- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Motions in the Lok Sabha: confidence, no-confidence and censure
Practise how the Council of Ministers is tested in the Lok Sabha and tell apart a confidence motion, a no-confidence motion, a censure motion and an adjournment motion.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The Constitution says in Article 75(3) that the Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the House of the People. The ways in which the House tests that responsibility are mostly matters of its rules and conventions, and examination questions like to confuse them. This lesson separates the four motions you must know.
How responsibility is enforced
A government survives only while it commands a majority in the Lok Sabha. The House can test this through motions and through votes on important business. The Rajya Sabha does not decide the fate of the government because the Council is not responsible to it, although its members may question ministers and debate policy.
| Motion | Purpose | Reasons stated? | House |
|---|---|---|---|
| Confidence motion | Government seeks proof that it still has majority support | Not applicable | Lok Sabha |
| No-confidence motion | Opposition says the Council has lost the House's confidence | No reasons need be given | Lok Sabha |
| Censure motion | Criticises specific policies or acts of the government or a minister | Reasons must be stated | Lok Sabha |
| Adjournment motion | Draws attention to an urgent matter of public importance | The matter is specified | Lok Sabha only |
Other tests of confidence
- Defeat of the government on a money bill or a vote on the budget is treated as loss of confidence.
- Defeat on a motion of thanks to the President's address is treated the same way.
- Defeat of a minor measure or an ordinary bill does not by itself force resignation unless the government treats it as a matter of confidence.
- A no-confidence motion may be moved against the whole Council of Ministers; it is not moved against a single minister.
Worked example 1: whom does a vote remove
Question: A no-confidence motion against the Council of Ministers is passed by the Lok Sabha. Who must resign? Working: Under collective responsibility the Council is responsible as one body. If the House withdraws confidence, the whole Council, headed by the Prime Minister, must go. A single minister does not resign alone. Answer: The entire Council of Ministers.
Worked example 2: choosing the right motion
Question: A member wants to criticise one policy of the government and must give reasons in the motion. Which motion is this? Working: A no-confidence motion needs no reasons. A censure motion must state reasons and is aimed at particular policies or acts. An adjournment motion is for an urgent matter, not for blame on a policy. Answer: A censure motion.
Worked example 3: a house-by-house check
Question: The Rajya Sabha rejects a bill that the Lok Sabha passed with a clear majority. Must the Council of Ministers resign? Working: The Council is responsible only to the Lok Sabha, and it keeps the confidence of that House. The disagreement is settled by the process for ordinary bills, not by resignation. Answer: No, the Council continues.
Council is responsible to the Lok Sabha only; no-confidence needs no reasons, censure must give reasons.
Key takeaways: Collective responsibility is to the Lok Sabha alone. A no-confidence motion removes a government without stating reasons, a censure motion states reasons about a policy, a confidence motion is moved by the government, and an adjournment motion is for urgent matters in the Lok Sabha only.
Check your understanding
-
1. To which House is the Council of Ministers collectively responsible?
- The Rajya Sabha
- Both Houses equally
- The Lok Sabha
- The Legislative Council
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 75(3) makes the Council collectively responsible to the House of the People, the Lok Sabha.
-
2. Unlike a censure motion, which motion against the Council of Ministers need not state its grounds?
- No-confidence motion
- Cut motion
- Motion of thanks
- Privilege motion
Show answer
Answer: A. A no-confidence motion needs no reasons, whereas a censure motion must state them.
-
3. What happens if a no-confidence motion against the Council of Ministers is carried in the Lok Sabha?
- Only the Prime Minister resigns
- The President dissolves the Rajya Sabha
- The Rajya Sabha reviews it
- The whole Council of Ministers resigns
Show answer
Answer: D. Collective responsibility means the entire Council, with the Prime Minister, must resign.
-
4. An adjournment motion is used to:
- Remove the Speaker from the chair
- Raise an urgent matter of public concern
- Amend a provision of the Constitution
- Pass the annual budget of the Union
Show answer
Answer: B. The adjournment motion draws attention to a definite urgent matter of public importance and may be used in the Lok Sabha only.
-
5. The Rajya Sabha defeats an ordinary bill passed by the Lok Sabha. The Council of Ministers:
- Is not required to resign on that ground
- Must seek the Rajya Sabha's vote of confidence
- Must resign at once
- Is dismissed by the Chairman
Show answer
Answer: A. The Council answers to the Lok Sabha only, so the Rajya Sabha's rejection of a bill does not force resignation.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.