• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

President, Prime Minister and Chief Minister: statement-type traps

Practise statement-type and comparison questions that mix up the Prime Minister with the President and the Chief Minister, and learn to check each statement against its Article.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Many questions give three or four statements about the Prime Minister and ask which are correct. The wrong ones usually swap a power between the Prime Minister, the President and the Chief Minister. The method is simple: attach each statement to an Article and check the office it names.

A comparison to keep in mind

Union and State offices side by side
PointUnionState
Nominal headPresident (Article 52)Governor (Article 153)
Real head of the executivePrime MinisterChief Minister
Council aids and advisesArticle 74Article 163
Appointment of the head of the CouncilArticle 75Article 164
Council responsible toLok SabhaLegislative Assembly

Statements that are usually false

  • The Prime Minister is directly elected by the people. (Wrong: appointed by the President, usually the leader of the majority.)
  • The Prime Minister must be a member of the Lok Sabha. (Wrong: either House is allowed.)
  • The Prime Minister has a fixed five-year term under the Constitution. (Wrong: no fixed term is set for the office.)
  • The Council of Ministers is responsible to the President alone. (Wrong: collectively to the Lok Sabha.)
  • The Rajya Sabha can force a government out by a no-confidence vote. (Wrong: only the Lok Sabha.)

Worked example 1: three statements

Question: (1) The Prime Minister is appointed by the President. (2) The Prime Minister must belong to the Lok Sabha. (3) The Prime Minister holds no fixed term. Which are correct? Working: Statement 1 is true under Article 75(1). Statement 2 is false because a member of the Rajya Sabha may be Prime Minister. Statement 3 is true because the Constitution fixes no term and the office lasts while the majority lasts. Answer: Statements 1 and 3 only.

Worked example 2: office to Article

Question: Match: (a) Council aids and advises the President, (b) Council aids and advises the Governor, (c) Prime Minister's duty to inform the President. Options: Articles 78, 163, 74. Working: (a) is Article 74 because it is the Union Council; (b) is Article 163 for the State; (c) is Article 78. Answer: a-74, b-163, c-78.

Worked example 3: who can speak

Question: A minister is a member of the Rajya Sabha. May this minister speak in the Lok Sabha and vote there? Working: Article 88 gives every minister the right to speak in and take part in the proceedings of either House, but a minister votes only in the House of which he or she is a member. Answer: May speak but not vote.

Reading the question stem

  • Underline the office in each statement: President, Prime Minister, Governor or Chief Minister. Swapped offices are the commonest trap.
  • Underline the House: Lok Sabha, Rajya Sabha or both. Collective responsibility is always to the Lok Sabha.
  • Look for absolute words such as always, only and never. A true constitutional statement rarely uses them.
  • Note that the Prime Minister advises the President on summoning and proroguing Parliament and on dissolving the Lok Sabha in practice, but the formal power stays with the President.

Check each statement against an Article and the office named: Union is 74-78, State is 163-167.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: Treat each statement separately, look for swapped offices, and remember that the Prime Minister is appointed, not directly elected, and holds office as long as the Lok Sabha majority lasts.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which Article governs the aid and advice given to the Governor by the State Council of Ministers?

    1. Article 163
    2. Article 75
    3. Article 74
    4. Article 78
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Article 163 provides for the Council of Ministers to aid and advise the Governor. Article 74 is the Union equivalent.

  2. 2. The Prime Minister of India is:

    1. Directly elected by all voters
    2. Elected by the Rajya Sabha alone
    3. Chosen by the Chief Justice
    4. Appointed by the President
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Under Article 75(1) the President appoints the Prime Minister, usually the leader who commands a Lok Sabha majority.

  3. 3. Which statement is correct?

    1. The Prime Minister must be a Lok Sabha member
    2. A Rajya Sabha member may be Prime Minister
    3. The Constitution fixes a five-year term for the Prime Minister
    4. The Council is responsible to the Rajya Sabha
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A member of either House may be Prime Minister. The others are false: no term is fixed and the Council answers to the Lok Sabha.

  4. 4. The Prime Minister's duty to furnish information to the President is in:

    1. Article 52
    2. Article 88
    3. Article 78
    4. Article 164
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Article 78 sets out the Prime Minister's duties towards the President. Article 88 concerns the rights of ministers in the Houses.

  5. 5. A Rajya Sabha member who is a Union minister can in the Lok Sabha:

    1. Speak and vote
    2. Speak but not vote
    3. Vote but not speak
    4. Neither speak nor vote
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Article 88 gives the right to speak and take part, but the right to vote only in the House of which the minister is a member.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery