Revision notes

Ethical Dilemmas: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

What an ethical dilemma is

Telling them apart
SituationTypeWhy
A clerk is offered money to move a file out of turnTemptation (right versus wrong)Taking the money is wrong; only self-interest pulls the other way
A doctor must decide whether to tell a frightened patient the full prognosis todayDilemma (right versus right)Honesty and compassion both matter
An officer is asked to falsify an attendance registerTemptationFalsifying is wrong; pressure does not make it right
A teacher must decide whether to report a good student's first act of copying or to counsel him privatelyDilemmaFairness to others and mercy to the student both matter

A dilemma is right versus right; a temptation is right versus wrong. Name the values on each side before you decide which you face.

  • An ethical dilemma involves genuine obligations that cannot all be met.
  • Kidder's distinction: right versus right (dilemma) and right versus wrong (temptation).
  • List the values on each side to classify the situation correctly.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Four common patterns of dilemmas

Kidder's four right-versus-right patterns
PatternThe conflictEveryday examplePublic-service example
Truth versus loyaltyHonesty and transparency against faithfulness to a person or groupTelling a teacher that your friend cheatedReporting a respected senior's irregularity
Individual versus communityThe good of one person against the good of the manyLending your only scooter to a neighbour when your family needs itAcquiring one farmer's land for a road that serves thousands
Short term versus long termPresent needs against future needsSpending savings on a festival or keeping them for educationGiving immediate cash relief or investing in long-term livelihood
Justice versus mercyFairness and rules against compassion and forgivenessPunishing a child equally for a first and a tenth mistakePenalising a poor vendor strictly for an encroachment

Truth versus loyalty, individual versus community, short term versus long term, justice versus mercy: name the pattern before you solve it.

  • Kidder's four patterns cover most right-versus-right dilemmas.
  • Public service adds forms such as law versus conscience and efficiency versus equity.
  • A case may involve more than one pattern; name each.
  • Naming the pattern often points to a creative middle option.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Ethical theories as tools for dilemmas

Five ethical lenses
LensKey thinkersCentral questionStrengthWeakness
Consequentialism (utilitarianism)Jeremy Bentham, John Stuart MillWhich option produces the best overall outcome for everyone affected?Takes results and welfare seriouslyMay sacrifice individuals for the majority
Duty ethics (deontology)Immanuel KantWhat do my duties require, regardless of outcome? Could my rule be a universal law? Am I treating people as ends?Protects rights and dignityRigid when duties conflict
Virtue ethicsAristotleWhat would a person of good character, with practical wisdom, do here?Focuses on character and judgementGives less precise guidance
Care ethicsCarol Gilligan, Nel NoddingsWhat response best maintains relationships and meets the needs of those who depend on me?Attends to vulnerability and contextMay favour those close to us
Justice as fairnessJohn RawlsWhat would I choose behind a veil of ignorance, not knowing my position?Protects the least advantagedAbstract in fast decisions

Look through several lenses: outcomes, duties, character, care and fairness. Where they agree, act with confidence; where they differ, look for a response that honours the most.

  • Bentham and Mill: judge by consequences for all affected.
  • Kant: act on duties that could be universal, and treat persons as ends.
  • Aristotle: ask what a person of practical wisdom would do.
  • Gilligan and Noddings: attend to care, relationships and vulnerability.
  • Rawls: choose as if behind a veil of ignorance.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

A step-by-step method for resolving dilemmas

Quick tests for options
TestQuestion
Publicity (newspaper) testWould I be comfortable if my decision and my reasons were reported on the front page?
Golden ruleWould I accept this decision if I were in the other person's place?
UniversalityWhat if everyone in my position did this?
Gandhi's talismanWill this step help the poorest and weakest person affected?
Mirror testCan I respect myself after doing this?

Facts, stakeholders, values, law, options, tests, decision: and always look for the third way before accepting a forced choice.

  • Use the seven steps in order; they prevent hasty choices.
  • Law sets the outer limit; ethics works within and sometimes beyond it.
  • Quick tests (publicity, golden rule, universality, talisman, mirror) check options fast.
  • The best answer is often a third way that partly honours both values.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Classic dilemmas explained

Five classic dilemmas at a glance
DilemmaCore conflictLesson
HeinzLaw and property versus lifeReasons reveal moral maturity
TrolleyNumbers saved versus how harm is doneOutcomes are not everything
ArjunaPersonal feeling versus role dutyAct on duty without selfish attachment
AntigoneState law versus conscience and family dutyLimits of obedience
Sartre's studentTwo duties with no formula to chooseWe remain responsible for our choices

Use classic dilemmas to illuminate a point, describe them accurately, and never invent their details or quotations.

  • Heinz (Kohlberg): reasons matter.
  • Trolley (Foot, Thomson): means as well as outcomes matter.
  • Arjuna (Gita): duty without attachment to results.
  • Antigone (Sophocles): conscience against state law.
  • Sartre's student: responsibility when no formula decides.
Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery