| Situation | Type | Why |
|---|---|---|
| A clerk is offered money to move a file out of turn | Temptation (right versus wrong) | Taking the money is wrong; only self-interest pulls the other way |
| A doctor must decide whether to tell a frightened patient the full prognosis today | Dilemma (right versus right) | Honesty and compassion both matter |
| An officer is asked to falsify an attendance register | Temptation | Falsifying is wrong; pressure does not make it right |
| A teacher must decide whether to report a good student's first act of copying or to counsel him privately | Dilemma | Fairness to others and mercy to the student both matter |
A dilemma is right versus right; a temptation is right versus wrong. Name the values on each side before you decide which you face.
- An ethical dilemma involves genuine obligations that cannot all be met.
- Kidder's distinction: right versus right (dilemma) and right versus wrong (temptation).
- List the values on each side to classify the situation correctly.