- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Articles 74 to 78: advice, oaths, pay and the courts
Practise the finer provisions on advice to the President, reconsideration, oaths, the six-month rule, ministers' pay and the Rules of Business.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Basic questions ask who appoints the Prime Minister. Better questions ask what the Constitution says about the advice the Council gives, who fixes ministers' pay, and what happens to a minister who is not a member of Parliament. This lesson drills those finer provisions so that you can match each rule to its Article without hesitation.
The provisions to know
- Article 74(1): the Council of Ministers with the Prime Minister at the head aids and advises the President, who acts in accordance with that advice. The 44th Amendment (1978) added a proviso: the President may ask the Council to reconsider its advice once, but must act on the advice given after reconsideration.
- Article 74(2): the question what advice, if any, was tendered by ministers to the President cannot be inquired into by any court.
- Article 75(4): before a minister enters office, the President administers the oath of office and the oath of secrecy.
- Article 75(5): a minister who is not a member of either House for any period of six consecutive months ceases to be a minister at the end of that period.
- Article 75(6): the salaries and allowances of ministers are what Parliament fixes by law.
- Article 77: executive action of the Government of India is expressed to be taken in the name of the President, and the President makes rules for the more convenient transaction of business (the Rules of Business).
- Article 78: the Prime Minister's duty to communicate Council decisions and to furnish information to the President.
| Article | Subject | Memory hook |
|---|---|---|
| 74 | Council aids and advises the President | Advice, with one reconsideration |
| 75 | Appointment, oaths, responsibility, pay | Everything about ministers themselves |
| 77 | Conduct of business in the President's name | Orders issue in the President's name |
| 78 | Duties of the Prime Minister to the President | Communicate and inform |
Worked example 1: reconsideration
Question: The Council of Ministers advises the President on a matter. The President returns the advice for reconsideration and the Council repeats it unchanged. What must the President do? Working: The proviso to Article 74(1), added by the 44th Amendment, lets the President seek reconsideration only once. After the Council reconsiders and tenders advice, the President must act in accordance with it. Answer: The President is bound to act on the reconsidered advice.
Worked example 2: the six-month rule
Question: A person who is not a member of either House is sworn in as a minister on 10 January. By what date must the person become a member to continue? Working: Article 75(5) allows six consecutive months. Six months from 10 January ends on 10 July. If the person is elected or nominated to a House by then, the person continues; otherwise the person ceases to be a minister. Answer: On or before 10 July of the same year.
Worked example 3: who fixes pay
Question: Who determines the salary of Union ministers, and by what means? Working: Article 75(6) says it is such as Parliament may by law determine. The President and the Prime Minister do not fix it by order. Answer: Parliament, by law.
Article 74 advice (one reconsideration, then binding); 75 appointment, oath, six months, pay; 77 President's name; 78 Prime Minister informs the President.
Common traps
- The six months run for a minister who is not a member; it is not a limit on how long a member may serve.
- Reconsideration is allowed once; a President cannot keep returning the advice.
- Article 74(2) protects the content of the advice from court inquiry. It does not make the Council's actions immune from review.
- Article 77 concerns the form in which executive action is expressed; Article 78 is about the Prime Minister's duty to inform the President.
Key takeaways: Article 74 gives advice that the President must follow after at most one reconsideration; Article 75 covers oaths, the six-month rule and pay; Article 77 gives the President's name to executive action; Article 78 makes the Prime Minister the channel to the President.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which Amendment allowed the President to ask the Council of Ministers to reconsider its advice once?
- The 42nd Amendment
- The 44th Amendment
- The 52nd Amendment
- The 91st Amendment
Show answer
Answer: B. The proviso to Article 74(1) was added by the 44th Amendment (1978). The 52nd Amendment concerns defection and the 91st the size of the Council.
-
2. A person who is not a member of either House is made a minister. For how long may the person continue without becoming a member?
- Three consecutive months
- Twelve consecutive months
- Nine consecutive months
- Six consecutive months
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 75(5) allows six consecutive months, after which the person ceases to be a minister unless a member of a House.
-
3. Who fixes the salaries and allowances of the Union ministers?
- The Parliament by law
- The Prime Minister
- The President by order
- The Rajya Sabha Chairman
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 75(6) says the salaries and allowances are such as Parliament may by law determine.
-
4. Which Article says that executive action of the Government of India is expressed to be taken in the name of the President?
- Article 74
- Article 75
- Article 77
- Article 78
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 77 deals with the conduct of Government business and the form of executive action. Article 78 deals with the Prime Minister's duties to the President.
-
5. Which statement about Article 74(2) is correct?
- The Lok Sabha must approve the advice before it is given
- Courts must examine every item of advice tendered
- The President must publish all the advice received
- Courts cannot inquire what advice was given to the President
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 74(2) bars inquiry by any court into whether any advice was tendered and what it was. It does not require publication or prior approval.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.