- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Ethical theories as tools for dilemmas
Use the main ethical theories, consequentialism, duty ethics, virtue ethics, care ethics and justice as fairness, as lenses to analyse a dilemma and see what each one highlights.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Ethical theories are not just names to memorise. Each is a lens that brings some features of a situation into focus. Looking through several lenses at the same dilemma helps you see it fully and justify your choice. This lesson introduces five lenses in plain language.
Five lenses
| Lens | Key thinkers | Central question | Strength | Weakness |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Consequentialism (utilitarianism) | Jeremy Bentham, John Stuart Mill | Which option produces the best overall outcome for everyone affected? | Takes results and welfare seriously | May sacrifice individuals for the majority |
| Duty ethics (deontology) | Immanuel Kant | What do my duties require, regardless of outcome? Could my rule be a universal law? Am I treating people as ends? | Protects rights and dignity | Rigid when duties conflict |
| Virtue ethics | Aristotle | What would a person of good character, with practical wisdom, do here? | Focuses on character and judgement | Gives less precise guidance |
| Care ethics | Carol Gilligan, Nel Noddings | What response best maintains relationships and meets the needs of those who depend on me? | Attends to vulnerability and context | May favour those close to us |
| Justice as fairness | John Rawls | What would I choose behind a veil of ignorance, not knowing my position? | Protects the least advantaged | Abstract in fast decisions |
Applying the lenses: one dilemma
Situation: Anil, a school headmaster, has one scholarship left. Two students qualify. Meena scored slightly higher; Raju scored slightly lower but his father died last month and he may drop out without help.
- Consequences: giving it to Raju may keep a student in school who would otherwise leave; Meena may manage without it. Outcome favours Raju, if the facts are right.
- Duty: if the published rule is 'highest score wins', fairness and keeping one's word to all applicants favour Meena. Changing rules after applications distorts fairness.
- Virtue: a wise headmaster seeks a response that is both just and compassionate: perhaps give the scholarship by the rule and seek another source of help for Raju.
- Care: attention to Raju's vulnerability is pressing; the headmaster's relationship with both students matters.
- Justice as fairness: behind the veil, one would want rules followed and also some safety net for students in sudden crisis; this suggests the scheme itself should include a hardship clause.
Notice how the lenses together produce a better answer than any one alone: follow the published rule (Meena), actively arrange other support for Raju, and recommend a hardship provision for the future.
A second short example
A district officer finds that announcing a disease outbreak early may cause panic. Consequences ask about the overall harm of panic versus delay; duty asks about the public's right to know and the officer's duty of honesty; virtue asks what courage and prudence require; care asks how to protect the vulnerable; justice asks whether the least advantaged would be harmed more by silence. Most lenses point to timely, honest, carefully communicated disclosure.
Look through several lenses: outcomes, duties, character, care and fairness. Where they agree, act with confidence; where they differ, look for a response that honours the most.
Key takeaways
- Bentham and Mill: judge by consequences for all affected.
- Kant: act on duties that could be universal, and treat persons as ends.
- Aristotle: ask what a person of practical wisdom would do.
- Gilligan and Noddings: attend to care, relationships and vulnerability.
- Rawls: choose as if behind a veil of ignorance.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which lens asks 'Which option produces the best overall outcome for everyone affected?'
- Virtue ethics
- Consequentialism
- Care ethics
- Duty ethics
Show answer
Answer: B. Consequentialism, as developed by Bentham and Mill, judges actions by their outcomes for all affected.
-
2. Kant's ethics would most strongly object to:
- keeping a promise made to all applicants
- treating a person merely as a means to an end
- following a published rule
- telling the truth
Show answer
Answer: B. Treating humanity always as an end and never merely as a means is a central formulation of Kant's categorical imperative.
-
3. Which thinkers are associated with care ethics?
- Carol Gilligan and Nel Noddings
- Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill
- Plato and Aristotle, writing in ancient Greece
- Thomas Hobbes and John Locke, on the state
Show answer
Answer: A. Gilligan's work on moral development and Noddings's work on caring are foundational to care ethics.
-
4. Rawls's veil of ignorance asks decision-makers to choose principles:
- knowing exactly their own position in society and their own wealth
- that maximise their own benefit once the society is formed
- based only on tradition and the customs of their own community
- without knowing what position they will occupy in society
Show answer
Answer: D. Not knowing one's own position encourages fair principles that protect the least advantaged.
-
5. In the scholarship case, what does combining the lenses suggest?
- Ignore the published rule and give the scholarship to Raju, out of sympathy for his hardship
- Follow the published rule, find other support for Raju, and recommend a hardship clause for the future
- Give nothing to either student, since the rule and the hardship cannot be reconciled
- Split the scholarship between the two students without telling anyone about the rule
Show answer
Answer: B. The combined answer honours fairness, compassion and long-term reform together.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.