristotleWhat would a person of good character, with practical wisdom, do here?Focuses on character and judgementGives less precise guidance
Care ethicsCarol Gilligan, Nel NoddingsWhat response best maintains relationships and meets the needs of those who depend on me?Attends to vulnerability and contextMay favour those close to us
Justice as fairnessJohn RawlsWhat would I choose behind a veil of ignorance, not knowing my position?Protects the least advantagedAbstract in fast decisions

Applying the lenses: one dilemma

Situation: Anil, a school headmaster, has one scholarship left. Two students qualify. Meena scored slightly higher; Raju scored slightly lower but his father died last month and he may drop out without help.

  • Consequences: giving it to Raju may keep a student in school who would otherwise leave; Meena may manage without it. Outcome favours Raju, if the facts are right.
  • Duty: if the published rule is 'highest score wins', fairness and keeping one's word to all applicants favour Meena. Changing rules after applications distorts fairness.
  • Virtue: a wise headmaster seeks a response that is both just and compassionate: perhaps give the scholarship by the rule and seek another source of help for Raju.
  • Care: attention to Raju's vulnerability is pressing; the headmaster's relationship with both students matters.
  • Justice as fairness: behind the veil, one would want rules followed and also some safety net for students in sudden crisis; this suggests the scheme itself should include a hardship clause.

Notice how the lenses together produce a better answer than any one alone: follow the published rule (Meena), actively arrange other support for Raju, and recommend a hardship provision for the future.

A second short example

A district officer finds that announcing a disease outbreak early may cause panic. Consequences ask about the overall harm of panic versus delay; duty asks about the public's right to know and the officer's duty of honesty; virtue asks what courage and prudence require; care asks how to protect the vulnerable; justice asks whether the least advantaged would be harmed more by silence. Most lenses point to timely, honest, carefully communicated disclosure.

Look through several lenses: outcomes, duties, character, care and fairness. Where they agree, act with confidence; where they differ, look for a response that honours the most.

Key takeaways

  • Bentham and Mill: judge by consequences for all affected.
  • Kant: act on duties that could be universal, and treat persons as ends.
  • Aristotle: ask what a person of practical wisdom would do.
  • Gilligan and Noddings: attend to care, relationships and vulnerability.
  • Rawls: choose as if behind a veil of ignorance.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which lens asks 'Which option produces the best overall outcome for everyone affected?'

    1. Virtue ethics
    2. Consequentialism
    3. Care ethics
    4. Duty ethics
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Consequentialism, as developed by Bentham and Mill, judges actions by their outcomes for all affected.

  2. 2. Kant's ethics would most strongly object to:

    1. keeping a promise made to all applicants
    2. treating a person merely as a means to an end
    3. following a published rule
    4. telling the truth
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Treating humanity always as an end and never merely as a means is a central formulation of Kant's categorical imperative.

  3. 3. Which thinkers are associated with care ethics?

    1. Carol Gilligan and Nel Noddings
    2. Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill
    3. Plato and Aristotle, writing in ancient Greece
    4. Thomas Hobbes and John Locke, on the state
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Gilligan's work on moral development and Noddings's work on caring are foundational to care ethics.

  4. 4. Rawls's veil of ignorance asks decision-makers to choose principles:

    1. knowing exactly their own position in society and their own wealth
    2. that maximise their own benefit once the society is formed
    3. based only on tradition and the customs of their own community
    4. without knowing what position they will occupy in society
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Not knowing one's own position encourages fair principles that protect the least advantaged.

  5. 5. In the scholarship case, what does combining the lenses suggest?

    1. Ignore the published rule and give the scholarship to Raju, out of sympathy for his hardship
    2. Follow the published rule, find other support for Raju, and recommend a hardship clause for the future
    3. Give nothing to either student, since the rule and the hardship cannot be reconciled
    4. Split the scholarship between the two students without telling anyone about the rule
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The combined answer honours fairness, compassion and long-term reform together.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery