• Practice
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Anti-defection law and the Prime Minister's powers in Parliament

Practise the Tenth Schedule rules on defection that affect the stability of ministries and the Prime Minister's role in Parliament.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Political stability depends on who can sit and vote. The anti-defection law, added by the 52nd Amendment in 1985 as the Tenth Schedule, affects how ministries survive.

Key rules

  • A member is disqualified if he or she voluntarily gives up membership of the party on whose ticket elected.
  • Disqualification also follows if a member votes or abstains against the party whip without permission.
  • An independent member is disqualified if he or she joins a political party after election.
  • A nominated member is disqualified if he or she joins a party more than six months after taking a seat.
  • The decision rests with the presiding officer of the House, and is subject to judicial review.
  • The 91st Amendment (2003) removed the exemption for splits and left a merger of two-thirds of a legislature party as the exception.

Worked example 1: whip

Question: A member votes against the party whip on a bill without permission. What follows? Working: Such voting attracts disqualification under the Tenth Schedule. Answer: Disqualification as a member.

Worked example 2: who decides

Question: Who decides a disqualification petition? Working: The presiding officer, the Speaker in the Lok Sabha and the Chairman in the Rajya Sabha. Answer: The presiding officer.

Tenth Schedule, 52nd Amendment 1985; decided by the presiding officer; merger exception of two-thirds.

— Facts

Key takeaways: The anti-defection law supports stability of governments; the presiding officer decides.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The anti-defection law was added to the Constitution as the Tenth Schedule by

    1. the 42nd Amendment, 1976
    2. the 61st Amendment, 1988
    3. the 73rd Amendment, 1992
    4. the 52nd Amendment, 1985
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The 52nd Amendment (1985) inserted the Tenth Schedule.

  2. 2. An independent member joins a political party after his election. Under the Tenth Schedule he

    1. is disqualified
    2. stays a member, since independents are exempt
    3. is disqualified only if he joins within six months
    4. needs only the President's approval to stay
    Show answer

    Answer: A. An independent member who joins a political party after election is disqualified.

  3. 3. A nominated member joins a political party five months after taking his seat. Under the Tenth Schedule

    1. he is disqualified at once
    2. he is not disqualified, because he joined within six months
    3. he is disqualified only if he later votes against the whip
    4. his nomination is cancelled by the President
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A nominated member is disqualified only if he joins a party more than six months after taking his seat. Five months is within the limit.

  4. 4. Who decides whether a member is disqualified on the ground of defection?

    1. The President, on the advice of the Election Commission
    2. The Prime Minister
    3. The presiding officer of the House, subject to judicial review
    4. The Supreme Court in the first instance
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The Speaker or Chairman decides; the decision can be reviewed by the courts.

  5. 5. After the 91st Amendment, which situation still protects members from disqualification?

    1. A split by one-third of the legislature party
    2. Abstaining against the party whip without permission
    3. Voluntarily giving up membership of the party
    4. A merger agreed to by at least two-thirds of the legislature party
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The 91st Amendment removed the exemption for splits; the merger of two-thirds of a legislature party remains the exception.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery